Fratelli Pizzeria

27 Seguine Ave, Staten Island
(718) 356-8742

Recent Reviews

Brandon Stafford

I have only been here once since I am not from the area but Fratelli Pizzeria was very good. I had a veal cutlet grinder and it was excellent. The bread it was on was very fresh and it was not too heavy unlike some other places. The veal was very good and the amount balences well with the bread. Their sauce was great, not too sweet or too sour and the sandwich had just enough to make the sandwich moist but not to cause the bread to get soggy. And last but not least was the cheese. I'm not normally a big cheese fan, but the fresh mozzarella was VERY good. I normally ask for light cheese on things, but this time I did not, and I'm glad I didn't. You could tell that it was not the usual slices or shredded mozzarella that most other restaurants normally use on a grinder. It had that fresh mozzarella taste which went well with everything and didn't overpower the bread or veal. The size of the grinder was also very good for the price and I was able to eat half and take the other half for later, without feeling like I am shorting myself out of a full meal.While it is kind of hard to review a pizzeria without trying their pizza, if it's like their grinders then I'm sure it's excellent.

Michele Mariocca

they're fried calamari is delicious they're pizzas amazing. all their pasta dishes are just delicious and all them chicken and fish plates or delicious.

Daniel N.

Didn't expect it but, Fratelli Pizzeria & Pasticceria was simply exceptional. I don't want to leave because of the atmosphere. Every single thing I have ever purchased here has been fresh and tastes terrific. Staff are very welcoming. They're accommodating, respectful and always on their game. Fratelli Pizzeria & Pasticceria...Period.

Lou Nero

Above average square, above average calzone.

jeffrey mckeon

delivery took almost 2 hours food was cold and prepared poorly. been ordering from this place for a while without incident but this time was horrible

Jeff Dauguste

Found you in recent weeks and each time I am so happy to have ordered from you which is several times a week. So sad today when you were closed and can’t wait for you to reopen! Hope you are all well!

Barb C.

Fresh, delicious, can't say enough about how happy I was with prepared food from here. Compared to almost every other place they were generous, affordable and gracious while picking up.

A C.

Love this place. Pizza is always fresh. The rolls are wonderful. Mozzarella sticks are always perfectly fried and crunchy. Can't go wrong with anything here. Chicken carciofini is a winner

Jeannie C.

I am beyond disappointed with this pizzeria. I was looking forward to having lunch there and when I walked in, there was a young man without a mask, and the older woman behind the counter also did not have a mask on. When my co-worker asked if the mask rule was only for customers and not for employees, the woman replied that she was behind the plexiglass so it wasn't necessary to wear one. I then said "but your still talking and breathing open food" to which she had no reply. My friend and I walked out and decided to eat elsewhere. I will be reporting this to the Board of Health.

Daniel Pino

Buffalo chicken slice - goodSquare slice - goodChicken roll - good

Kolby Benitez

I celebrated my graduation yesterday in this gorgeous place. happy to tell that we had a marvelous evening and the restaurant was unquestionably one of the reasons for this strong event. The stuff cooperated in a lovely manner, the cuisine was great and my friends were so cheerful. We shall absolutely visit again for more joyful events. thanks very much.

John M.

Just ordered for pickup through slice. I have been here many times and I have never been disappointed. Props to the owner and the chef for the amazing food. Thank you, will definitely me ordering more!!

Jackie Renda

Placed an order for pick up, everything was absolutely delicious, fresh & piping hot, from the pizza, pastas, rice ball, salad, soup & garlic knots

Ann W.

Ordered from Fratellis last night -long week of working from home and my children remote learning all week. It was later and we were so happy they were open and appreciative of delivery. Pies, pasta and garlic knots were all delicious. Thank you Fratelli and your workers especially your delivery person making deliveries. Appreciate you and hope you are soon fully open and accessible!

Linda Gardner Browne

My fillet of sole franchises is always made to perfection.

Load More