Eleni’s

226 3rd Ave, New York
(212) 982-9030

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Fettuccine Shrimp
Chicken Souvlaki
Mediterranean Pie
Chocolate Mousse
Horiatiki Salad
Galaktoboureko
Fried Calamari
Sal Anthony's
Eleni's Chips
Shrimp Pasta

Menu

Appetizer-
Avgolemono Soup
CLASSIC ORGANIC EGG-LEMON SOUP WITH CHICKEN STOCK AND ORZO
Calamarakia
CHOICE OF FRIED OR GRILLED; EXTRA VIRGIN OLIVE OIL AND LEMON SAUCE
Dolmadakia
GRAPE LEAVES STUFFED WITH RICE, PINE NUTS, RAISINS, AND EXTRA VIRGIN OLIVE OIL, SERVED ON A BED OF TZATZIKI
Eleni's Chips
ORGANIC ZUCCHINI & EGGPLANT CHIPS WITH TZATZIKI
Garides Saganaki
BRAISED JUMBO SHRIMP IN FRESH TOMATO SAUCE, MELTED GREEK FETA CHEESE AND ORGANIC HERBS
Garides Sharas
GRILLED JUMBO SHRIMP DRESSED WITH EXTRA VIRGIN OLIVE OIL AND HERBS
Gigantes
BRAISED IMPORTED GIANT GREEK LIMA BEANS WITH TRADITIONAL TOMATO SAUCE
Halloumi
SEMI-HARD SEARED CHEESE, TOPPED WITH CAPERS AND CITRUS MUSTARD VINAIGRETTE
Htenia
SEARED DIVER SCALLOPS ON A BED OF FAVA PUREE
Imam
ROASTED EGGPLANT, CARAMELIZED ONIONS; IN ORGANIC TOMATO SAUCE, HERBS AND OLIVE OIL
Keftedes
GREEK STYLE MEAT BALLS SLOW ROASTED IN TOMATO SAUCE
Melitzana Feta
ROASTED EGGPLANT ROLLED AND STUFFED WITH FETA CHEESE, TOMATO SAUCE AND ORGANIC PARSLEY
Mussels
STEAMED IN THE SHELL; CHOICE OF: TOMATO SAUCE OR WHITE SAUCE, FETA, FRESH HERBS
Octopodi Sharas
MEDITERRANEAN GRILLED OCTOPUS, ONIONS, CAPERS, FAVA PUREE, LEMON AND HERBS
Pikilia
TRADITIONAL GREEK SPREADS; TARAMA (CARP ROE), MELITZANOSALATA (EGGPLANT DIP), SPICY FETA AND TZATZIKI; SURROUNDED BY WARM PITA
Roasted Veggies
PAN ROASTED ZUCCHINI, YELLOW SQUASH, EGGPLANT, CARROT, ONION, TOMATO WITH YOGURT AND DILL
Saganaki
TRADITIONAL HARD PAN SEARED GRAVIERA CHEESE, LEMON
Seftalia
CYPRIOT STYLE MEATBALLS, GRILLED, ON BED OF TZATZIKI, TOMATOES, ONIONS AND CUCUMBER
Spanakopita
TRADITIONAL SPINACH AND FETA SAVORY PASTRY

Salads-
Horiatiki Octopus
marouli shrimp
marouli salmon
Marouli Chicken
Horiatiki Shrimp
Horiatiki Salmon
Horiatiki Chicken
Horiatiki
DICED ORGANIC TOMATOES, CUCUMBERS, PEPPERS, ONIONS, OLIVES, FETA AND EXTRA VIRGIN OLIVE OIL
Marouli
CHOPPED ROMAINE HEARTS, CHOPPED SCALLIONS, DILL AND ARACHOVA FETA WITH EXTRA VIRGIN OLIVE OIL
Ntakos
GREEK BRUSCHETTA; OLIVE OIL, SHREDDED TOMATO, OREGANO, ONION AND FETA CHEESE; ON A CRISP RYE RUSK
Octapodi Salad
ENDIVE MIXED GREENS TOPPED WITH CHOPPED GRILLED OCTOPUS TAIL AND SHAVED GRAVIERA CHEESE
Patzaria
BED OF ARUGULA TOPPED WITH PICKLED BEETS, WALNUTS, FETA AND EXTRA VIRGIN OLIVE OIL

