We loved our visit here and already have plans to return later in the year. The atmosphere was beautiful and intimate, the staff very attentive, and the food was divine.
Updated from previous review on 2026-01-22
JoshHyatt
All I can say is that the food, ambiance, and staff are exceptional. Prefect sized portions, pasta is like butter in your mouth, limoncello cake amazing. Definitely on my rotation for my NYC travel!
Updated from previous review on 2026-01-16
SilviaPrieto07
Amazing food! Going back for sure
KarlMeyer
Everything about my experience here was perfect. The food was outstanding, the staff were friendly & attentive, the environment was classic & the food was fast. I can’t wait until I’m back in New York City because I’ll be going straight here as soon as I arrive.
Updated from previous review on 2026-01-06
KatelynMS
We had the Fennel Pork Arancini, Whipped Ricotta Toast, Short Rib Agnolotti, Ricotta Ravioli, Strawberry Panna Cotta and Chocolate Hazelnut Dome on our first visit (yes, we will be going back).
EVERYTHING was amazing. Though I found the whipped ricotta toast to be one of the best things I've ever eaten. It had no right being so good.
vcg777
No Italian food in the US compares to Coletta!! Love the arancini, meatballs, fig pizza, pepperoni pizza, ravioli, agnolotti, rosemary bread, garlic knots…haven’t had anything there I didn’t love. Don’t even get me started on the hazelnut chocolate dome and tiramisu🤤
Updated from previous review on 2025-12-29
carolynbb
Coletta is a beautiful restaurant, and even though tables are tight, we didn't feel crowded. We had the steak and the salmon. Unbelievably good! Would never know vegan. We also had the olive rosemary bread - so good!
All the servers are very friendly.
Matthew Burke
I should have asked for our server's name, because she was wonderful. My partner said that the limoncello olive oil cake more or less brought me to tears, and im inclined to agree as that was one of the most incredible cakes ive ever had in my life. Love to see the diverse range of options the owner has created throughout his multiple restaurants, and I can't wait to come back for that cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
minnor
This is an amazing restaurant. Every bite was scrumptious. We shared a pizza margherita to start, which was too big but we ate it all because it was so good. The crust, the perfectly melted cheese, the seasonings—divine. My husband had the chunk “steak”; I had the risotto with “salmon.” As people who have not eaten animals for almost seven years, we haven’t found anything quite like this. The “salmon” had not only the taste I remember, it also the flaky texture. Uncanny. My husband loved the “steak.”We were far too full for dessert.
Updated from previous review on 2025-12-18
Ali Deambrosio
Amazing service and food! Highly recommend the rigatoni alla Norma, the garlic knots, and the tiramisu! Really can’t recommend the tiramisu enough! Also our server Lucy was so kind, patient, and attentive especially towards allergies!
This restaurant is FABULOUS! I came here with my Italian husband - and I myself I’ve lived in Italy for many years - and we were a big skeptical. Coletta exceeded our expectations big time! It’s the best vegan I’ve ever been to and better than many regular Italian restaurants of the same price range in the city.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julie
We came to celebrate my friend’s birthday and had a wonderful experience. The vegan Italian food was delicious, the atmosphere was warm, and the staff made it feel like a truly special night. Our server Kevin was so friendly and attentive and we really appreciated everyone going out of their way to celebrate my friend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barry Mizrahi
Everything was delicious with a wonderful atmosphere and stellar service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coletta Tiramisu
Mariella T
Amazing experience here. Autumn was a fantastic server and paid close attention to our table. The food was delicious and a favourite was the truffle mushroom pizza and tiramisu. I would recommend anyone to come here!
We were absolutely astonished. Each course surprised us with outrageously good flavors. Fabulous atmosphere. My husband and I kept looking at each other in disbelief as I am not a huge fan of Italian food but I am a vegan and wow the salad was the best I have ever had. The mushroom pasta was sublime and the lemon olive oil cake was the best dessert I have ever had anywhere.
