Food is awesome, but the service here for Sunday lunchtime was rough — seemed like one waiter for the whole restaurant?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Andrea Sutjeska
Thoroughly enjoyed our experience and dinner here. The staff know how to host. Our waitress (Noemi? With curly hair) was a delight. She was personable, knowledgeable, and genuinely kind. Her recommendations were delicious, we were debating returning two days later but wanted to try something new (only two nights in NY) and Emmys wasn’t opening for another 2 hours that afternoon.We cannot wait to return, thank you for a great experience!Get the pepperoni with pickled jalapeño and honey or the truffle pizza. You won’t regret it! Also, the bartender has a “generous” pour, delicious jug of sangria.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Colony Pizza
Nils Brolin
Good thick pizza. Huge portions we shared one pizza and got 6 squares for $22. Took 35 min to get it and it was a little bit fat but good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Johnny Novo
I rarely stray away from simple pizzas. I normally just get cheese or pepperoni, as the opportunity cost of trying a new pizza and not liking it is just so damn great. Some of y'all do SO much with your pizza smh.There are few things better than bread, cheese, red sauce, and some pepperoni done well. Simple, yet effective. Oddly similar to my mid range jump shot...All this to say, my girlfriend really wanted the Colony pizza from Emmy Squared, as she is far more adventurous with her pizza. I realize this only adds honey and jalapenos to a pepperoni pizza ahahaaha but still, I was nervous. Plus she was buying so what was I really gonna say lol.Upon opening the box, I was hopeful. It still looked delicious. I mean it literally just adds jalapenos to what I normally get so...... I know I'm nuts, but I can only be me.After ripping into my first bite, I got a mouth full of jalapeno so that threw me off a bit, but I composed myself and kept forging on. I ended up eating 3 slices, and was gonna go for 4 but didn't want to be a little piggy wiggly because I'm tryna be rockstar skinny. I prob shouldn't be eating pizza when I'm tryna be rockstar skinny, but here we are.I did end up eating around the jalapenos if we are being honest, but that honey did add so much to my normal pepperoni pizza. It inspired me to start adding hot honey to my pepperoni pizzas. I know I'm behind the 8 ball on that but whatever. It is what it is.Thank you, Emmy Squared, for taking me on this journey.IG @jnov_Tiktok @jnov_reviews
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jacob Dinetz
Recently celebrated my birthday here and couldn't recommend it more. Big group of almost 25 people. Staff, food, and atmosphere were all great. Super easy to book as well - communication couldn't have been
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
BrittanyS
Great food but staff at location were very low energy and it didn't seem very tidy. Seemed a bit run down. Staff generally seemed very bored to be there and it dragged down the vibe. Again, food was top notch but perhaps not busy enough.
paul kostabi
Great and they made exactly what we
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Meron Aberha
Spent Valentine’s Day here and was not disappointed. The food was phenomenal. The burger has to be one of the best. The flavor of the patty is memorable and the Sammy sauce is kickin! A side of waffle fries makes this meal a heft challenge for any foodie. No biggie for you?? Well then add their delicious Detroit style pizza! You won’t regret and your stomach will forgive you because there is real fomo here.Sit back and enjoy the food while the AMAZING staff takes care of all your needs. A staple for anybody wanting good food and good vibes
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Saeed Alrahma
The pizza dough was soggy and the slice fell apart when you picked up the slice. Otherwise the cheese and sauce were good just hard to eat the slice and enjoy.
Best pizza in the east village, every bite is flavorful, friendly staff, great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily Majors
Insane burger!! But the spicy chicken sandwich stole my heart. Best I've ever had. maybe one day I'll go back for the pizza...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Jeffrey G.
Closer to "Flint Style" than "Detroit Style" Placed an order to go, was given a 100 minute wait time. Showed up to pick up pizza 15 minutes before scheduled time, and the pizzas were already sitting out and cold. Crust for one had started to get a little soggy. Even if it was hot and fresh, crust seemed a little undercooked. Would not recommend.
Ryan Kincheloe
Pizza and drinks were great! nice
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Anne Rajotte
The atmosphere is relaxed and fun, and the food delicious. The best part of our night was the superb service we received from CHYNA! She is the #1 reason that we will return to this location. Chyna knows every detail of the food and beverage menus, and her recommendations were absolute perfection. She was fun, kind, professional, and she brought such joy to our dining experience.We also had outstanding service with a smile from Marvelous. He was Chyna's right hand man when we dined-in in mid-November. They were a phenomenal team. Thank you, Chyna and Marvelous! You added to the spectacular, quality experience at Emmy Squared Pizza.
