Carnegie Pizza
200 W 41st St, New York
(212) 777-4141
Customers' Favorites
Margherita Pizza Pepperoni Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Classic Sicilian Square Pie
Spicy Pepperoni Square Pie
Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Any Two Topping Slice
Eggplant Square Pizza
Mushroom Spinach Pizza
Spicy Pepperoni Pizza
White Sicilian Pizza
Menu
Photos
+66 photos
+65 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I’ve been back on both of my recent trips to the city and they never disappoint. As natives who moved far from the tri states - Carnegie pizza always scratches that itch for try New York style pizza
Really really good pizza and the price is very fair considering we’re in an ultra touristy part of the city. You know it’s a good place when the guys behind the counter call you ‘Boss’. My ONLY criticism is the garlic knots. I love garlic bread as does most everyone but these things are SUPER garlic knots meaning that it’s garlic with a bit of bread. I can still taste it in my mouth 2 days later so be prepared! Otherwise very delicious
You May Also Like
5 o'Clock Somewhere Bar - Times Square - 560 7th Ave
![]()
American, Bar, Cocktail Bar, Burgers, Chicken Wings
LandShark Bar & Grill - Times Square - 560 7th Ave
![]()
Bar, American, Cocktail Bar, Bar & Grill, Vegetarian
Pink Taco - 7 Times Sq
![]()
Mexican, Tacos, Bar
Service is quick, friendly, and consistent every time. We went twice in one weekend! :) Whether you’re grabbing a slice on the go or sitting down for a quick bite, this...