The ambience was nice, low lighting, vintage wine bottles, live music downstairs. However, the food was extremely mediocre. I guess it's a good deal for the pre-theater dinner for $65, but still, food was barely worth that. Then we got absolutely screwed with the bar bill. Charged $90 for a glass of prosecco, a glass of red wine, and a coffee. On top of that, the wait staff all seem like they would rather be doing anything else. Grumpy, rushed us, and not welcoming at all. Overall, it was a convenient dinner prior to a show, but I would never pay $300 for that again.
Thomas
This is the classic Northern Italian New York restaurant. We have been coming here for many years, and it combines old world charm with great food and exquisite service
Alan
Nicely Italian rather than Italian-American, focused on Piemonte. We had swordfish on lentils, beef in Barolo, peppers in bagna cauda, baked apples for dessert, all home-style but very well-prepared. In other words, wide selection not limited to pasta, pizza, parm. Only drawback was only six tables occupied on Friday night in huge dining room, so bring your own fun.
Kerry
It was “fine”. Not sure I would go back. Besides the old decor it wasn't special. Food was average and expensive. Waiters were strict and not personable 🤷🏻♀️. Not my fave
Frank
We were particularly looking for a Northern Italian restaurant and Barbetta fit the bill! The food and service were impeccable, and the elegant decor set the mood. This will be a routine stop on our visits to New York.
David Rosensaft
Just as wonderful as it has been for the 50+ years I've dined there. A true classic -- the most beautiful and romantic dining room, with it's outdoor garden and elegant surroundings -- that one can find in Manhattan. Service in the old style -- trust the Captain to offer and recommend outstanding choices. Food was exquisitely prepared and delicious. Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Haimm
Went here after I proposed to my now fiancé before we went to a show. We were running late and not only did they get all of our food out fast to accommodate us it was absolutely fantastic! The best part is the service though. They treat you like family. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a great dinner spot before a show
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victor
Great dinner at Barbetta. We had the Sea Bass and the Crabmeat in Sherry. We shared the peppers and a walnut cake. everything was delicious. Such a lovely dining experience.
Marc
It was pricey for the pris fix pre theater dinner, but the ambiance is nice and it is in the theater district so it's convenient. There are, at least, a number of options on the dinner menu, so most people should be able to find something they like,
Philip
I'm not gonna lie, that roasted rabbit is very good a unique flavor in the menu. I always something different to eat.
The roasted beet appetizer was the best of the meal. The agnolotti tasted good but came out lukewarm. The Barolo beef was so tough I could barely cut it but the sauce was tasty.
Veronica
The best rabbit I've ever eaten in my entire life. I'm very particular about meals, and I can say this dish made me cry with happiness! A delicacy fit for the gods. You must try it and you'll understand what I'm talking about. About the service: 10/10. Definitely this place is going to be one of my favorite places in the town.
Nicolae Rita
Beautiful historical restaurant with a charming outdoor dining and classic servers …but the food was atrocious and expensive. We shared the antipasto platter which was really sad looking with some random vegetables and for the main I had the sword fish which was overcooked and in an awful sauce. The other dishes were also lacking flavor and were overcooked. I left hungry and disappointed after spending $100 per person!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Norberto Charlotten
Myself and Husband had the best of everything at this restaurant.We loved the back courtyard and the servers were very attentive. I will be back.
The ambience was nice, low lighting, vintage wine bottles, live music downstairs. However, the food was extremely mediocre. I guess it's a good deal for the pre-theater dinner for $65, but still, food was barely worth that. Then we got absolutely screwed with the bar bill. Charged $90 for a glass of prosecco, a glass of red wine, and a coffee. On top of that, the wait staff all seem like they would rather be doing anything else. Grumpy, rushed us, and not welcoming at all. Overall, it was a convenient dinner prior to a show, but I would never pay $300 for that again.
This is the classic Northern Italian New York restaurant. We have been coming here for many years, and it combines old world charm with great food and exquisite service
Nicely Italian rather than Italian-American, focused on Piemonte. We had swordfish on lentils, beef in Barolo, peppers in bagna cauda, baked apples for dessert, all home-style but very well-prepared. In other words, wide selection not limited to pasta, pizza, parm. Only drawback was only six tables occupied on Friday night in huge dining room, so bring your own fun.
It was “fine”. Not sure I would go back. Besides the old decor it wasn't special. Food was average and expensive. Waiters were strict and not personable 🤷🏻♀️. Not my fave
We were particularly looking for a Northern Italian restaurant and Barbetta fit the bill! The food and service were impeccable, and the elegant decor set the mood. This will be a routine stop on our visits to New York.
Just as wonderful as it has been for the 50+ years I've dined there. A true classic -- the most beautiful and romantic dining room, with it's outdoor garden and elegant surroundings -- that one can find in Manhattan. Service in the old style -- trust the Captain to offer and recommend outstanding choices. Food was exquisitely prepared and delicious. Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went here after I proposed to my now fiancé before we went to a show. We were running late and not only did they get all of our food out fast to accommodate us it was absolutely fantastic! The best part is the service though. They treat you like family. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a great dinner spot before a show
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great dinner at Barbetta. We had the Sea Bass and the Crabmeat in Sherry. We shared the peppers and a walnut cake. everything was delicious. Such a lovely dining experience.
It was pricey for the pris fix pre theater dinner, but the ambiance is nice and it is in the theater district so it's convenient. There are, at least, a number of options on the dinner menu, so most people should be able to find something they like,
I'm not gonna lie, that roasted rabbit is very good a unique flavor in the menu. I always something different to eat.
Restaurantji Recommends
The roasted beet appetizer was the best of the meal. The agnolotti tasted good but came out lukewarm. The Barolo beef was so tough I could barely cut it but the sauce was tasty.
The best rabbit I've ever eaten in my entire life. I'm very particular about meals, and I can say this dish made me cry with happiness! A delicacy fit for the gods. You must try it and you'll understand what I'm talking about. About the service: 10/10. Definitely this place is going to be one of my favorite places in the town.
Beautiful historical restaurant with a charming outdoor dining and classic servers …but the food was atrocious and expensive. We shared the antipasto platter which was really sad looking with some random vegetables and for the main I had the sword fish which was overcooked and in an awful sauce. The other dishes were also lacking flavor and were overcooked.
I left hungry and disappointed after spending $100 per person!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Myself and Husband had the best of everything at this restaurant.We loved the back courtyard and the servers were very attentive. I will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great ambiance
Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loading...