Bagel Mill Cafe
1461 3rd Ave, New York
(212) 426-0868
Photos
+9 photos
+8 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I didn't realize this place was called the bagel mill. I had a great sandwich and my friend did as well. I also had Nathan's hot dogs and fries there as well and the fries were as good as they are in Coney Island with the red forks even
Very nice selection of bagels and toppings. The staff are reasonably friendly and the cleanliness is average. I really recommend the salted bagel with butter and turkey. If you have it toasted it is extremely delicious although the sodium may require you to check your blood pressure and cholesterol once in a while if you eat this regularly.
Decent place to stop for breakfast or lunch. Nothing outstanding, but at least it's consistent. If they could keep a solid A rating, I would be inclined to rate this higher, but I consistently see them at a B or "grade pending".
You May Also Like
Phil Hughes Bar - 1682 1st Ave.
![]()
Irish Pub, Pet Friendly
Dragon 88 - 1680 1st Ave.
![]()
Chinese, Noodles, Soup
Hollybrook Lane - 1712 1st Ave.
![]()
Southern, Comfort Food