Great pre-theatre option in Time Square, especially if going to see The Great Gatsby. Tommy provided great service! The entree (duck carbonara) was wonderful. The autumn sangria cocktail was very flavorful. The dessert (chocolate cake) wasn't anything special, and Tommy mentioned that it wasn't his favorite either.
Maura
Delicious dinner! We shared the calamari, squid ink pasta and a spicy soppressata pizza. Nice atmosphere and we had a great server, Morgan who was attentive and gave recommendations for after show drink spots.
Jill
Wonderful experience at Gatsy's Landing. You can't beat the location - directly across the street from "Maybe Happy Ending" and "Waiting for Godot". We were greeted warmly by Lana the hostess who was super accommodating with our table (or should I say tables?) :) Our waitress Valen was fantastic! Super attentive, patient and great with recommendations. I ordered the frittata (delish), my mom and nephew had the duck hash (also delish) and my niece had a salad (didn't taste but looked tasty). We capped off the meal with tiramisu and creme brulee. Highly recommend - loved the food, service and wonderful music they were playing in the background.
Mali
We love this place! Great food, attentive service and a fun vibe. Get the ravioli or pasta special - they never disappoint! Save room for the s'mores desert.
Steve
Katie was an amazing server. She was pleasant and kind, gave us excellent food advice, as well as NYC pro tips
bobbi
Amazing service and beautiful restaurant. Food was delicious with great wine and cocktail options. Definitely a must in Times Square.
Kevin Sutorius
The best burger I have ever had
amanda r
Came out for dinner, Tori was an absolute angel. She was super attentive and made us feel like the only ones in the restaurant. She is the best, will definitely come back to enjoy the vibe and food as well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kara Steele
Highly recommend! Perfect place to go before a broadway show in NYC! The service was perfect! The food was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Gray
The nicest staff ever! This is a delicious dinner place with a great atmosphere. The staff was so attentive and even held our umbrellas for us while we dined. Their homemade pasta is delicious, my family loved all of our dishes! My dad said it’s the best lasagna he’s ever had.
I have not allowed the nice looking decor to influence my overall rating of this restaurant as previous reviewers appear to have done. I had the brick chicken ($38) this Sunday. It was not juicy, it was hard to cut (a steak knife was needed) and it had little flavor. It came with fingerling potatoes and a choice of another vegetable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
tom walrath
Very good fast service. Across the Street from the Bellasco Theater.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Broccolini
Ben
Went for Valentine’s Day with my girlfriend and had an incredible evening. The whole experience was perfect, from the food to the atmosphere and service. Wyatt, our server, was professional and kind. The NY strip and the Half Chicken were delicious and the drinks were amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tey Renee
Nice place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Cornelius Pants
Service & atmosphere is 10/10. The food needs A LOT of work. Portions are small, bland & hardly edible. They do not meet the descriptions on the menu AT ALL. 2/10.
Great pre-theatre option in Time Square, especially if going to see The Great Gatsby. Tommy provided great service! The entree (duck carbonara) was wonderful. The autumn sangria cocktail was very flavorful. The dessert (chocolate cake) wasn't anything special, and Tommy mentioned that it wasn't his favorite either.
Delicious dinner! We shared the calamari, squid ink pasta and a spicy soppressata pizza. Nice atmosphere and we had a great server, Morgan who was attentive and gave recommendations for after show drink spots.
Wonderful experience at Gatsy's Landing. You can't beat the location - directly across the street from "Maybe Happy Ending" and "Waiting for Godot". We were greeted warmly by Lana the hostess who was super accommodating with our table (or should I say tables?) :) Our waitress Valen was fantastic! Super attentive, patient and great with recommendations. I ordered the frittata (delish), my mom and nephew had the duck hash (also delish) and my niece had a salad (didn't taste but looked tasty). We capped off the meal with tiramisu and creme brulee. Highly recommend - loved the food, service and wonderful music they were playing in the background.
We love this place! Great food, attentive service and a fun vibe. Get the ravioli or pasta special - they never disappoint! Save room for the s'mores desert.
Katie was an amazing server. She was pleasant and kind, gave us excellent food advice, as well as NYC pro tips
Amazing service and beautiful restaurant. Food was delicious with great wine and cocktail options. Definitely a must in Times Square.
The best burger I have ever had
Came out for dinner, Tori was an absolute angel. She was super attentive and made us feel like the only ones in the restaurant. She is the best, will definitely come back to enjoy the vibe and food as well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Highly recommend! Perfect place to go before a broadway show in NYC! The service was perfect! The food was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The nicest staff ever! This is a delicious dinner place with a great atmosphere. The staff was so attentive and even held our umbrellas for us while we dined. Their homemade pasta is delicious, my family loved all of our dishes! My dad said it’s the best lasagna he’s ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I have not allowed the nice looking decor to influence my overall rating of this restaurant as previous reviewers appear to have done. I had the brick chicken ($38) this Sunday. It was not juicy, it was hard to cut (a steak knife was needed) and it had little flavor. It came with fingerling potatoes and a choice of another vegetable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Very good fast service. Across the Street from the Bellasco Theater.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Broccolini
Went for Valentine’s Day with my girlfriend and had an incredible evening. The whole experience was perfect, from the food to the atmosphere and service. Wyatt, our server, was professional and kind. The NY strip and the Half Chicken were delicious and the drinks were amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Service & atmosphere is 10/10. The food needs A LOT of work. Portions are small, bland & hardly edible. They do not meet the descriptions on the menu AT ALL. 2/10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Loading...