Food is awesome, but the service here for Sunday lunchtime was rough — seemed like one waiter for the whole restaurant?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Thoroughly enjoyed our experience and dinner here. The staff know how to host. Our waitress (Noemi? With curly hair) was a delight. She was personable, knowledgeable, and genuinely kind. Her recommendations were delicious, we were debating returning two days later but wanted to try something new (only two nights in NY) and Emmys wasn’t opening for another 2 hours that afternoon.We cannot wait to return, thank you for a great experience!Get the pepperoni with pickled jalapeño and honey or the truffle pizza. You won’t regret it! Also, the bartender has a “generous” pour, delicious jug of sangria.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Colony Pizza
Good thick pizza. Huge portions we shared one pizza and got 6 squares for $22. Took 35 min to get it and it was a little bit fat but good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
I rarely stray away from simple pizzas. I normally just get cheese or pepperoni, as the opportunity cost of trying a new pizza and not liking it is just so damn great. Some of y'all do SO much with your pizza smh.There are few things better than bread, cheese, red sauce, and some pepperoni done well. Simple, yet effective. Oddly similar to my mid range jump shot...All this to say, my girlfriend really wanted the Colony pizza from Emmy Squared, as she is far more adventurous with her pizza. I realize this only adds honey and jalapenos to a pepperoni pizza ahahaaha but still, I was nervous. Plus she was buying so what was I really gonna say lol.Upon opening the box, I was hopeful. It still looked delicious. I mean it literally just adds jalapenos to what I normally get so...... I know I'm nuts, but I can only be me.After ripping into my first bite, I got a mouth full of jalapeno so that threw me off a bit, but I composed myself and kept forging on. I ended up eating 3 slices, and was gonna go for 4 but didn't want to be a little piggy wiggly because I'm tryna be rockstar skinny. I prob shouldn't be eating pizza when I'm tryna be rockstar skinny, but here we are.I did end up eating around the jalapenos if we are being honest, but that honey did add so much to my normal pepperoni pizza. It inspired me to start adding hot honey to my pepperoni pizzas. I know I'm behind the 8 ball on that but whatever. It is what it is.Thank you, Emmy Squared, for taking me on this journey.IG @jnov_Tiktok @jnov_reviews
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recently celebrated my birthday here and couldn't recommend it more. Big group of almost 25 people. Staff, food, and atmosphere were all great. Super easy to book as well - communication couldn't have been
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food but staff at location were very low energy and it didn't seem very tidy. Seemed a bit run down. Staff generally seemed very bored to be there and it dragged down the vibe. Again, food was top notch but perhaps not busy enough.
Great and they made exactly what we
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Spent Valentine’s Day here and was not disappointed. The food was phenomenal. The burger has to be one of the best. The flavor of the patty is memorable and the Sammy sauce is kickin! A side of waffle fries makes this meal a heft challenge for any foodie. No biggie for you?? Well then add their delicious Detroit style pizza! You won’t regret and your stomach will forgive you because there is real fomo here.Sit back and enjoy the food while the AMAZING staff takes care of all your needs. A staple for anybody wanting good food and good vibes
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza dough was soggy and the slice fell apart when you picked up the slice. Otherwise the cheese and sauce were good just hard to eat the slice and enjoy.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
it was very
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza in the east village, every bite is flavorful, friendly staff, great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Insane burger!! But the spicy chicken sandwich stole my heart. Best I've ever had. maybe one day I'll go back for the pizza...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Closer to "Flint Style" than "Detroit Style" Placed an order to go, was given a 100 minute wait time. Showed up to pick up pizza 15 minutes before scheduled time, and the pizzas were already sitting out and cold. Crust for one had started to get a little soggy. Even if it was hot and fresh, crust seemed a little undercooked. Would not recommend.
Pizza and drinks were great! nice
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
The atmosphere is relaxed and fun, and the food delicious. The best part of our night was the superb service we received from CHYNA! She is the #1 reason that we will return to this location. Chyna knows every detail of the food and beverage menus, and her recommendations were absolute perfection. She was fun, kind, professional, and she brought such joy to our dining experience.We also had outstanding service with a smile from Marvelous. He was Chyna's right hand man when we dined-in in mid-November. They were a phenomenal team. Thank you, Chyna and Marvelous! You added to the spectacular, quality experience at Emmy Squared Pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5