Crave Fishbar

428 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(646) 494-2750

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Crave Fishbar's Famous Chocolate Chip Cookie
East and West Coast Oyster Sampler
Rice Dusted Point Judith Calamari
Nashville Style Crispy Fish Tacos
Chocolate Cookie with Ice Cream
Handmade Squid Ink Spaghetti
East and West Coast Oysters
Salmon Sashimi Tostada
Nye Grilled Octopus
East Coast Oyster

Menu

RETURNABLE REUSABLE PACKAGING
Use DeliverZero containers, please
Fight climate change and reduce waste; get your order in returnable, reusable containers. Return the containers to any DeliverZero drop point or at your door within 3 weeks, and the containers will be thoroughly sanitized and reused. We will need to share certain info such as phone, email, and names with DeliverZero. DeliverZero provides its service in accordance with the terms available at www.deliverzero.com/terms and will process your personal information in accordance with its privacy policy available at www.deliverzero.com/privacy.

RAW BAR / SUSHI
East Coast Oyster
half dozen freshly shucked east coast served with lemon, packed over ice (gf)
Colossal Shrimp Cocktail (3pc)
colossal shrimp cocktail (3 pieces) (gf, s)
Littleneck Clams
6 pieces
Fluke Nigiri
tahini sesame lime, tamari soy, grated ginger
Spicy Tuna Sushi Roll
hand chopped tuna, calabrian chili, broccoli rabe 6pcs
Cherrystone Clams (6pieces)
Our large cherry stone clams are served 6 pieces in an order
Jonah Crab Claws
1/2 LB (2-4pcs) Served with cocktail sauce and mustard remoulade

APPETIZERS
Cauliflower Soup
cauliflower puree, chive gremolata, crispy fried oyster (gf, s)
Rice Dusted Point Judith Calamari
thai miso sauce, mung bean sprouts, aleppo chile (gf)
Nashville Style Crispy Fish Tacos
cabbage, buttermilk dressing, cilantro, spicy, two tacos (gf, s)
Salmon Sashimi Tostada
avocado puree, calabrian chili oil, grapefruit, crispy shallots
Little Gem Lettuce (GF)
red endive, romano beans, breakfast radish, goat gouda, roasted pistachios, spring garlic vinaigrette
Plancha Grilled Octopus
roasted sweet potato, roasted fennel, red wine vinaigrette, fennel pollen
Glazed Baby Back Ribs

ENTREES
Oven Roasted Barramundi
Oven roasted barramundi, miso honey glaze, jumbo asparagus, chipotle oil
Maine Lobster Roll
spicy avocado garlic aioli, warm butter, orwasher's top split bun, hand cut french fries (s)
Handmade Squid Ink Spaghetti
chopped shrimp, spring garlic, fresno chile, clam stock (s)
Calabresi Fusilli with Jonah Crab
lemon, shredded brussel sprouts, thai basil, ricotta salata, calabrian chili
Homemade Cavatelli
vine ripened tomato ragout, whipped ricotta, basil purée
Lobster Curry
chu chee curry, charred red onion, japanese eggplant, thai apple eggplant, fresh bamboo shoots (gf, s)
Grilled Faroe Islands Salmon
oyster mushrooms, grilled onions, oven roasted spinach, pommery mustard
Seared Rare #1 Yellowfin Tuna

SIDES
Hand Cut Fries
hand cut, served with ketchup
Brussels Sprouts
chorizo vinaigrette (gf)
Garlic Chive Griddled Rice
snap pea, egg (gf)
Cauliflower
Za'atar roasted cauliflower with thaini & jalapeno sauce

DESSERTS
CFB Cookie
our famous homemade chocolate chip cookie, baked daily
Cookie Package
four of our famous homemade chocolate chip cookies, baked daily
Magnolia's Classic Banana Pudding
World's famous banana pudding: creamy vanilla pudding layers with vanilla wafers and fresh bananas
Magnolia's Red Velvet Cheesecake
Rich, chocolatey, and subtly tart cheese rests on a chocolate cookie crumb crust, with a dollop of whipped cream and chocolate shavings on top.

KIDS
Kid's Cavatelli with Butter
Kid's Cavatelli with Red Sauce
Kid's Barramundi Fish Sticks
Kid's Salmon
Kid's Menu & Crayons
Our in house menu for coloring and games. Comes with a pack of 4 crayons

Photos

Photo credit: ubereats
Photo credit: ubereats
Photo credit: google
+85 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+84 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I came here on Saturday night in mid July for a 745pm dinner a pleasant weather day with two other people. The reservation for the restaurant was booked less a week prior. The restaurant didn’t seem to be close to full at any point during our experience so a reservation might not always be needed. Note that is table seating in the front bar area as well as in the primary dining room, in addition to outside seating.

I really wanted to like this restaurant....
July 2025
I was suggested to come to crave fish bar. I absolutely love the ambience and the fresh seafood. The staff is so welcoming and friendly. It is amazing to feel so comfortable somewhere in New York City! Love supporting local restaurants and fisherman, kyle and maya were brilliant! Love this place thank u for the great hospitality!!!!!!! The oysters 🦪 were from Long Island !! Felt so good 😊.
March 2025
Food was delicious, and entree portions were relatively generous. Pricey, but can be expected for a seafood restaurant. Service was fast and accommodating. I’d recommend sitting in the back half of the restaurant for a more intimate setting. The crab sushi was delicious!
March 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Two Wheels Vietnamese - 426 Amsterdam Ave
Vietnamese, Vegan
Luke's Lobster Upper West Side - 426 Amsterdam Ave
Seafood, Soup, Vegetarian
Jake's Dilemma - 430 Amsterdam Ave
Sports Bar, American, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly

Crave Fishbar

428 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
(646) 494-2750