Reasonable prices in a great location. There were only two staff members on a Saturday morning but the food was amazing and I was surprised to see alcohol here as an option (beer and soju). They also had ice cream Pints both vegan and regular. There is a restroom for customers and some seating indoors. Personally it was just too hot to stay and eat there for longer than I wanted to.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
James C
One of the best burgers I've had in a long time. The beef patty has a subtle flavorful taste between soft fresh buns. The tasty fries complemented the burger well. Glad I stopped in for lunch.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sofia Lopez
I was in the area and hungry, so I looked up what food was around. This came up and the poutine fries looked great, corn dogs too. I ordered those 2 things and the wait was so long. About 15 minutes, and it wasn’t just me, I heard 2 other people talking about the wait, and a kid even went up to the worker and asked when his stuff was gonna be ready. Then the food, poutine fries looked nothing like the picture. They were drenched in the gravy and soggy fries, and the corn dog didn’t even stay on the stick. Actual taste was alright but I wouldn’t come back here if I’m ever looking for something to eat.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Ivan Ottavian
Burger & Shake Co. on Amsterdam Avenue is my great discovery of the day! I don’t normally hang out on Amsterdam but I walked into this place that I’ve been wanting to try for a long time now. It’s a solid neighborhood spot if you’re craving a straightforward burger and fries without breaking the bank. The burgers are good, tasty, simple, well-assembled, and satisfying, a bit overcooked for my personal taste but completely fine and filling. Don’t expect a gourmet experience, but they hit the right notes for flavor and freshness. The loaded crinkle-cut fries (Poutine Fries) topped with melted mozzarella and scallions, are a delightful nice touch and definitely worth adding on. Service is fast, smiling and efficient, which makes this place a reliable option when you’re on the go or just want a quick sit-down bite. The prices are the best part. For New York City, they’re extraordinarily reasonable, making “Burger & Shake Co.” a great value stop for students, locals, or anyone looking to enjoy a good burger without spending too much.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Sasha Torres
Amazing burger!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tuan Nguyen
Great burgers, great beer selection, great prices. Little gem of the neighborhood
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dhwani Dalal
I used to love this place. But unfortunately I’ve gotten a raw turkey burger from here twice. I gave them a chance the first time but that’s really dangerous that it’s repeatedly happening.
Les F
Great food & service. Love coming here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
M S
This place was spot-on on every level! I recently tried the fried chicken sandwich they make and I couldn't believe that I actually found a fast food place that had a better quality chicken sandwich than Smash Burger's. The chicken meat was juicy, tender and tasty to the core! I experienced bliss with every succulent bite. Then it was time for the shake -- I was shook! The pistachio shake was heavenly! Thick but not too dense and very nutty-yum! The fries and onion rings were very crispy and they travelled well, surprisingly. The memory of that first meal will linger until my second visit. The service was quick and very efficient and the atmosphere was easy-going and unhurried. Also the price was right, for the quality of food. I cannot wait to try the burger! If you have not yet given Burger & Shake Co. a try, you should, today! Your palate and your belly will thank you.
I tried this place again, and they delivered on consistency. The shakes were out of this world! I had the sea salt caramel— delish! The burgers were filling and tasty and the onion rings were huge-omg!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Wilson
Great service . The truffle fries were 💯 . I am not a big fan of beef , but I enjoyed the burger .
My husband and I love eating here after a day spent working out at Riverbank. The burgers are very reasonably priced and creative. There is always someone kind working behind the counter.
Camille M
30 minutes for a cheeseburger during my 1 hour lunch break. I won’t ever go back.
Brendan Ahmed
Ordered a normal burger and got a lamb burger. Tasted disgusting and now my stomach hurts so bad. NEVER go here!
Andrew Luhn
The food is pretty good here and good prices but the hours are dumb. They close at either 8 or 9. And even when they’re supposedly open until 9 they close their online ordering earlier. I’d probably eat here often but I don’t get home from work until 8 or later most nights. You’d think a place like this right next to a college would be open til at least 10 most nights.
