Unfortunately, at this point this place is all hype and no substance. At 7pm on a Thursday we waited outside for 20 minutes without anyone opening the door to greet us. After a long wait and finally getting in, the two bartenders were overwhelmed and we only got one cocktail in an hour and 15 minutes. We closed out without getting a second cocktail and were hit with a bill for $23 drinks before tax+tip.
Cocktails were very good, but absolutely not worth the wait, crowding, and slow service. Go to any of the other cocktail bars with a similar ambiance and where you can chat with the bartenders.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 2
Jo aisen
It was my first time visiting a speakeasy, and Attaboy gave me a pretty great experience. Although we had to wait nearly two hours since they don’t take reservations, it was worth it. The experience is fun and unique — there’s no menu, so you can describe your drink using any words, and the bartender always surprises you with something amazing. There’s no dress code. Each drink we ordered this time was $23. No food is served here, so make sure to eat before you come!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jonathan Miller
Cool place with fantastic bar tenders
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angel zhong
One of the worst bar experiences I’ve ever had. After waiting on the waitlist, we were finally called in—only to be told to stand in a narrow hallway, drinking uncomfortably while people constantly walked past. It felt more like being punished than enjoying a night out. No seating, no space, and no reason to bring people in when the bar clearly isn’t ready—especially if you’re just a party of one or two. Regardless of how good the drinks might be, the most basic expectation of a bar is to provide a place to relax. This was a total disappointment and felt like a complete scam. Won’t be returning.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Maggie Liu
Drinks quality really depends on your bartenders skills. Some of them just not that good. Plus some of them seems dismissive
Nikariy Dominguez
I think the music selection can be better, but I really enjoyed the place, the drinks and the atmosphere were 🫶🏽🫶🏽
Atmosphere: 4
Dyan
We waited nearly 3 hours to get in.
Doorman (J N) gave us a 2 hours estimation so we bar hopped a bit before coming back. After 2 hours doorman told us it will be a “mystery” time for us to get a table. What does that even mean!? We waited another 30mins and then decided to cut our losses. At that same moment doorman called us and then we got in.
This is definitely not a great experience, and I believe they should be more transparent with their waitlist.
Drinks were creative and atmosphere was good. Doorman was also the server who picked up our orders but it took a while for our drinks. After our drinks, the doorman kind of rushed us out of the place.
Honestly I don’t think the drinks are worth it due to the doorman/server experience. Unless you can “somehow” get in without waiting then yea go for it. Otherwise just cut your losses early and find another place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
John Allie
Best cocktails in New York City. Controversial? Maybe. But I’ll stand by it.
From the nondescript door to the intimate, hidden vibe, Attaboy feels like stepping into a different world. The space is cozy, low-lit, and beautifully curated without trying too hard. Whoever’s managing the flow at the door — owner or manager — deserves a shoutout. They keep things moving without killing the vibe, and the result is a space that never feels overcrowded or chaotic.
And then… the cocktails. Chris behind the bar is the Da Vinci of drinks — tell him your mood and flavor preference and he’ll absolutely nail it. No menu, just trust.
Their take on the Undertaker is a must. Spirit-forward, complex, layered — a full-on flavor experience that deserves an award. The Fort Washington? Smoky, crisp, like a campfire in the New Jersey woods — one of the most unique drinks I’ve ever had.
If you’re into cocktails, go out of your way to come here. Even if there’s a wait, it’s worth it — and their sister bar next door is amazing too, so you’re covered either way.
A true gem. Can’t recommend it enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erik
Really poor and bad service. We got there behind only one other couple and waited in line. The hostess said she had to take our number. We waited close by she let the couple in and a bunch of other people left and she told us that we should go find another bar that we’re probably not going to get in. And then she proceeds to let people that showed up after us in. I guess our money is no good there. Poor service and rude hostess.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Harman Kaur
There was no seating but the drink more than made up for it. Strongest gin and tonic I’ve had in a long time. Definitely would go back with friends.
An unforgettable experience this iconic bar is a must-visit for any cocktail enthusiast. There’s no menu; instead, you’ll chat with the bartender, share your mood, and they’ll craft something just right for you. The bar’s founder actually invented the Penicillin, which happens to be my favorite drink don’t leave without trying one.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nighat Muzaffar
Absolutely amazing experience! There’s no set menu — instead, you simply tell them what you’re in the mood for. I love customizing some of my favorite cocktails by adding ingredients I enjoy and leaving out anything I don’t. The result? A personalized drink that’s perfect for me every time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Haidar Hachem
Was really looking forward to checking out the OG Attaboy seeing as how we spent our time at the Nashville Attaboy and it was absolutely phenomenal; that was not the case here. We walked in when a couple had been leaving and was greeted with an attitude by the hostess. Apparently you’re supposed to ring the doorbell and wait to be let in. She walked us to what she referred to as “standing room” but was literally just us standing at the bar. My wife went to the bathroom and said there were empty tables with no reservation notices or anything. The drinks were good and the bartenders were accommodating, but that’s where the good in this place ended. I wouldn’t come back for a drink here again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Rachel Arnold
Its a fun place and the bartender listens to what you're interested in ordering and makes that for you. And occasionally doesn't listen to you if the bartender thinks you'll like something (complimentary). Its a very specific cocktail experience and if you want something with a menu I would go somewhere else, if you want something tailored to your tastes, go here.
