Caledonia Bar

424 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(646) 912-9277

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+49 photos
+48 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This bar is Epic! Lucky to have found this establishment next to our AirBnB and it did not disappoint! In town for a week from southern France, we bellied up to this bar 4 times on a week long holiday. Unbelievable selection of Scotch whiskeys and Jeff, a proper bartender (complete with authentic accent). If you love whiskey, do not miss this spot.

If we lived here, this would be our local watering hole for sure.

You’re welcome.
My friend group had a fantastic meal here last week. Restaurant workers offer kind help and suggest dishes you'll enjoy. This place is beyond impressive! The prices are very customer friendly, and the food is very fresh. This place avoids the predictable.
Feels like home the moment you walk in. Our host and bartender, Jeff (spelling likely wrong) was charming, knowledgeable, warm and friendly. Bars can be all the same, but he make this place special. Great selection of whiskies (>250) and frothy Guinness among other standards. Will return often when in area!

More Reviews