Didn't eat here but 5 stars for the drinks. Very well curated section of spirits/aperitivo. Amaro focused so if that is your taste you'll be very happy. Bartender did us some great off menu cocktails. Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Iriana Cruz
We came here while we waited for our table at Attaboy and ... wow the drinks! I had a coffee mocktail that made me love coffee and orange together! Loved the place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
T Y
Cozy and intimate little spot in NYC with a great vibe. It's a small place with limited seating, so definitely book ahead if you can--we got lucky with a no-show reservation. The host was absolutely lovely and made us feel very welcome right away.
The food leans more towards light bites--think tinned seafood, dips, and snacks--which is perfect if you're after a chill evening with drinks. The menu is interesting and creative, and I'd definitely come back to try more.
We had a glass of wine and a beer, both were delicious and surprisingly affordable for NYC. Great place to unwind with a drink and something a bit different.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gilles De Cannière
Great service!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Grace
Jeremy was the best!! He started us with a wine tasting when we couldn’t decide on the selection, and the drinks he made were delicious. The ambiance, music, and lighting were beautiful. I’m visiting New York from out of town but I’ll definitely be returning when I’m here again!
Margo S
Stumbled upon Good Guy’s originally while waiting for a dinner reservation - ultimately came back after dinner for another drink! The atmosphere is 10/10 (intimate but good vibes) and Jared & Noah were lovely, fun, and helpful bartenders. We had the smoked trout dip to nibble on and it surpassed expectations, drinks were great. Thank you guys!!
Hitesh Kalia
Accidentally went here because we were looking for attaboy but ended up with Best experience of amaro drinks. Jerry was the best
Albert K
Attaboys team opened this bar next door. Attaboy was too busy so I ended up going here.
Extremely chill nyc vibes and fun staff. They have food also and specialize in spritz.
Bunch more seating here and a few beers on draft!
Claudia Rogers
This bar has so much potential, but the experience fell short. The drink prices rivaled those of world-renowned establishments nearby, yet the service was inattentive and lackluster. Disappointing, considering what it could be.
Riana Singh
Very cute, small and cozy space! A dark and moody environment in the booths, and a perfect spot for some wine and spritzes! We came here before going to Attaboy and it was the perfect night out. We especially loved the labneh and chip combo.
Good Guy’s is a five-star gem in NYC. The staff is friendly, attentive, and impressively knowledgeable. The food is flavorful yet light, and the drinks are fantastic, especially the spritzes, which completely redefined what I thought a spritz could be. Can’t wait to return!
Jessica Shu
Not bad but the service is pretty slow and didn’t love the food
Yana Andreeva
Pressured to order more drinks or leave bc of the long waitlist..
Sophia Tulp
Had fantastic after-work drinks here with my sister. Service was 10/10 above and beyond. Our server was fantastic, attentive and made excellent suggestions. We snacked on the labneh and pan con tomate, both were great. We each had two great spritz’s and finished with orange wine. Atmosphere/aesthetics were incredible but truly the service was the best part.
seerat A
Good Guys nails amaro-based cocktail - balanced yet bold . The staff knows their stuff, the vibes are just right, and every sip feels like a discovery. A must for spritz and aperitivo lovers.
Didn't eat here but 5 stars for the drinks. Very well curated section of spirits/aperitivo. Amaro focused so if that is your taste you'll be very happy. Bartender did us some great off menu cocktails. Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We came here while we waited for our table at Attaboy and ... wow the drinks! I had a coffee mocktail that made me love coffee and orange together! Loved the place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cozy and intimate little spot in NYC with a great vibe. It's a small place with limited seating, so definitely book ahead if you can--we got lucky with a no-show reservation. The host was absolutely lovely and made us feel very welcome right away.
The food leans more towards light bites--think tinned seafood, dips, and snacks--which is perfect if you're after a chill evening with drinks. The menu is interesting and creative, and I'd definitely come back to try more.
We had a glass of wine and a beer, both were delicious and surprisingly affordable for NYC. Great place to unwind with a drink and something a bit different.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeremy was the best!! He started us with a wine tasting when we couldn’t decide on the selection, and the drinks he made were delicious. The ambiance, music, and lighting were beautiful. I’m visiting New York from out of town but I’ll definitely be returning when I’m here again!
Stumbled upon Good Guy’s originally while waiting for a dinner reservation - ultimately came back after dinner for another drink! The atmosphere is 10/10 (intimate but good vibes) and Jared & Noah were lovely, fun, and helpful bartenders. We had the smoked trout dip to nibble on and it surpassed expectations, drinks were great. Thank you guys!!
Accidentally went here because we were looking for attaboy but ended up with Best experience of amaro drinks. Jerry was the best
Attaboys team opened this bar next door. Attaboy was too busy so I ended up going here.
Extremely chill nyc vibes and fun staff. They have food also and specialize in spritz.
Bunch more seating here and a few beers on draft!
This bar has so much potential, but the experience fell short. The drink prices rivaled those of world-renowned establishments nearby, yet the service was inattentive and lackluster. Disappointing, considering what it could be.
Very cute, small and cozy space! A dark and moody environment in the booths, and a perfect spot for some wine and spritzes! We came here before going to Attaboy and it was the perfect night out. We especially loved the labneh and chip combo.
Restaurantji Recommends
Good Guy’s is a five-star gem in NYC. The staff is friendly, attentive, and impressively knowledgeable. The food is flavorful yet light, and the drinks are fantastic, especially the spritzes, which completely redefined what I thought a spritz could be. Can’t wait to return!
Not bad but the service is pretty slow and didn’t love the food
Pressured to order more drinks or leave bc of the long waitlist..
Had fantastic after-work drinks here with my sister. Service was 10/10 above and beyond. Our server was fantastic, attentive and made excellent suggestions. We snacked on the labneh and pan con tomate, both were great. We each had two great spritz’s and finished with orange wine. Atmosphere/aesthetics were incredible but truly the service was the best part.
Good Guys nails amaro-based cocktail - balanced yet bold . The staff knows their stuff, the vibes are just right, and every sip feels like a discovery. A must for spritz and aperitivo lovers.
Loading...