HARLEM 1990
The burgers and fries here perfection. Friendly staff. Even the ice cream is very Good. 10/10
Reasonable prices in a great location. There were only two staff members on a Saturday morning but the food was amazing and I was surprised to see alcohol here as an option (beer and soju). They also had ice cream
Pints both vegan and regular. There is a restroom for customers and some seating indoors. Personally it was just too hot to stay and eat there for longer than I wanted to.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best burgers I've had in a long time. The beef patty has a subtle flavorful taste between soft fresh buns. The tasty fries complemented the burger well. Glad I stopped in for lunch.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was in the area and hungry, so I looked up what food was around. This came up and the poutine fries looked great, corn dogs too. I ordered those 2 things and the wait was so long. About 15 minutes, and it wasn’t just me, I heard 2 other people talking about the wait, and a kid even went up to the worker and asked when his stuff was gonna be ready. Then the food, poutine fries looked nothing like the picture. They were drenched in the gravy and soggy fries, and the corn dog didn’t even stay on the stick. Actual taste was alright but I wouldn’t come back here if I’m ever looking for something to eat.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Burger & Shake Co. on Amsterdam Avenue is my great discovery of the day! I don’t normally hang out on Amsterdam but I walked into this place that I’ve been wanting to try for a long time now. It’s a solid neighborhood spot if you’re craving a straightforward burger and fries without breaking the bank. The burgers are good, tasty, simple, well-assembled, and satisfying, a bit overcooked for my personal taste but completely fine and filling. Don’t expect a gourmet experience, but they hit the right notes for flavor and freshness. The loaded crinkle-cut fries (Poutine Fries) topped with melted mozzarella and scallions, are a delightful nice touch and definitely worth adding on.
Service is fast, smiling and efficient, which makes this place a reliable option when you’re on the go or just want a quick sit-down bite. The prices are the best part.
For New York City, they’re extraordinarily reasonable, making “Burger & Shake Co.” a great value stop for students, locals, or anyone looking to enjoy a good burger without spending too much.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Amazing burger!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great burgers, great beer selection, great prices. Little gem of the neighborhood
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I used to love this place. But unfortunately I’ve gotten a raw turkey burger from here twice. I gave them a chance the first time but that’s really dangerous that it’s repeatedly happening.
Great food & service. Love coming here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place was spot-on on every level! I recently tried the fried chicken sandwich they make and I couldn't believe that I actually found a fast food place that had a better quality chicken sandwich than Smash Burger's. The chicken meat was juicy, tender and tasty to the core! I
experienced bliss with every succulent bite. Then it was time for the shake -- I was shook! The pistachio shake was heavenly! Thick but not too dense and very nutty-yum! The fries and onion rings were very crispy and they travelled well, surprisingly. The memory of that first meal will linger until my second visit. The service was quick and very efficient and the atmosphere was easy-going and unhurried. Also the price was right, for the quality of food. I cannot wait to try the burger!
If you have not yet given Burger & Shake Co. a try, you should, today! Your palate and your belly will thank you.
I tried this place again, and they delivered on consistency. The shakes were out of this world! I had the sea salt caramel— delish!
The burgers were filling and tasty and the onion rings were huge-omg!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service . The truffle fries were 💯 . I am not a big fan of beef , but I enjoyed the burger .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
My husband and I love eating here after a day spent working out at Riverbank. The burgers are very reasonably priced and creative. There is always someone kind working behind the counter.
30 minutes for a cheeseburger during my 1 hour lunch break. I won’t ever go back.
Ordered a normal burger and got a lamb burger. Tasted disgusting and now my stomach hurts so bad. NEVER go here!
The food is pretty good here and good prices but the hours are dumb. They close at either 8 or 9. And even when they’re supposedly open until 9 they close their online ordering earlier. I’d probably eat here often but I don’t get home from work until 8 or later most nights. You’d think a place like this right next to a college would be open til at least 10 most nights.
The burgers and fries here perfection. Friendly staff. Even the ice cream is very Good. 10/10
Loading...