Fat Witch Bakery
75 9th Ave, New York
(212) 807-1335
Customers' Favorites
All Chocolate Witch Brownie
Snow Witch Brownie
Chocolate Brownie
Caramel Witch
Fat Witch
Brownies
Menu
Photos
+83 photos
+82 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Been ordering from Fat Witch for a few years now. Their brownies are always so moist and dense plus the shipping is fast....This time my order came in a cute little Valentines bag and ribbon 🥰
Over $5 for a regular size brownie. Over $3 for a bite size one. It's super sweet, definitely need something to off-set it like milk or tea. Possibly even some chips. A good brownie regardless. It is definitely an indulgence item.
I've had the Fat Witch Bakery cookbook for many years, and always wanted to order from them to try the real thing. I ordered the 8 baby pack for delivery to TN, and it was almost $40. I didn't expect the size to be quite so tiny, but that could be my fault for not reading. They are a couple of bites each. I did get 8 different flavors to try, and so far they've been okay at best. I think my favorite was mint, and my least favorite was honey. None of them have really...
You May Also Like
Very Fresh Noodles - 409 W 15th St
![]()
Taiwanese, Chinese, Noodles, Pet Friendly, Vegan
Seed + Mill - 409 W 15th St
![]()
Dessert, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Gluten-Free, Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream
Filaga - 75 9th Ave
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Bar, Vegan, Vegetarian