This is my go to bar with my friends. Went here on Halloween and it was great vibes. Gets very packed for football games. Especially great for conference championship week for college football. Love this place would recommend to anyone food is great and no better place than here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Omer Talpur
The shepherds pie was delicious, and so were the Buffalo wings. Maria was a very attentive server, and the drinks were good as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
DANNY D
Good atmosphere. Friendly employees. I'd definitely recommend it to others
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Vianney Encinas Benitez
This place is amazing and one of my favorite spots in New York. The staff is incredibly friendly, and both the food and drinks are consistently great. Always a wonderful experience!
robert bobby
I do not like leaving bad reviews but sometimes you just have to, 1st off the atmosphere was good, 2nd the server did not listen to you and was drunk seen her doing shots at the bar. 4 of us dined in we ordered 2 ceaser salads 1 with chicken the salads were the best part but you cant hardly mess that up we ordered the Fitzgerald burger with Swiss medium cooked with sweet potato fries the burger came out RAW AS CAN BE the fries were good I ordered the steak medium cooked it came out WELL DONE HARDLY CHEWABLE I ordered Fries and vegetable of the day it came out with mashed potatoes and the vegetables seemed days old reheated but cold, she did bring the fries those were good but the kicker is i was served with no steak knife there is also no salt pepper or any sauces on the table we did not say anything because of the fear they will mess with your food if you say something if they offer to remake it the drinks were good white Russians and the Fitzgerald amber beer
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 2
The GINGER-CANDY Rapper!
For my first 4 years in NYC this was my hangout mainly because of the WORLD'S BEST BARTENDER named JOSEPH who is just a magnificent friendly human being and an awesome server and drink maker. For some mysterious reason wonderful outstanding Joseph was let go and of course this establishment since that time has been in a nose-dive into the dirtiest and slinkiest sewers of the world! Carlos on Tuesdays is particularly a disdainful excuse for a bartender and is oh so rude. Anyhow who ever heard of an Irishman named Carlos. This pub is basura pura! When Joseph comes back I'm sure this place will b immediately returned to utter excellence!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
Lucy Aleman
The bartender, John, was lovely!! Very warm & friendly and a very good bartender! He even invented a drink for the table next to us! I asked for it and it was yummy! Not too sweet & very refreshing!!
Really laid back and relaxing vibe. For sure a pub
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Wesley Baker
Fantastic pub, all the food is made fresh and not frozen bar food. Great staff and better drinks. Will definitely be coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stuart Davis
Ate lunch/had a work meeting here yesterday. I have worked for ten years literally 30 seconds away from Fitzgerald's but have only been in once before and didn't eat. This time I got the BLT and he got a burger. The BLT was totally fine--my friend (who goes in there quite a bit and recommended the place) liked his burger a lot. The food was ok but what sets this place apart is the bartender. He was amazingly friendly and warm.
I would definitely go back. However, part of the reason why I'd not been to Fitzgerald's very much is because there are two other pubs in the area (Molly's and The Globe) that I love. I won't go as far as making this my all-the-time go to place--I love the food at Molly's---but will definitely come back here regularly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Jon-Paul Turek
Probably the most balanced Shepard's pie I've ever had. Amazing potatoes, the ground beef and gravy was fantastic, and none of it overpowered the veggies. Perfection.
This is my favorite bar ever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Foods Great
Fantastic wings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is my go to bar with my friends. Went here on Halloween and it was great vibes. Gets very packed for football games. Especially great for conference championship week for college football. Love this place would recommend to anyone food is great and no better place than here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The shepherds pie was delicious, and so were the Buffalo wings. Maria was a very attentive server, and the drinks were good as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good atmosphere. Friendly employees. I'd definitely recommend it to others
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
This place is amazing and one of my favorite spots in New York. The staff is incredibly friendly, and both the food and drinks are consistently great. Always a wonderful experience!
I do not like leaving bad reviews but sometimes you just have to, 1st off the atmosphere was good, 2nd the server did not listen to you and was drunk seen her doing shots at the bar. 4 of us dined in we ordered 2 ceaser salads 1 with chicken the salads were the best part but you cant hardly mess that up we ordered the Fitzgerald burger with Swiss medium cooked with sweet potato fries the burger came out RAW AS CAN BE the fries were good I ordered the steak medium cooked it came out WELL DONE HARDLY CHEWABLE I ordered Fries and vegetable of the day it came out with mashed potatoes and the vegetables seemed days old reheated but cold, she did bring the fries those were good but the kicker is i was served with no steak knife there is also no salt pepper or any sauces on the table we did not say anything because of the fear they will mess with your food if you say something if they offer to remake it the drinks were good white Russians and the Fitzgerald amber beer
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 2
For my first 4 years in NYC this was my hangout mainly because of the WORLD'S BEST BARTENDER named JOSEPH who is just a magnificent friendly human being and an awesome server and drink maker. For some mysterious reason wonderful outstanding Joseph was let go and of course this establishment since that time has been in a nose-dive into the dirtiest and slinkiest sewers of the world! Carlos on Tuesdays is particularly a disdainful excuse for a bartender and is oh so rude. Anyhow who ever heard of an Irishman named Carlos. This pub is basura pura! When Joseph comes back I'm sure this place will b immediately returned to utter excellence!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
The bartender, John, was lovely!! Very warm & friendly and a very good bartender! He even invented a drink for the table next to us! I asked for it and it was yummy! Not too sweet & very refreshing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Really laid back and relaxing vibe. For sure a pub
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Fantastic pub, all the food is made fresh and not frozen bar food. Great staff and better drinks. Will definitely be coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ate lunch/had a work meeting here yesterday. I have worked for ten years literally 30 seconds away from Fitzgerald's but have only been in once before and didn't eat. This time I got the BLT and he got a burger. The BLT was totally fine--my friend (who goes in there quite a bit and recommended the place) liked his burger a lot. The food was ok but what sets this place apart is the bartender. He was amazingly friendly and warm.
I would definitely go back. However, part of the reason why I'd not been to Fitzgerald's very much is because there are two other pubs in the area (Molly's and The Globe) that I love. I won't go as far as making this my all-the-time go to place--I love the food at Molly's---but will definitely come back here regularly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Probably the most balanced Shepard's pie I've ever had. Amazing potatoes, the ground beef and gravy was fantastic, and none of it overpowered the veggies. Perfection.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Mac and cheese ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...