We went back the next day like to little kids wanting to be sure it was real. It was.
Updated from previous review on 2025-12-09
We loved our visit here and already have plans to return later in the year. The atmosphere was beautiful and intimate, the staff very attentive, and the food was divine. Updated from previous review on 2026-01-22
All I can say is that the food, ambiance, and staff are exceptional. Prefect sized portions, pasta is like butter in your mouth, limoncello cake amazing. Definitely on my rotation for my NYC travel! Updated from previous review on 2026-01-16
Amazing food! Going back for sure
Everything about my experience here was perfect. The food was outstanding, the staff were friendly & attentive, the environment was classic & the food was fast. I can’t wait until I’m back in New York City because I’ll be going straight here as soon as I arrive. Updated from previous review on 2026-01-06
We had the Fennel Pork Arancini, Whipped Ricotta Toast, Short Rib Agnolotti, Ricotta Ravioli, Strawberry Panna Cotta and Chocolate Hazelnut Dome on our first visit (yes, we will be going back). EVERYTHING was amazing. Though I found the whipped ricotta toast to be one of the best things I've ever eaten. It had no right being so good.
No Italian food in the US compares to Coletta!! Love the arancini, meatballs, fig pizza, pepperoni pizza, ravioli, agnolotti, rosemary bread, garlic knots…haven’t had anything there I didn’t love. Don’t even get me started on the hazelnut chocolate dome and tiramisu🤤 Updated from previous review on 2025-12-29
Coletta is a beautiful restaurant, and even though tables are tight, we didn't feel crowded. We had the steak and the salmon. Unbelievably good! Would never know vegan. We also had the olive rosemary bread - so good! All the servers are very friendly.
I should have asked for our server's name, because she was wonderful. My partner said that the limoncello olive oil cake more or less brought me to tears, and im inclined to agree as that was one of the most incredible cakes ive ever had in my life.
Love to see the diverse range of options the owner has created throughout his multiple restaurants, and I can't wait to come back for that cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is an amazing restaurant. Every bite was scrumptious. We shared a pizza margherita to start, which was too big but we ate it all because it was so good. The crust, the perfectly melted cheese, the seasonings—divine. My husband had the chunk “steak”; I had the risotto with “salmon.” As people who have not eaten animals for almost seven years, we haven’t found anything quite like this. The “salmon” had not only the taste I remember, it also the flaky texture. Uncanny. My husband loved the “steak.”We were far too full for dessert. Updated from previous review on 2025-12-18
Amazing service and food! Highly recommend the rigatoni alla Norma, the garlic knots, and the tiramisu! Really can’t recommend the tiramisu enough! Also our server Lucy was so kind, patient, and attentive especially towards allergies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This restaurant is FABULOUS! I came here with my Italian husband - and I myself I’ve lived in Italy for many years - and we were a big skeptical. Coletta exceeded our expectations big time! It’s the best vegan I’ve ever been to and better than many regular Italian restaurants of the same price range in the city.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We came to celebrate my friend’s birthday and had a wonderful experience. The vegan Italian food was delicious, the atmosphere was warm, and the staff made it feel like a truly special night. Our server Kevin was so friendly and attentive and we really appreciated everyone going out of their way to celebrate my friend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything was delicious with a wonderful atmosphere and stellar service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coletta Tiramisu
Amazing experience here. Autumn was a fantastic server and paid close attention to our table. The food was delicious and a favourite was the truffle mushroom pizza and tiramisu. I would recommend anyone to come here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coletta Tiramisu, Wild Mushroom Truffle Pizza
We were absolutely astonished. Each course surprised us with outrageously good flavors. Fabulous atmosphere. My husband and I kept looking at each other in disbelief as I am not a huge fan of Italian food but I am a vegan and wow the salad was the best I have ever had. The mushroom pasta was sublime and the lemon olive oil cake was the best dessert I have ever had anywhere. We went back the next day like to little kids wanting to be sure it was real. It was. Updated from previous review on 2025-12-09
Loading...