Avrilililly's Creamery LLC

Passion fruit sorbet was deliciousssssss!! Matcha was terrible lol but honestly the sorbet made up for it.

I'll definitely be back. The three non-dairy flavors i tried were all great, but I went with the P.O.G and another that was similar to almond joy. The owner was friendly and the seating area was comfortable. There's also outdoor seating available!

Love this shop! Gelato is hands down the best in NYC, made fresh on premises in both standard and imaginative flavors. Owners are thoughtful, beautiful people. 100% worth the subway ride uptown for this NY-er. 😋

Perfectly balanced flavor for passionfruit sorbet, not too sour not too sweet, I will visit again when I am in the area. Customer service 10/10 and I loved the aesthetics ! 🍨 It's also spacious enough where you can sit down and just relax!

This is the cutest ice cream/bakery I've been to in the city. And the sweets are amazing! I had the passionfruit sorbet which was really refreshing.

I really liked this place. very clean and quiet. I ordered banana puding which was good but very sweet for me.

One of the best creameries in the city!! Stop what you’re doing, and treat yourself to an amazing experience and a nicer treat. Everything is fresh and the prices are reasonable. Don’t leave NY without stopping here.

5 Stars – Sweet Surprise on a Rainy Day!

My wife and I found this place completely by accident. We were walking around the neighborhood when it suddenly started raining, so we rushed into the nearest spot – and wow, we got so lucky.

We ended up in one of the best dessert places we've ever tried. The Blueberry and Chinola ice creams were both incredibly creamy and full of real, natural flavor – no fake stuff here. Then we shared a Tiramisu, and it was honestly one of the best we’ve ever had. Light, perfectly balanced, and clearly homemade.

The place has a cozy, welcoming vibe, and you can tell they really care about quality. What started as us escaping the rain turned into a perfect little sweet adventure. Highly recommended – we’ll be back for sure!

I hate banana pudding and I got it. I still don't like banana pudding but my sister's ice cream was good

Super cute place with a great selection of cakes and ice cream. Their Banana Pudding is my new obsession—so creamy and flavorful! I highly recommend this place for a sweet treat.

Cutie little place on Amsterdam, love the banana pudding! Staff is so kind as well!

2 stars for the nice interior and nice staff, but the gelato was honestly bad. Extremely icy, terrible texture, and flavorless- I tried the choco loco and cookies and cream and both lacked any sort of flavor. I was excited to try gelato in this neighborhood but it’s not worth the money or calories. The carrot cake looked really good so maybe would try a pasty next time

The best little shop in the city. The owners and staff are some of the kindest people I've met and they always welcomed me into their shop. The shop itself is beautiful and I love the care they take when making their coffees, gelatos, and pastries. My little happy place in Harlem, I bring all my friends.

The gelato here is delicious! The fresh flavors with fruit are my favorite. I have been multiple times and have not had a flavor I don't like.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sugar Cookie is HUGE! I also got the banana pudding. Both tasted great and prices were great too!

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding, Sugar Cookie