By the Way Bakery

1236 Lexington Ave, New York
(212) 988-3300

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Lemon Poppy Mini Bundt Cake
Lemon Poppy Seed Cake
Sprinkle Cake - 6 Inch
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Tea Cakes & Specialty
Fudge Brownie Cookie
Coconut Cake Slice
Honey Cake Muffins
GF Cream Puff
Whoopie Pie

Menu

Most Popular
Amy Cake
a delightful little bundt cake with sprinkles inside and out, one serving
Schnibbles Mini
an over-the-top Devil's food chocolate chip bundtlette, one serving
Brownie
an indulgent, no-holds-barred brownie made with Belgian chocolate, one brownie per serving
M Cake
vanilla layers with chocolate frosting inside and out! serves 6-10 guests
Classic Chocolate - 6 inch
moist cocoa-based chocolate cake and decadent chocolate frosting - serves 6-10 guests
Sprinkle Cake - 6 inch
an all vanilla layer cake covered in multicolored nonpareils! serves 6-10 guests
Lemon Poppy Swirl
a spiral-shaped bundt with just the right balance of tart and sweet, serves 8 - 12
The M Cupcake
vanilla cake with chocolate frosting, one serving
Lemon Poppy Seed Mini
a classic combination with a tender crumb, one serving
Black and White Cupcake
chocolate cake with vanilla chiffon frosting, one serving

Picked for you
Amy Cake
a delightful little bundt cake with sprinkles inside and out, one serving
Sprinkle Cake - 6 inch
an all vanilla layer cake covered in multicolored nonpareils! serves 6-10 guests
M Cake
vanilla layers with chocolate frosting inside and out! serves 6-10 guests
Chocolate Truffle Torte
with deep chocolate flavor and a creamy texture, serves 8 - 12
Classic Chocolate - 6 inch
moist cocoa-based chocolate cake and decadent chocolate frosting - serves 6-10 guests

Specialty Cakes
Lemon Poppy Swirl
a spiral-shaped bundt with just the right balance of tart and sweet, serves 8 - 12
Chocolate Truffle Torte
with deep chocolate flavor and a creamy texture, serves 8 - 12
Blueberry Coffee Cake
with a cinnamon streusel crumb topping, serves 8 - 12

Mini Cakes
Amy Cake
a delightful little bundt cake with sprinkles inside and out, one serving
Whoopie Pie
sweet, creamy filling sandwiched between two chocolatey cake-like cookies! one serving
Schnibbles Mini
an over-the-top Devil's food chocolate chip bundtlette, one serving
Apple Mini Cake
chunks of apples nestled in a mini spiral bundt, one serving
Lemon Poppy Seed Mini
a classic combination with a tender crumb, one serving
Almond Spiral
with a delicate crumb and a light orange glaze, one serving

Bags Of Cookies
Fudge Brownie Cookie - Bag of 6
a crispy-chewy-chocolatey treat, bag of 6 cookies
Rugelach Raspberry - Bag
ribbons of pastry dough wrapped around raspberry filling, 10 pieces per bag
Rugelach Apricot - Bag
ribbons of pastry dough wrapped around apricot filling, 10 pieces per bag
Biscotti - Bag
perfect for dipping in your morning coffee - bag of 10 pieces
Almond Cookie - Bag of 6
our award-winning cookie, with a crunchy exterior and a moist center! bag of 6 cookies
Coconut Pecan Chewy - Bag of 6
the coconut macaroon meets the chocolate chip cookie, bag of 6 cookies
Rugelach Chocolate - Bag
ribbons of pastry dough wrapped around chocolate filling, 10 pieces per bag

Snacks & more
Granola
made with certified gluten-free oats, nuts, dried fruit, and a touch of honey
Mo Mix Chocolate Hazelnut
A salty-sweet snack made with cereal squares, pretzels, and salted caramel - Chocolate Hazelnut
Mo Mix Coconut Almond
A salty-sweet snack made with cereal squares, pretzels, and salted caramel - Coconut Almond
Mo Mix Pecan Chai
A salty-sweet snack made with cereal squares, pretzels, and salted caramel - Pecan Chai

Small Treats
Brownie
an indulgent, no-holds-barred brownie made with Belgian chocolate, one brownie per serving
Creme Puff
petite "donut holes" filled with custard, one puff
Fudge Brownie Cookie
a crispy-chewy-chocolatey treat, one serving
Blondie
These soft and chewy squares are everything you want a blondie to be, the chocolate chips make them even better! one blondie per serving
Almond Cookie
our award-winning cookie, with a crunchy exterior and a moist center, one cookie
Pecan Turtle Bar
caramel, pecans, and chocolate in a magical bar cookie, one bar per serving
Raspberry Bar
luscious raspberry jam in a shortbread crust, one bar per serving
Chocolate Chip cookie
like your favorite aunt used to make - Okay, maybe a little better! one cookie

Cupcakes
The M Cupcake
vanilla cake with chocolate frosting, one serving
Black and White Cupcake
chocolate cake with vanilla chiffon frosting, one serving
Classic Chocolate Cupcake
chocolate cake with chocolate frosting, one serving

6 inch Layer Cakes
Classic Chocolate - 6 inch
moist cocoa-based chocolate cake and decadent chocolate frosting - serves 6-10 guests
Coconut Cloud - 6 inch
coconut layers with dreamy white frosting covered in coconut chips - serves 6-10 guests
Sprinkle Cake - 6 inch
an all vanilla layer cake covered in multicolored nonpareils! serves 6-10 guests
M Cake
vanilla layers with chocolate frosting inside and out! serves 6-10 guests

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+67 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+66 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I think by the way bakery is super underrated! It’s fully kosher parve and their custom cake they made for my occasion was not only beautiful but delicious!!!!! The customer service who helps with custom is also very responsive and helpful.
July 2025
Cute little store, friendly and helpful staff, usually lots of options to choose from or order. A little pricy but I always find myself coming back, especially when I have friends who are lactose intolerant.
May 2025
BEST ALMOND COOKIES I’VE EVER HAD

And they’re gluten-free!

Just a heads-up: it’s not a place to sit down. It’s a small bakery where you can grab some delicious gluten-free treats to take with you.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free
January 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Thai At Lex - 1244 Lexington Ave
Thai, Noodles, Asian Fusion, Asian, Vegetarian
Tal Bagels - 1228 Lexington Ave
Bagels, Vegan, Vegetarian
Lexington Candy Shop - 1226 Lexington Ave
Diner, American, Burgers, Vegan, Vegetarian

By the Way Bakery

1236 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10028
(212) 988-3300