Everything you want, everything you need. Bonus points for handing my phone back at the end of the night.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Ralph Young
The best bar in Manhattan, periodt. Take a pic of your ticket.
Scott Gabrielle
A true institution of the NYC leather scene, The Eagle is an iconic bar that has evolved over time to offer something for everyone. While it maintains its classic, dark, and cruisy atmosphere—a nod to its leather bar roots—it’s also a fantastic place to dance, hang out with friends, or simply grab a drink and see what happens. The atmosphere is unpretentious and welcoming, making it a reliable destination whether you’re a regular or a first-timer.
Michael Donato
A lot of fun!
Lucas Toledo
Free before 9pm, but they will suddenly take their damn time to ID people when it's almost 9pm, so if you're here by 8:50pm the line will SuDdEnLy take extra long to have their ID checked, and they will charge you cover, even on an empty night. Total BS. Very rude staff, elongates the wait time just to charge patrons 😮💨😤😡😞 I'm not paying a cover at 9pm on the dot because you can't scan IDs or manage the queue properly. Bartenders will not give you free water even if you have ordered several drinks from the same bartender (and tipped generously) 😢 Cash only bar and cover. Additional coat check charge.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Christopher Schwartz
It's the Eagle. If you're looking it up, you know what it is and it's the best that NYC has for this type of venue. At least one that's open every night.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Mario
Great music Had an amazing time
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Diego Omar
Last Sunday, I paid twenty dollars just to walk into Eagle NYC. The doorman greeted me with unnecessary rudeness, dismissing me simply because I was clueless about the occasion, and looked a little distracted for that night’s theme. The doorman’s bad attitude set the tone before I even made it upstairs. On the second floor, the scene was a raw marketplace of flesh, shirtless men circling restlessly in search of sex. That’s nothing new at that venue, but I wasn't expecting a meat market on a Sunday night. I wanted to enjoy the evening calmly, maybe have a drink, have a conversation, but that wasn’t the rhythm the bar was offering. I could see myself going back for a social leather-themed event only. I have my own gear and I’m familiar with some faces. But beyond that, the dynamic of relentless pursuit isn’t for me. The night before, though, was a different story. My time at Ty’s was extraordinary. The atmosphere was social, the crowd was approachable, and I felt entirely at ease. Ty’s reminded me that a bar can still be about connection beyond sex. Given the rapid speed of gentrification in Chelsea, I give NYC Eagle five more years before it ceases operations. That’s why they are milking the cow as much as they can with the high charges.
I love this place. I lost my wallet there on a Friday. They had it safe and sound with the $112.00 bucks in cash I still had in it when I came back on the following night. That’s amazing. Props to the crew. It’s stressful losing your IID/ccds. Thanks Eagle 😘
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Nicolas Cavalli
We went on a Sunday. Roof top was fun, had a chat with some guys and got in the mood for later. It became very cruisy at the bar with a nice mix of people. Was pretty full and so much fun. Also the dance floor was nice.
Tonci Antunovic
my favorite gay club in nyc. sundays and wednesdays are the best
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
BohDan Ovcharenko
The music? On point. The crowd? Delicious. And the staff? Sweethearts with just the right edge—made the whole night feel extra special. Can’t wait to be back for more. 😘✨
Everything you want, everything you need. Bonus points for handing my phone back at the end of the night.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
The best bar in Manhattan, periodt. Take a pic of your ticket.
A true institution of the NYC leather scene, The Eagle is an iconic bar that has evolved over time to offer something for everyone. While it maintains its classic, dark, and cruisy atmosphere—a nod to its leather bar roots—it’s also a fantastic place to dance, hang out with friends, or simply grab a drink and see what happens. The atmosphere is unpretentious and welcoming, making it a reliable destination whether you’re a regular or a first-timer.
A lot of fun!
Free before 9pm, but they will suddenly take their damn time to ID people when it's almost 9pm, so if you're here by 8:50pm the line will SuDdEnLy take extra long to have their ID checked, and they will charge you cover, even on an empty night.
Total BS.
Very rude staff, elongates the wait time just to charge patrons 😮💨😤😡😞
I'm not paying a cover at 9pm on the dot because you can't scan IDs or manage the queue properly.
Bartenders will not give you free water even if you have ordered several drinks from the same bartender (and tipped generously) 😢
Cash only bar and cover.
Additional coat check charge.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
It's the Eagle. If you're looking it up, you know what it is and it's the best that NYC has for this type of venue. At least one that's open every night.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Great music Had an amazing time
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Last Sunday, I paid twenty dollars just to walk into Eagle NYC. The doorman greeted me with unnecessary rudeness, dismissing me simply because I was clueless about the occasion, and looked a little distracted for that night’s theme. The doorman’s bad attitude set the tone before I even made it upstairs. On the second floor, the scene was a raw marketplace of flesh, shirtless men circling restlessly in search of sex. That’s nothing new at that venue, but I wasn't expecting a meat market on a Sunday night. I wanted to enjoy the evening calmly, maybe have a drink, have a conversation, but that wasn’t the rhythm the bar was offering. I could see myself going back for a social leather-themed event only. I have my own gear and I’m familiar with some faces. But beyond that, the dynamic of relentless pursuit isn’t for me. The night before, though, was a different story. My time at Ty’s was extraordinary. The atmosphere was social, the crowd was approachable, and I felt entirely at ease. Ty’s reminded me that a bar can still be about connection beyond sex. Given the rapid speed of gentrification in Chelsea, I give NYC Eagle five more years before it ceases operations. That’s why they are milking the cow as much as they can with the high charges.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Always fun!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
By far the best gay club in whole country
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
A must
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love this place. I lost my wallet there on a Friday. They had it safe and sound with the $112.00 bucks in cash I still had in it when I came back on the following night. That’s amazing. Props to the crew. It’s stressful losing your IID/ccds. Thanks Eagle 😘
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
We went on a Sunday. Roof top was fun, had a chat with some guys and got in the mood for later. It became very cruisy at the bar with a nice mix of people. Was pretty full and so much fun.
Also the dance floor was nice.
my favorite gay club in nyc. sundays and wednesdays are the best
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
The music? On point. The crowd? Delicious. And the staff? Sweethearts with just the right edge—made the whole night feel extra special. Can’t wait to be back for more. 😘✨
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...