Carnegie Pizza
200 W 41st St, New York
(212) 777-4141
Customers' Favorites
Margherita Pizza Pepperoni Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Classic Sicilian Square Pie
Spicy Pepperoni Square Pie
Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Any Two Topping Slice
Eggplant Square Pizza
Mushroom Spinach Pizza
Spicy Pepperoni Pizza
White Sicilian Pizza
Menu
Photos
+69 photos
+68 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Anytime we go to NYC, we avoid the tourist traps that charge 7 dollars for a slice of pizza and head to Carnegie Pizza. The service is quick, options are high, prices are great for the area, and the pizza is fantastic. My absolute favorite is the upside down pizza. You won’t be disappointed.
When you walk in and two of New York’s finest (NYPD) are chowing down, you know it’s a good place. Great variety and so so good. Originally thought we’d go somewhere else that had a huge line. The walk around the corner was well worth it. You won’t be disappointed.
Carnegie Pizza is a true gem in NYC. The pizza including the service is amazing!💯 My 8 year old daughter has celiac disease and is on a gluten free diet. We truly appreciate the employees taking precautions against wheat cross contamination when making her pizza. They use separate pans to cook GF pizzas and even provide customers with their own separate pizza cutter to cut their pizza. It’s very rare to find restaurants that we trust when it comes to providing truly delicious...
You May Also Like
Rosetta Bakery - 120 W 42nd St
![]()
Bakery, Pizza, Pet Friendly
5 o'Clock Somewhere Bar - Times Square - 560 7th Ave
![]()
American, Bar, Cocktail Bar, Burgers, Chicken Wings
LandShark Bar & Grill - Times Square - 560 7th Ave
![]()
Bar, American, Cocktail Bar, Bar & Grill, Vegetarian