Taking a star away, not because of the staff, but the cut throat, overdramatic Hells Kitchen 20-30yo Queens. Otherwise amazing place to get laid. @BootedPigBro on X and Tele
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 5
Mike the Explorer
It used to be better years ago.
Atmosphere: 2
Service: 1
Hyena Hallstrom
Got cruised to some dude's hotel room in times square, BF got lightly molested. Fun dark rooms and overall good times beaides that incident.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Logan Elkins
Had a fantastic time last night. Great music and plenty of room to get around. I lost my phone at one point and the staff found it! So grateful… the bartenders and staff were super nice. Looking forward to next time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karl
If you're on the fence about going to Eagle, well just hop off already and get your bum over there. I finally did and realized I had been missing out all this time. This fantastically grungy place is fueled by a mix of thumping beats, leather harnesses, and shirtless men. Even at its busiest, the vibe stays open, fun, and surprisingly well organized.
The Wednesday before thanksgiving is apparently known for being the busiest night at the Eagle, and this year's record crowd should have sunk the whole operation, but the staff kept the entire production going smoothly like it was rehearsed.
The Eagle's security team deserves direct credit. They managed an impossibly massive crowd without a hitch. Even with thousands trying to get in, the kilometric entrance line and the coat check line that stretched to the roof moved smoothly and never descended into chaos. Dan in particular handled a near-impossible task: recovering my smartwatch from a crowd so packed I had assumed it was gone for good. He somehow retrieved it, safeguarded it, and returned it to me with the utmost professionalism.
Music is solid. The vibe is leather and musk. The inclusivity is not just a tag line but a daily practice. This bar deserves every positive review on this app. Ignore the haters. Peace!
Jake Thonis
Boooooo the bartender on the third floor sucked, he refused to serve us tap water after we bought 5 total drinks and tipped him at least 12 dollars. He called us names and was generally aggresive in a way that makes me never want to come back here. Bad job hiring him. You all suck for making that decision. He was shirtless and gross
Michael Whitbread
This is an unsafe venue. A patron randomly approached me on Saturday November 15, 2025, and wrenched the back of my neck. I shook him off and elbowed his breast plate. I looked around and there were no security staff anywhere.
It will be a long time before I feel safe going to the Eagle NYC again.
Keep your wits about you, New York. Evil stalks these streets.
Update 11/18/25: A report has now been filed with the NYPD.
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 1
Alexander Balderas S .
Nice place . Lots of fun, cool guys . But one small red bull for $9 ???? I’m not crying lol but I think it’s a little bit overpriced.
This past Sunday I lost my sunglasses and the awesome security team found it, they treated me so well a 10/10 service, I really recommend going to this club if you want to have a great time with friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Mario Montenegro
Always a great time when I go... love ending the night here 😆
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
rob allen
This🎽s just tje entry
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brando Munoz
Bad serivee bad serice I was just went with my best friend and the security guard was really bad attention. It’s a bad place Bad welcome to the people nev we come back
Damn hot!
Atmosphere: 5
Taking a star away, not because of the staff, but the cut throat, overdramatic Hells Kitchen 20-30yo Queens. Otherwise amazing place to get laid. @BootedPigBro on X and Tele
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 5
It used to be better years ago.
Atmosphere: 2
Service: 1
Got cruised to some dude's hotel room in times square, BF got lightly molested. Fun dark rooms and overall good times beaides that incident.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Had a fantastic time last night. Great music and plenty of room to get around. I lost my phone at one point and the staff found it! So grateful… the bartenders and staff were super nice. Looking forward to next time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you're on the fence about going to Eagle, well just hop off already and get your bum over there. I finally did and realized I had been missing out all this time. This fantastically grungy place is fueled by a mix of thumping beats, leather harnesses, and shirtless men. Even at its busiest, the vibe stays open, fun, and surprisingly well organized.
The Wednesday before thanksgiving is apparently known for being the busiest night at the Eagle, and this year's record crowd should have sunk the whole operation, but the staff kept the entire production going smoothly like it was rehearsed.
The Eagle's security team deserves direct credit. They managed an impossibly massive crowd without a hitch. Even with thousands trying to get in, the kilometric entrance line and the coat check line that stretched to the roof moved smoothly and never descended into chaos. Dan in particular handled a near-impossible task: recovering my smartwatch from a crowd so packed I had assumed it was gone for good. He somehow retrieved it, safeguarded it, and returned it to me with the utmost professionalism.
Music is solid. The vibe is leather and musk. The inclusivity is not just a tag line but a daily practice. This bar deserves every positive review on this app. Ignore the haters. Peace!
Boooooo the bartender on the third floor sucked, he refused to serve us tap water after we bought 5 total drinks and tipped him at least 12 dollars. He called us names and was generally aggresive in a way that makes me never want to come back here. Bad job hiring him. You all suck for making that decision. He was shirtless and gross
This is an unsafe venue. A patron randomly approached me on Saturday November 15, 2025, and wrenched the back of my neck. I shook him off and elbowed his breast plate. I looked around and there were no security staff anywhere.
It will be a long time before I feel safe going to the Eagle NYC again.
Keep your wits about you, New York. Evil stalks these streets.
Update 11/18/25: A report has now been filed with the NYPD.
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 1
Nice place . Lots of fun, cool guys . But one small red bull for $9 ???? I’m not crying lol but I think it’s a little bit overpriced.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
The real leather bar
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
A fun night
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 5
This past Sunday I lost my sunglasses and the awesome security team found it, they treated me so well a 10/10 service, I really recommend going to this club if you want to have a great time with friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Always a great time when I go... love ending the night here 😆
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This🎽s just tje entry
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bad serivee bad serice I was just went with my best friend and the security guard was really bad attention. It’s a bad place
Bad welcome to the people nev we come back
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...