Conmigo

1410 Madison Ave, New York
(212) 368-1684

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Eric Marcantonio

Came here for a quick take out meal, I was sitting at the bar and the bartender was extremely friendly. Food is great! Atmosphere and music are perfect. Highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tracey M

Did my lap around the reservoir and worked up a real hankerin’ for shrimp tacos. Slid over to Conmigo on the UES. Had a margarita, classic and crisp. Then the tacos hit Spicy, fresh, shrimp cooked just right. Chips ‘n guac on the side? Delish. Simple, solid, exactly what I needed. this place is definitely worth the NYC walk.

Great music pumping through the speakers and a shout out to the bartender on duty. He was running the entire front of the house bartender, host, waiter, food pickups. he also was kind enough to make me a drink that wasn't on the menu anymore and it did not disappoint!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Phatty Chunk

An ok establishment.

Cinnamon Willis

They have a great taco Tuesday special. The ambiance was nice and chill and tacos were delish

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rebecca Katz

Best burger I’ve ever had. Great atmosphere, very aesthetic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tash _

Place looks nice but that’s it. No chips and salsa for the table. Flautas were tasteless and quesadilla had nothing with it no pico de gallo guac or any other usual stuff. Not worth the price. Waiter didn’t speak Spanish and barely understood English. the vibe wasn’t there at all. Would not return.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 1

Andrea

I honestly don’t understand how this place has so many good reviews. I went in on July 3 and ordered two chicken and carnitas tacos for myself and my kid. Big mistake. I ended up with terrible food poisoning, and my child was vomiting nonstop. 🚫 If you can avoid this place, please do.

The service was slow, and the food was awful—cold, overcooked, and honestly looked like leftovers. Two tacos for $15? Definitely not worth it. I’m never coming back.

Food: 1

Christine S

The Mexican corn slapped. My chicken flauta was overcooked. The brisket burrito was where it was at. Couldn’t get tacos here, 2 for $15 is not a good deal.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Patrick van Kessel

Absolutely delicious, with some real standout dishes (the tuna tartare was unlike anything I've ever had) - an all around fantastic TexMex gem!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yuezhe Li

Cute place with wonderful guacamole and lovely tacos. Loved the mushroom taco.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tammy Vel

The best smash burger ever and the salad it came with was fresh and delicious. Good service and atmosphere but the entree stole the show.

Nick McCaskill

Oddly empty when we showed up, and even more strange considering how freaking good it was. My wife & I split the burrito & the chicken tacos 🤤 We also got the rice & beans and chips and salsa and were stuffed. We will absolutely be back.

Lin Avril

Great value and quality — highly recommended!

Cameron Eaton

Staff is friendly enough but the service here is so, so slow—even if it’s not busy. I’m talking: by the time your drinks finally come, the food comes right after (so like a 15-minute wait for drinks, which everyone in the industry knows should arrive much sooner); servers don’t really check back on the table, and when you are able to flag them down for the check, it doesn’t come until you remind them again another probably 15 minutes later. And I don’t exaggerate. The tacos and quesadilla taste great, though! The rice and beans, here, however, are way over priced and could easily be made at home with canned beans and sazón

NANCY OCONNELL

Place is nothing great. Dribble were horrible. Food was ok. Not a menu you would find most things in other Mexican restaurants

Loading...