Casa Carmen Flatiron

5 W 21st St, New York
(917) 540-5600

Recent Reviews

Sort by
PJ

Love this restaurant! The mole is the best! I just wish the spicy margaritas were spicy! But the service is excellent!

William

Service was outstanding especially for drinks. Food was just OK - tostada was stale, daily special wasn't very special. Had higher expectations.

Sherry

Food was delicious- - love the place. Diego was wonderful. Diego suggested many delicious plates- The manager was very accommodating. We had such a lovely time. Chicken was fantastic, as well as our appetizers, love love love. .Will be back Sherry Boyd -

Katherine

Pablo is a superb server and we really appreciated how great he was. This includes moving us to a quieter table. You're lucky to have him! I live in the neighborhood and we've been to your restaurant twice.And we'll definitely be back! We also appreciate Jennifer's kindness and hospitality.

Abby

The service here was excellent, my husband and I had a joke that he was trying to finish his water before the waiter refilled it so that he could have topo Chico but the waiter was too good and never let our water glasses get below half full! The food was excellent, I'll recommend the chicken verdes enchiladas, the elote, and the banana old fashioned.

Camille

We loved our meal at Casa Carmen. Great food, delicious cocktails, attentive and helpful service all in an elegant setting. We'll be back!

Rachel

A great mix of inventive and traditional. Everything we ordered was delicious. I will definitely be back.

Charlie Liao

Came here for happy hour drinks — thoroughly enjoyed it!! Got this old fashioned with banana liquor in it that was tasty. Generally enjoyed the tacos here too although they didn’t blow me away. Cool ambiance. Felt like I was in Tulum

Ava

Went for a late brunch with 3 friends. Service was attentive and accommodating- the place was very quiet on a holiday weekend - food was delicious tho 16-18 for two tacos a was bit high in my opinion. The mezcalitas were amazing.

Pamela

Had a great dinner date with my fellas 🥳

Johnny Mancini

Yeah hi, i attended the work dinner that Neal just posted about. This is how my face looks, I did NOT have a pouty face. Cerveza was incredible and Elias gave me an intimate experience. Neal (hat) tried speaking espanol all night.

Neal Harrod

We hosted our annual work dinner at casa Carmen. It was all excellent - Despite one in our party having a pouty face in this photo. Elias, our bartender served excellent drinks as we reminisced about his childhood in San Juan. Five stars!

Kimberly

It was delicious! We enjoyed our appetizers and our main courses. We didn't feel rushed nor were we ignored. We would definitely return.

O O

Great spot for a date night or to have a nice meal with friends! It’s feels intimate but not overly romantic. The food was delicious, the salsa that came with the guacamole was one of the best ones I’ve had, tasted like smoked chipotle. Drinks were top notch.

Richard

Every dish was loaded with flavor, creative and a real pleasure to experience; service was also outstanding, informative and extremely courteous. Only problem was not having a big enough appetite to taste everything that intrigued us. Looking forward to returning.

Loading...