Bagel Market

264 W 40th St, New York
(212) 681-6301

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Greg Stewart

Loved the atmosphere and service, awesome bagels, salads and sandwiches

Jill Schuman

As a former NJ resident and bagel lover, Bagel Market’s are the only place I go to when in from Colorado and in the city. They are the best. I wish they shipped!!!! Sherif the manager is a gem and an interesting guy. Thank you Bagel Market for starting my day off as a “10”!!!! Jill

amanda cowan

This place isn’t on anyone’s ’viral must do’ video. But honestly, it’s one of the best places we went. Food is ok, pretty good. Portions are pretty large. My daughter and I both got eggs, bacon, toast and potatoes and honestly, we could have shared it and I felt bad because neither of us finished ours. They had a clean bathroom (well, clean enough). It was very large and airy and no one was yelling at customers. All in all, I’d go back.

Con: they had plus up and down the seats for USB but none of them worked.

Nuray Mamedova

My order is in the receipt.
I don’t eat meat and specifically ordered plate with no meat…. But I got a sausage on top, plus instead of the honey mustard I got cayenne pepper sauce. Wow.

I had to leave office again and get different food because I couldn’t eat this. Place was not busy when I picked up my order. I don’t understand how you can mess up something so easy….

Molly Cameron

On a school field trip, we took a bagel making class with our students. Reva and Aiden (I believe) taught our class and were the best. Learning the incredible history of bagels, how to make them from start to finish, and being able to eat our products was amazing. Thanks for taking such great care of us y'all!

Serap Bardakçı

Amazing place to eat

Laerte Fontoura Martins

Didn't get what i ordered

Jehanzaib Ahmed

I was searching a venue for an official breakfast of 20 people in the vicinity before heading to Microsoft Innovation Hub when I came across Bagel Market. Bagel Market satisfied my criteria, large enough dining area upstairs, restrooms, cleanliness, nice ambiance of the restaurant and a large menu to satisfy a diverse audience but the decisive factor was Shareef (manager). I met him on my visit and explained to him why I am visiting his restaurant, he put me at ease and ensured my guests are his guests and he and his team will do their best to serve them without compromising their regular business.

Shareef advised me to place the order in advance using their website, since the restaurant is usually busy in the morning (we were there from 9:00 - 10:00 a.m. so short window). When I arrived at 8:55 a.m., our bagels were being wrapped and beverages finalized, thus our food was fresh and hot, a concern I had while placing the order in advance. We ordered a variety of items from their menu, and all hit the spot, no complaints even from picky eaters. Simply put, the food was delicious. Most importantly the staff is very kind and cooperative, the team had a good time while there. In terms of value, great value, menu is reasonably priced, and portion size are massive.

PS. Thank you Shareef for the dessert, you sweetened our day.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Akshay Patel

Ordered a bagel including tomatoes in it, but they were frozen so the bagel was soggy and cold when I ate it.

Responding to reply: I’m sure other bagel places are also required to keep produce cold, but you don’t put icy crunchy frozen tomatoes in the bagel when serving it. You could warm up the tomatoes first at serving time. I haven’t had this experience elsewhere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Amanda Stansell

Great place for breakfast and coffee! The french toast is amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ron H

Nice place to grab bagels ? just was hot inside ..

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kaden Hansen

Great place for a quick stop! Their breakfast sandwiches are really quite good, and their bagels with cream cheese are a highlight for the price. Tons of flavor, they load you up, and they are pretty quick.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Custom Bagel Sandwich, Bacon Egg and Cheese

Konrad Kubicki

They sold me a bagel without anything even though I ordered it with smoked fish

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

evangeline

Wanted to experience the NY bagel..this place is perfectly delicious!

Azanyah Maloney

I didn’t get any food I only got a smoothie which was good the place was super clean and service was fast

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Loading...