Casa Carmen Flatiron

5 W 21st St, New York
(917) 540-5600

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Molletes Gratinados
Fruit Granola Bowl
Panuchos Yucatecos
Esquites Trufados
Tacos De Rib Eye
Enchiladas Verdes
Tacos De Lengua
Ceviche Verde
Chile Relleno
Ribeye Tacos

To Share
Guacamole
Avocado, jalapeño, cilantro, onion, cacalas
Aguachile
Shrimp, scallop, avocado, cucumber, chile chiltepin, lime, cilantro, onion
Caldo Xóchitl
Chicken broth, avocado, jalapeño, cilantro, onion
Ceviche verde
Fluke, olives, jalapeño, tomatillo, avocado, lime, cacalas
Chicharrón
Pork crakling
Empanadas de plátano con frijol
Plantain, fried beans, charred chipotle salsa
Ensalada Carmen
Diced cactus, grilled queso fresco, tomato, oregano
Ensalada de betabel
Beet, orange, requesón, lettuce, toasted pepita
Fideo seco
Fideo, avocado, cilantro, crema
Garnachas Orizabeñas
Brisket, potatoes, salsa
Panuchos Yucatecos
Cochinita pibil, fried beans, pickled onion, habanero
Tostadas de cangrejo
Crab, toasted corn, habanero aioli, cilantro
Tostadas de pato en escabeche
Pickled duck, fried beans, lettuce
Trio de quesadillas
Melted Oaxacan cheese, seasonal vegetables

Tacos
Tacos de barbacoa
Lamb barbacoa, cilantro, onion
Tacos de carnitas
Michoacan pork carnitas, cilantro, onion
Tacos de lengua
Slow cooked beef tongue, cilantro, onion
Tacos de pollo
Diced grilled chicken, axiote, cilantro, onion
Tacos de pulpo al mojo de ajo
Sauteed octopus, fried beans, garlic, epazote
Tacos de rib eye
Skirt steak, guacamole, onion, cilantro
Tacos vegetarianos
Vegetarian tacos, choose your favorite vegetable

Mains
Chamorro en adobo
Slow cooked pork shank, fried beans, adobo
Enchiladas verdes
Chicken or vegetables, tomatillo salsa, crema, Cotija cheese
Enmoladas
Chicken or vegetables, mole Xico, crema, Cotija cheese
Huarache de rib eye
Rib eye 7oz, fried beans, salsa
Pescado a la talla
Whole branzino, adobo, salsa verde, black beans, pickled onion, chile morita salsa, tortillas
Pescado a la veracruzana
Branzino, güero peppers, olives, capers, tomato salsa
Pescado con verdolagas
Branzino, purslane tomatillo salsa
Pollo con mole Xico
Chicken leg and thigh, mole Xico, crema, sesame
Pulpo al mojo de ajo
Render octopus cooked in garlic oil, jalapeño and lime juice, finished with fresh epazote, served with mexican rice, side of frijoles refritos, fresh tortillas and a salsa of choice
Pavo con mole Xico
Pavo con pipian verde
Cecina de res natural
Cecina de cerdo enchilada

Sides
Arroz a la mexicana
Red rice, corn, carrots
Esquites preparados
Corn, mayo, Cotija cheese, chile ancho
Frijoles refritos
Refried black beans
Hongos salteado
Sauteed mushrooms, jalapeño, epazote
Rajas con crema
Poblano pepper, onion, crema

Desserts
Churros
Churros with brown sugar and cinnamon
Flan de la casa
Caramel flan
Pastel de elote
Warm corn cake with a touch of cajeta

Non Alcoholic
Coca Cola Mexican
Saratoga Flat Large
Saratoga Flat Small
Saratoga Sparkling Large
Topo Chico Sparkling Small

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+77 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+76 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

First time dining at Casa Carmen, food was delicious. Lengua, pulpo, tostada, all delicious. Great mariscos and beautiful interior. Lighting was intimate, tortillas were great. No complaints here!
November 2025
 the food was fine. I'm not a big drinker, but I took a sip of a Friend margarita when he thought it didn't have any tequila in it and I couldn't even taste the tequila and then they charged $12 for another shot to make it taste like a decent drink. It's a Mexican restaurant. They should know how to make a margarita.
November 2025
My new favorite Mexican place. Authentic Mexican, not the usual. Really thoughtful menu and super fresh ingredients - best guac I've had. Great drinks menu too. Extra bonus was how aware they are of gluten issues, and our waiter was hugely helpful informing us if the best choices for us. And overall, the service team was another reason for the 5 stars. Great place.
October 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Sagaponack - 4 W 22nd St
Seafood, Bar, American, Specialty Food, Asian Fusion
Zero Otto Nove - 15 W 21st St
Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian
COTE Korean Steakhouse - 16 W 22nd St
Steak House, Korean, Cocktail Bar, Vegan, Vegetarian

Casa Carmen Flatiron

5 W 21st St, New York, NY 10010
(917) 540-5600