Unfortunately, at this point this place is all hype and no substance. At 7pm on a Thursday we waited outside for 20 minutes without anyone opening the door to greet us. After a long wait and finally getting in, the two bartenders were overwhelmed and we only got one cocktail in an hour and 15 minutes. We closed out without getting a second cocktail and were hit with a bill for $23 drinks before tax+tip.
Cocktails were very good, but absolutely not worth the wait, crowding, and slow service. Go to any of the other cocktail bars with a similar ambiance and where you can chat with the bartenders.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 2
It was my first time visiting a speakeasy, and Attaboy gave me a pretty great experience. Although we had to wait nearly two hours since they don’t take reservations, it was worth it. The experience is fun and unique — there’s no menu, so you can describe your drink using any words, and the bartender always surprises you with something amazing. There’s no dress code. Each drink we ordered this time was $23. No food is served here, so make sure to eat before you come!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Cool place with fantastic bar tenders
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the worst bar experiences I’ve ever had. After waiting on the waitlist, we were finally called in—only to be told to stand in a narrow hallway, drinking uncomfortably while people constantly walked past. It felt more like being punished than enjoying a night out. No seating, no space, and no reason to bring people in when the bar clearly isn’t ready—especially if you’re just a party of one or two. Regardless of how good the drinks might be, the most basic expectation of a bar is to provide a place to relax. This was a total disappointment and felt like a complete scam. Won’t be returning.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Drinks quality really depends on your bartenders skills. Some of them just not that good. Plus some of them seems dismissive
I think the music selection can be better, but I really enjoyed the place, the drinks and the atmosphere were 🫶🏽🫶🏽
Atmosphere: 4
We waited nearly 3 hours to get in.
Doorman (J N) gave us a 2 hours estimation so we bar hopped a bit before coming back. After 2 hours doorman told us it will be a “mystery” time for us to get a table. What does that even mean!? We waited another 30mins and then decided to cut our losses. At that same moment doorman called us and then we got in.
This is definitely not a great experience, and I believe they should be more transparent with their waitlist.
Drinks were creative and atmosphere was good. Doorman was also the server who picked up our orders but it took a while for our drinks. After our drinks, the doorman kind of rushed us out of the place.
Honestly I don’t think the drinks are worth it due to the doorman/server experience. Unless you can “somehow” get in without waiting then yea go for it. Otherwise just cut your losses early and find another place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Best cocktails in New York City. Controversial? Maybe. But I’ll stand by it.
From the nondescript door to the intimate, hidden vibe, Attaboy feels like stepping into a different world. The space is cozy, low-lit, and beautifully curated without trying too hard. Whoever’s managing the flow at the door — owner or manager — deserves a shoutout. They keep things moving without killing the vibe, and the result is a space that never feels overcrowded or chaotic.
And then… the cocktails. Chris behind the bar is the Da Vinci of drinks — tell him your mood and flavor preference and he’ll absolutely nail it. No menu, just trust.
Their take on the Undertaker is a must. Spirit-forward, complex, layered — a full-on flavor experience that deserves an award. The Fort Washington? Smoky, crisp, like a campfire in the New Jersey woods — one of the most unique drinks I’ve ever had.
If you’re into cocktails, go out of your way to come here. Even if there’s a wait, it’s worth it — and their sister bar next door is amazing too, so you’re covered either way.
A true gem. Can’t recommend it enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really poor and bad service. We got there behind only one other couple and waited in line. The hostess said she had to take our number. We waited close by she let the couple in and a bunch of other people left and she told us that we should go find another bar that we’re probably not going to get in. And then she proceeds to let people that showed up after us in. I guess our money is no good there. Poor service and rude hostess.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
There was no seating but the drink more than made up for it. Strongest gin and tonic I’ve had in a long time. Definitely would go back with friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
An unforgettable experience this iconic bar is a must-visit for any cocktail enthusiast. There’s no menu; instead, you’ll chat with the bartender, share your mood, and they’ll craft something just right for you. The bar’s founder actually invented the Penicillin, which happens to be my favorite drink don’t leave without trying one.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely amazing experience! There’s no set menu — instead, you simply tell them what you’re in the mood for. I love customizing some of my favorite cocktails by adding ingredients I enjoy and leaving out anything I don’t. The result? A personalized drink that’s perfect for me every time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was really looking forward to checking out the OG Attaboy seeing as how we spent our time at the Nashville Attaboy and it was absolutely phenomenal; that was not the case here. We walked in when a couple had been leaving and was greeted with an attitude by the hostess. Apparently you’re supposed to ring the doorbell and wait to be let in. She walked us to what she referred to as “standing room” but was literally just us standing at the bar. My wife went to the bathroom and said there were empty tables with no reservation notices or anything. The drinks were good and the bartenders were accommodating, but that’s where the good in this place ended. I wouldn’t come back for a drink here again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Its a fun place and the bartender listens to what you're interested in ordering and makes that for you. And occasionally doesn't listen to you if the bartender thinks you'll like something (complimentary). Its a very specific cocktail experience and if you want something with a menu I would go somewhere else, if you want something tailored to your tastes, go here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
amazing!! great food & vibe
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...