Just walked out after getting ignored in an empty store while the employee washed dishes. Tried to get a retention several times, obviously not interested in making a sale
A1MG
Tasty cakes
Joel Yap
Great cakes.
Gretchen Hopper
I ordered a cupcake and lemon bar online for an afternoon treat. The cupcake was probably one of the driest I’ve had in my life. The lemon bar was good, but not exceptional. When I walked in to pick up my order the employee was only a phone call for a while and didn’t acknowledge me and then pulled up the wrong order initially, not a big deal, but also not a great service experience.
Sabrina R.
The coconut cake we ordered for a friend’s birthday was absolutely delicious. Perfectly sweet but not overpowering, perfectly coconut-y, and perfectly moist!
Libby
We ordered Custom Cupcakes, the printing was just what we ordered. The cupcakes, vanilla, were the driest cupcakes I’ve ever had. Everyone was so surprised just how dry they were. We served them the same day we picked them up on Saturday. Just try them before ordering, we didn’t.
Liam Ben Zur
Second year in a row ordering a custom cake for my son’s birthday, and second year in a row that Billy’s hit it out of the park.
Delicious, attractive cakes. Always a crowd pleaser. Will continue ordering from them for sure!
Brittain Blackwell
Best vegan cupcake I have had in NYC and maybe ever! Had no idea they even had a vegan option, but it was delicious. Not dry and not overly sweet. Hard to find a vegan cupcake that gets the texture right! So good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Talia Davi
Purchased Red Velvet and Lemon Cream Cheese cupcakes; they were both DRY. The frosting was hard…unfortunately, both were thrown in the garbage after a bite of each cupcake. Very disappointing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Flaminia
This place is ran by the kindest and most compassionate people. It’s always a joy to see them, they always greet you with a smile. And of course Billy’s cakes and cupcakes are the BEST in the neighbourhood and - in my personal opinion - in all manhattan. This store is a UWS gem. Thank you guys!
I absolutely love Billy's Bakery. We ordered a small cake for our event and couldn't be more thrilled with the result. It was beautiful and utterly delicious. Not only was the cake super moist and most importantly the buttercream is actual buttercream.
The team was easy to work with on planning and designing the cake and pick up was seamless.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake, Cupcakes
Kevin Cartwright
I recently entrusted Billy’s Bakery to make a very special birthday cake for my partner. The cake in question was a German Chocolate Cake. I do not generally care for German Chocolate Cake due to my aversion to coconut, but I share this info to emphasize exactly how astoundingly delicious our German Chocolate Cake was. My partner absolutely loved the cake; just thrilled. In spite of the fact I do not care for German Chocolate Cake, I devoured nearly half of the cake myself because it was so good I just couldn’t stop eating it; almost like a delicious out-of-body cake devouring experience. If Billy’s can make a type of cake I do not usually care for so astonishingly good that I “accidentally” eat half of it, I can’t wait to experience another cake from here. Don’t hesitate, order anything from this place and you’re going to love it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake
Brian
First time customer after hearing about Billy’s for years. Thank you for the incredible cake which made my Mom’s 70th Birthday so special! Not only was the cake beautiful, but the party guests were raving about how delicious it was! 10/10 I’m a believer!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake
Shay Speizman
Ordered a couple of times online for birthdays. Great options in customizing the cupcakes which made the birthday girls even happier. Had a problem with ordering online once, they were super helpful in solving the issue. The kids loved the cupcakes and so did the adults.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Brian
First time customer after hearing about Billy’s for years. Thank you for the incredible cake which made my Mom’s 70th Birthday so special! Not only was the cake beautiful, but the party guests were raving about how delicious it was! 10/10 I’m a believer!!
Just walked out after getting ignored in an empty store while the employee washed dishes.
Tried to get a retention several times, obviously not interested in making a sale
Tasty cakes
Great cakes.
I ordered a cupcake and lemon bar online for an afternoon treat. The cupcake was probably one of the driest I’ve had in my life. The lemon bar was good, but not exceptional. When I walked in to pick up my order the employee was only a phone call for a while and didn’t acknowledge me and then pulled up the wrong order initially, not a big deal, but also not a great service experience.
The coconut cake we ordered for a friend’s birthday was absolutely delicious. Perfectly sweet but not overpowering, perfectly coconut-y, and perfectly moist!
We ordered Custom Cupcakes, the printing was just what we ordered. The cupcakes, vanilla, were the driest cupcakes I’ve ever had. Everyone was so surprised just how dry they were. We served them the same day we picked them up on Saturday. Just try them before ordering, we didn’t.
Second year in a row ordering a custom cake for my son’s birthday, and second year in a row that Billy’s hit it out of the park.
Delicious, attractive cakes. Always a crowd pleaser. Will continue ordering from them for sure!
Best vegan cupcake I have had in NYC and maybe ever! Had no idea they even had a vegan option, but it was delicious. Not dry and not overly sweet. Hard to find a vegan cupcake that gets the texture right! So good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Purchased Red Velvet and Lemon Cream Cheese cupcakes; they were both DRY. The frosting was hard…unfortunately, both were thrown in the garbage after a bite of each cupcake. Very disappointing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
This place is ran by the kindest and most compassionate people. It’s always a joy to see them, they always greet you with a smile. And of course Billy’s cakes and cupcakes are the BEST in the neighbourhood and - in my personal opinion - in all manhattan. This store is a UWS gem. Thank you guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I absolutely love Billy's Bakery. We ordered a small cake for our event and couldn't be more thrilled with the result. It was beautiful and utterly delicious. Not only was the cake super moist and most importantly the buttercream is actual buttercream.
The team was easy to work with on planning and designing the cake and pick up was seamless.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake, Cupcakes
I recently entrusted Billy’s Bakery to make a very special birthday cake for my partner. The cake in question was a German Chocolate Cake. I do not generally care for German Chocolate Cake due to my aversion to coconut, but I share this info to emphasize exactly how astoundingly delicious our German Chocolate Cake was. My partner absolutely loved the cake; just thrilled. In spite of the fact I do not care for German Chocolate Cake, I devoured nearly half of the cake myself because it was so good I just couldn’t stop eating it; almost like a delicious out-of-body cake devouring experience. If Billy’s can make a type of cake I do not usually care for so astonishingly good that I “accidentally” eat half of it, I can’t wait to experience another cake from here. Don’t hesitate, order anything from this place and you’re going to love it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake
First time customer after hearing about Billy’s for years. Thank you for the incredible cake which made my Mom’s 70th Birthday so special! Not only was the cake beautiful, but the party guests were raving about how delicious it was! 10/10 I’m a believer!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake
Ordered a couple of times online for birthdays. Great options in customizing the cupcakes which made the birthday girls even happier. Had a problem with ordering online once, they were super helpful in solving the issue.
The kids loved the cupcakes and so did the adults.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time customer after hearing about Billy’s for years. Thank you for the incredible cake which made my Mom’s 70th Birthday so special! Not only was the cake beautiful, but the party guests were raving about how delicious it was! 10/10 I’m a believer!!
Loading...