Pasta-
Veggie Pasta
Eleni's Pasta
WILD CAUGHT NORWEGIAN SALMON PAIRED WITH LINGUINE, FINISHED WITH A LIGHT WHITE WINE CREAM SAUCE AND A TOUCH OF TOMATO
Fettucine Shrimp
SAUTÉED SHRIMP AND ASPARAGUS OVER FETTUCINE,FINISHED WITH A LIGHT WHITE WINE CREAM SAUCE AND A TOUCH OF TOMATO
Makaroni Me Kima
BRAISED GROUND BEEF IN A TOMATO SAUCE OVER LINGUINE
Seafood Orzo
(GREEK PAELLA) SAUTÉED MUSSELS, SHRIMP, AND SCALLOPS OVER ORZO, FINISHED WITH ORGANIC TOMATO SAUCE
Sal Anthony's
WHOLE LOBSTER TAIL BRAISED IN TOMATO AND ASSYRTIKO WINE BROTH, HERBS AND A LIGHT CREAM SAUCE OVER LINGUINE

Entrees-
Platter Chicken Skewers
Brizola
16OZ. CHARCOAL GRILLED BLACK ANGUS RIB EYE STEAK SERVED WITH GREEK STYLE FRESH CUT FRIES
Chicken Souvlaki
ORGANIC CHICKEN BREAST KEBOB WITH TOUCHES OF RED PEPPERS AND ONIONS SERVED WITH LEEK RICE PILAF
Giouvetsi Arni
BABY LAMB SHANK OVEN-BAKED WITH ORZO AND FRESH TOMATO SAUCE
Kotopoulo
FREE RANGE ORGANIC HALF ROASTED CHICKEN, WITH EXTRA VIRGIN OLIVE OIL, LEMON, AND GREEK ORGANIC OREGANO. SERVED WITH LEMON POTATOES
Lamb Paidakia
NEW ZEALAND CHARCOAL GRILLED BABY LAMB CHOPS, SERVED WITH GREEK STYLE FRESH CUT FRIES
Langoustines
SEARED LANGOUSTINES FINISHED IN A BALSAMIC VINEGAR SAUCE
Lavraki
(IMPORTED – WHOLE) BRONZINI" LEAN WHITE FISH, MILD MOIST TENDER FLAKES, SEMI-SWEET FLAVOR; DRESSED IN LEMON OIL AND HERBS
Orata
(ANCIENT GREEK WORD MEANING "GOLDEN" ) MEDIUM PROTEIN, SEMI-SWEET, FLAKY WHITE FISH ; DRESSED IN LEMON OIL AND HERBS
Salmon
GRILLED WILD NORWEGIAN SALMON PAIRED WITH A LEEK RICE PILAF
Tiger Shrimp (2 PCS)
SEARED TIGER SHRIMP DRESSED IN LEMON AND OREGANO
Veal Paidakia
CHARCOAL GRILLED BABY VEAL CHOPS, SERVED WITH GREEK STYLE FRESH CUT FRIES
Moussakas
LAYERS OF SAUTÉED GROUND MEAT, EGGPLANT, POTATOES; TOPPED WITH BECHAMEL SAUCE

Sides-
Hummus Side
Spicy Feta Side
Melitzanosalata Side
Taramosalata Side
Tzatziki Side
Brussel Sprouts
Greek Feta Cheese
Greek Style Fresh Cut Fries
Leek Rice
Roasted Lemon Potatoes
Sauteed Baby Spinach
Spanakorizo
Brocolli Rabe

Dessert-
Chocolate Mousse
Greek Yogurt
Baklava
Glaktomopouriko

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
+44 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+43 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Great food with an unique hospitality, very welcoming atmosphere from Eleni . She really loves the industry and goes above and beyond to make sure you have a great experience. Food it self is very tasty and love their fish selections, a great fair price for Manhattan. Love their drinks and wine menu . A truly great neighborhood restaurant with a lot of passion and care . Great work Eleni 👏
August 2025
I thought Eleni’s was decent but it has potential to be better it’s super cute inside and was relatively crowded on a Thursday for dinner. I loved the salad but the lettuce wasn’t washed and I was crunching sand. That gave me trepidation for the rest of the meal. The shrimp were only four and two were large and two were much smaller. The pitas were banging tho! I’m not sure id go back but thank you for having us!
August 2025
The service was exceptional w/ the waitress providing wine taste tests…Had the grilled squid, fried zucchini/eggplant, octopus, swordfish, orata… The squid was not well prepared and tough but the rest was fantastic. Also didn’t care for the dessert - Galaktompouriko. Overall great experience and will be back!
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Taqueria Gramercy - 218 3rd Ave
Tacos, Bar, Vegetarian
Sathi - 216 3rd Ave
Indian, Himalayan/Nepalese, Vegan, Vegetarian
Paddy Maguire's Ale House - 237 3rd Ave
Bar, Sports Bar, Irish Pub

Eleni’s

226 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10003
(212) 982-9030