Duomo51

25 W 51st St 7th floor, New York
(646) 398-8098

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Antonio Holland

Food was “hotel” quality. Overpriced, lack of taste and poor quality. Additionally they tried to double tip us with applying auto gratuity and did not tell us at all. Would not recommend, plenty of other better brunch spots in the city.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

O V

Wonderful place and amazing food & service.
The place to be if you are in New York.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

korra dale

Food was flavorful (great truffle dishes and apps), service was excellent and welcoming, atmosphere nice and modern with rooftop charm. Worth it for Italian in Midtown.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Edward

This was a cool place. Food was delicious for a small place. Hard to find but the ambiance was cool. We didn't get the best view of the church but the food made up for it.

mio

Both food and service are equally bad and we still tipped 30%

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Oscar Flores

Walked in and glasses were dirty so I asked for new ones. Food was mid, at least the bread was good. Not sure how it has high reviews…definitely not upscale.

Laura Bennett

Ate here when seeing a show nearby at Radio City Music Hall. Pasta definitely was fresh and tasted homemade like places I've eaten in Italy, it did take awhile to come out but when it did it was piping hot and cooked perfectly. Our server was so polite and communicative. Would definitely eat here again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gabrielle

Loved the lychee martini and grilled calamari. Lola and Alsi were great with the service they provided me and my sister. Definitely coming back again!

Christian Agosto

Service and food were amazing. Treated us like royalty. I’ll definitely be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fabricio Barrios

Delicoius food, kind place! Hiper recommended!!!
The tiramisu, soooo good! bolognese and Carbonara, amazing! Very good point of cook!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bolognese, Caesar Salad, Ravioli Di Burrata Al Tartufo

JV Young

We decided to do a museum weekend and stayed at a hotel right by Rockefeller Center.

We came back from a lot of walking, and decided we would have dinner at this restaurant right at the hotel. The front desk made a reservation for us, and we arrived a little early but were seated right away.

It was very cold outside, and they did have patio seating which gave a little draft where we were seated. It wasn't bad, and as the night went on, it got comfortable.

The place was pretty full, and even the colder patio area seemed to be packed, but service was spot on.

I accidentally dropped a bread plate, and before I could lean over and pick it up, one of the other servers had already picked it up, while another slid a replacement plate from another table onto ours, and another server replaced that one. It happened so quick, but I felt was really remarkable after I had observed the whole thing. I was tempted to drop something else, but restrained myself.

Started off with a couple of cocktails, then appetizers, and the main courses. Everything came out timely, and very well prepared. Not once did I have to get someone's attention for anything. Our waiter was always nearby and very attentive, but not hovering.

The martinis were perfect and almost went down too easily. The Polpo was perfectly grilled and had a nice delicate bite. I'm a fan of goat cheese in my salad, so we got the Duomo51, which had some blueberries and a light lemon dressing which was just right. My better half had the Lobster Ravioli special, and I had the Ribeye. This arrived very hot with a great sear, but medium rare as I ordered it. They had sliced it while on the bone before grilling, so each piece was nicely crusted and medium rare. We skipped dessert, but did have a couple more martinis. They were delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: duomo51

Janine Hosseini

Other than that they did not have a record of our reservation when we arrived on Christmas Eve (AHHHH!), it was perfect. My daughter fortunately had emails confirming our reservation, so all went well. Food was excellent and portions were very generous. Within walking distance to St. Patrick's Cathedral, it was the perfect place for dinner prior to midnight mass.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

M3ali 876

The servant was rude and the view tables area was not nice ,, the food was delicious and the portion was perfect

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Mary Galyon

Chris was a phenomenal server! Our food was hot and delicious. He made recommendations not only on the menu but on our drinks as well. When I asked where the bathroom was, he walked me to the door that led to it and gave clear directions to find it. We simply adore Chris and would come back just for him!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Chuck Khuen

Attentive service, good food, nicely decorated and quiet enough for talking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...