Gotham Cafe

1298 2nd Ave, New York
(212) 717-0457

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Troy Bolton

Never going here again. I ordered a Chai Tea Latte and after asking of it was sweet they said it just had vanilla powder. It was not good. It didnt taste like Chai, just vanilla sweet milk. Kinda like a vanilla protein shake but hot. I respectfully and nicely went up to ask the lady who made my beverage if i could exchange it for a cafe mocha and right away she just gave me attitude and said “its mocha it’s gong to be sweet too” and after i explained it would be different because of the vanilla powder she said she wouldnt exchange it. I threw the whole thing away and left. Her attitude was TERRIBLE.

I love supporting businesses in my neighborhood but this one I will have to tell people to go somewhere else. Service is everything nowadays. Plus cleanliness is something. The table I sat at was not wiped down and dirty.

Service: 1

fior mera

I was craving a bagel and while walking to the post office I saw the place and entered. I Ordered a toasted bagel and it was served in record time, I sat and the bagel came
Noticed the bagel was not toasted and went to the cashier to let her know and I got the same bagel with grill lines on top.
I was expecting a better experience

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Arthur Glauberman

The Gotham Cafe is a wonderful neighborhood cafe where you can start your day with a hearty breakfast, such as their delicious homemade oatmeal meal with bananas, walnuts and brown sugar or enjky any of their fabulous omelets. For lunch, on a cold day, their soups are wonderful! I love their chicken noodle soup as well as their wonderful salads snd sandwiches.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

youssef Skitz

It’s very goood owner is very kind

Kathy O'Connor

So reliably good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tristan Arthur

Their signage is inaccurate. Sign says breakfast is served till 3 pm and when we ordered at 2:30 pm they said the grill was off. Lies.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 2

Alexander Pugliese

The smoothies were absolutely excellent. fresh flavorful and perfectly blended by Mooomood. Highly recommend and will definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark \u0026 Helen Zentner Levy

There is no finer place than Gotham Cafe. The staff is outstanding in every way and make it pleasure to be there. The service, food and beverages areTHE BEST. Go there you will love it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Giacomo Treviglio

This is what costumer service should be everywhere! The ladies are super nice and iT’s always great to start the day with a smile

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

THE EXPLORER

I stopped in today after having lunch at a nearby restaurant. I was also here a couple of weeks ago and had a panini and it was delicious. Today I just wanted an Americano coffee. Very nicely brewed.
Fairly crowded today so I had to sit very close to other people which I do not like. I like to have space from other people.

Sheila Grandio

Careless service. They forgot my order and the guy’s in front of me as well. Rude response from the staff. Coffee wasn’t even good and ended up leaving it there.

Natalia Bronshteyn

Came with a stroller and got help from the lovely clients while it was raining. Already a great sign of a local cafe. Only got a coffee but staff and atmosphere was lovely. Will definitely be back for food!

Felice Cohen

Love this place! Delish breakfast sandwiches, have every healthy add on, and cozy atmosphere.

Maddie B

Yum! NY bagels in the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tahsin Uddin

I used to come here a lot and loved it. I especially really loved their iced peppermint mochas - they would take their time to make it and put love and care into it. I'm not in the area as often anymore and came back today just for the peppermint mocha and the quality of service I remembered. First, I was waiting for my drink, and the workers didn't even realize I paid for an order and needed to ask me what I was waiting for, once she finished serving the white customers who came after me. Then, to make the drink, she essentially made a hot peppermint mocha and threw ice in it, and for the price it tastes watered down and terrible. Really disappointed, won't be coming back anymore. The cafe definitely became cheap / fell off compared to the quality of service delivered before.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...