Come Prima
903 Madison Ave, New York
(212) 517-7700
Customers' Favorites
Gamberi E Zucchine Grigliate
Spinach Ravioli
Risotto Risotto
Caprese Salad
Rack of Lamb
Panna Cotta
Lamb Chops
Carpaccio
Tiramisu
Cannoli
Menu
Photos
+68 photos
+67 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Nick and Sal and the rest of the crew at Come Prima are like family to all of us. Stranger or long time friend they welcome all with open arms and serve some of the best Italian food in New York. Don’t pass this place up when you are walking around Madison or visiting the Frick. You won’t regret that you stopped in for a visit.
Great ambience with very attentive hosts Nicola and Salvatore - we did “the experience” and were able to sample so many different dishes - fast service - laughter and good food !
An Unexpected and Absolutely Delicious Evening!
We stumbled upon Come Prima and were completely blown away by the experience. Every dish we tried was a standout. The burrata was impossibly creamy, the mushroom risotto was rich and comforting, and the scaloppine piccata with spinach had just the right amount of heat. We finished with the tartufo dessert, which was the perfect indulgent end to the meal.
A bottle of Vermentino complemented everything...
We stumbled upon Come Prima and were completely blown away by the experience. Every dish we tried was a standout. The burrata was impossibly creamy, the mushroom risotto was rich and comforting, and the scaloppine piccata with spinach had just the right amount of heat. We finished with the tartufo dessert, which was the perfect indulgent end to the meal.
A bottle of Vermentino complemented everything...
You May Also Like
Via Quadronno - 25 E 73rd St
![]()
Italian, Cafe, Vegan, Vegetarian
Ralph's Coffee - 888 Madison Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee, Pet Friendly
Caravaggio - 23 E 74th St
![]()
Italian, Venues & Event Spaces, Cocktail Bar, Vegan