City island in Harlem

94 St Nicholas Pl, New York
(646) 998-4147

Recent Reviews

A R.

The food is always fresh and delicious here! The service is so nice, all the workers are very friendly and its super attentive and fast. Definitely recommend the paella and the fish chunks.

Damien P.

Since the murder of the young unarmed man at this location. Where the worker chased the young man out in the street and murdered him. This restaurant has been on a downward spiral. The clientele has declined so often times the variety is limited here. Seafood and fish are foods that has to be fresh in order to prevent illness. I would be very cautious when purchasing foods from this establishment. That is claiming to be under new managment. Their is something fishy about this place pun intended. The Harlem area has so many seafood options to choose from. I would avoid this restaurant at all cost. A neighbor and all of her guest were recently sick after preparing fish she had purchased from here. It's no coincidence that all of her guest had food poising after her dinner party. After consuming fish from this restaurant. Seeking fresh fish with great service you wont find it here.

Cindy Y.

Fishmonger can clean the fish. Fast service. Will steam and fry for you. They have paella and ceviche there. Limited casual outdoor seating.

Massiel P.

The best seafood restaurant in Manhattan! I loved the food, staff and the place is super clean. I recommend this place completely! Can't wait to go back!

Load More