Pizza has gone downhill in quality - along with that 4 slices with topping and a soda / water 38 dollars. Kinda disappointed this place was a mainstay for a few decades until recently for me.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
J-Review
This place is proof that you can have BAD pizza in New York. It’s true! They try to get rid of old pizza by recooking it. Unless you complain, you end up eating horribly burnt, day-old, pizza. Minus one star was not available. Horrible pizza. Stay away!
Ash N. Patel
This is the pizza spot for those going in and out of penn station on a regular basis. Had countless slices here over the years. It’s always moving fast and the pizza is delicious. I hope they stick around for a long time.
Gerry
Great sub shop snacks beer drinks sweets but unique thing is they make subs with GLUTEN FREE SUB ROLLS!!!! you can’t find better!!!
senthil kumar
SCAMMER ALERT 🥶 I gave my debit card for 15 USD. They debited money and I got a message debited SMS and it reflected my bank application too. The cashier printed the receipt, but When I asked for a receipt they said money declined, I gave my phone SMS and bank application for evidence but they refused to give me evidence of payment declined. After a long argument they denied the order. These people are earning money by doing fraudulent transactions. 😡🤬 Save your money.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Nix Feeley
pizza was incredible and staff was very friendly, they saw us looking and invited us in and were joking with us after. baseball game was also on. very enjoyable experience while waiting for the train however a little pricey but i’d say it was worth it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Michael Tarselli
Pizza was fine; took a while to get. Drink options limited. Staff were a bit tough to talk with. Looks like a broad array of flavors, though I only tried the mushroom. Was fine.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Vegetable Pizza
Xio
The pizza here is so good and fresh. The crust is thin and crispy. I've gone to many pizzerias in NY, and they've all disappointed me except for this one. Many of the pizzerias have weird toppings and unappealing dough except for this one. This is the holy grail right here. The sauce they have is magical it is so good. If you're hungry for pizza and you're in the station, you need to stop by.
Jackson Snyder
This one of my favorite pizza places of all time. Whenever I go to Penn Station, I always stop by here to get a slice. Now the service is nothing special, but the food is. They have basically any pizza you can think of and while the variety is really good, the plain, New York Style pizza is my favorite. Now there are better pizza places that attract tourists such as Joe's Pizza, 2Bros (for the price), John's of Bleeker street, Best Pizza, and Lucali's however many of those places have very long lines and aren't nearly as convenient. And the pizza at Don Pepi's is still very good, its fresh and defined, every ingredient speaks for itself, but nothing too rich, its very casual pizza. Depending on which pizza you get, the crust will be different, but if you buy the NY style pizza, the crust is crispy, but not hard and crunchy. If you have the time to eat here without missing the train, I would recommend going here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Enrique Infante
Best pizza in Penn Station. Hot and fresh right out the oven.
The children were sitting eating food on the other side. I told him to sit down until I finished buying a pizza that I was charging for. He told two children to stand up without asking if he was with anyone later. He comes to the register and charges me. I ask him why they have to leave if I am paying for a pizza. I felt very uncomfortable. and very humiliated.
PHILLFS
Good warm pizza and hot sandwiches !
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eric Gill
Had an amazing pepperoni slice yesterday. Always solid, great service.
Alex M
Perfect pizza. Went to several in NYC that were recommended to me and Don Pepi ended up being my family ?
Pizza has gone downhill in quality - along with that 4 slices with topping and a soda / water 38 dollars. Kinda disappointed this place was a mainstay for a few decades until recently for me.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
This place is proof that you can have BAD pizza in New York. It’s true! They try to get rid of old pizza by recooking it. Unless you complain, you end up eating horribly burnt, day-old, pizza. Minus one star was not available. Horrible pizza. Stay away!
This is the pizza spot for those going in and out of penn station on a regular basis. Had countless slices here over the years. It’s always moving fast and the pizza is delicious. I hope they stick around for a long time.
Great sub shop snacks beer drinks sweets but unique thing is they make subs with GLUTEN FREE SUB ROLLS!!!! you can’t find better!!!
SCAMMER ALERT 🥶 I gave my debit card for 15 USD. They debited money and I got a message debited SMS and it reflected my bank application too. The cashier printed the receipt, but When I asked for a receipt they said money declined, I gave my phone SMS and bank application for evidence but they refused to give me evidence of payment declined. After a long argument they denied the order. These people are earning money by doing fraudulent transactions. 😡🤬 Save your money.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
pizza was incredible and staff was very friendly, they saw us looking and invited us in and were joking with us after. baseball game was also on. very enjoyable experience while waiting for the train however a little pricey but i’d say it was worth it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Pizza was fine; took a while to get. Drink options limited. Staff were a bit tough to talk with. Looks like a broad array of flavors, though I only tried the mushroom. Was fine.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Vegetable Pizza
The pizza here is so good and fresh. The crust is thin and crispy. I've gone to many pizzerias in NY, and they've all disappointed me except for this one. Many of the pizzerias have weird toppings and unappealing dough except for this one. This is the holy grail right here. The sauce they have is magical it is so good. If you're hungry for pizza and you're in the station, you need to stop by.
This one of my favorite pizza places of all time. Whenever I go to Penn Station, I always stop by here to get a slice. Now the service is nothing special, but the food is. They have basically any pizza you can think of and while the variety is really good, the plain, New York Style pizza is my favorite. Now there are better pizza places that attract tourists such as Joe's Pizza, 2Bros (for the price), John's of Bleeker street, Best Pizza, and Lucali's however many of those places have very long lines and aren't nearly as convenient. And the pizza at Don Pepi's is still very good, its fresh and defined, every ingredient speaks for itself, but nothing too rich, its very casual pizza. Depending on which pizza you get, the crust will be different, but if you buy the NY style pizza, the crust is crispy, but not hard and crunchy. If you have the time to eat here without missing the train, I would recommend going here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Best pizza in Penn Station. Hot and fresh right out the oven.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
The children were sitting eating food on the other side. I told him to sit down until I finished buying a pizza that I was charging for. He told two children to stand up without asking if he was with anyone later. He comes to the register and charges me. I ask him why they have to leave if I am paying for a pizza. I felt very uncomfortable. and very humiliated.
Good warm pizza and hot sandwiches !
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had an amazing pepperoni slice yesterday. Always solid, great service.
Perfect pizza. Went to several in NYC that were recommended to me and Don Pepi ended up being my family ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Best pizza in New York. Wish they came to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...