Croton Reservoir Tavern

108 W 40th St, New York
(212) 997-6835

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Nancy Obrien

Great food and atmosphere. Highly recommend going for a night out or friendly gathering

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David

Nice place, limited regular seating, majority are bar chair height including the banquets. Menu was nothing to brag about but basic stuff with a slight flair. Nothing major and portions were on the smaller side. Good restaurant with good food nothing more.

Philippe Trang

One of my local joints. Service is exceptional. Say hi to Sarah when you visit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Oswer

Luis is a 10/10 server, ask for him when you get there

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shanna Lee

Had happy hour here, and it was a good time! Luis our server was friendly and attentive. Food and drinks were great! Will come back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vanessa Morales

Drinks, food, and service were good. Nice place to go after work for some drinks with coworkers or friends. Lively yet not too crowded or noisy

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Remy Fenster

Good drinks in a comfortable atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tavern Burger, Veggie Burger, Crispy Crab Cake Sandwich

Rob

I had a reservation and glad I did cause place was crowded. Our server Casey was attentive and very nice. Convenient location and good selection of beers and pub type food. I e been here before and will come back again. I'm

Mike

Had the fixed menu and it was great! Skipped the wine deal because the Cabernet on that deal wasn't one of my favorites. Should add a Chardonnay to that instead of just a Pinot Grigio. Overall great experience and food!

Andres

This place is a bit outdated in the inside. The service was great, very nice waiters. I ordered a Greek salad and added a chicken breast. The chicken was dry and the vegetables in the salad didn't seem fresh. The salad also had a rice base which I've never seen on a Greek salad. I paid $35 bucks all in for a mediocre salad; would not recommend.

Ali

At 8:15 pm, we seated 10 people. Great service! Artichoke dip was tasty. Hamburgers were big!

Garrison Pease

I go there for their original/house beer on tap and the pretzel, an excellent respite near Bryant Park.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joanne

Great lunch, food was delicious. Our server Sarah was so friendly so helpful so attentive. She overall made our experience that much better. 

Dawn

My Group had a wide variety of options delivered to the table. The consensus determined the Brisket is to die for!

Michele

Burgers were delicious! Convenient location near Bryant Park. I liked the ambience but it was a bit loud at dinner time and it made it difficult at times to hear my dining partners. With that said, I do plan to come back again. I live in the neighborhood!

Loading...