Long nights require thick slices of pizza. Gotham is dependable. Not the best slice in Manhattan, perhaps not even the best in the UES. But this spot is your workhorse, your beast of burden. Less Rachmaninoff than Bruno Mars.
And the Bruno Mars comparison is apt because they play the chorus of a Mars song on loop. A perfect sound to lull you into pizza eating fantasia.
Hana Merhi
Totes hit the spot. Very tasty.
Tonguç Yaman
Best pizza slices and pepperoni in the neighborhood
Sebastian Almeida
Great pizza and very affordable. Not much space to eat in.
Anthony Bruni
Man, this is really good thin-crust pizza! Some of the best I've had!
Brian Sarman
Delicious and very affordable
sand undertable
I got my ass kicked by batman
Agustina Gallero
Best pizza I ever had. Fr.
חגי בן-יונס
Stinging tourists, they charged me significantly more than the written price on the grounds of additional taxes, I inquired and they chose to round up significantly, yes, it's delicious there, I won't lie
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Juan Rosario
Good pizza Great deal $6 for to cheese slices and a soft drink. 11am -3pm
There is this guy Reptar who is talking bad about your food on Twitter Spaces
Roberta Wiessner
My new favorite pie!! I love the thin textured crust, the sauce is delicious, and the pizza was delivered HOT!! Highly recommend!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tim Kunsa
We found this place by accident, it's the best pizza I ever had. And I came from New Haven, Gotham has the best thin crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Cheese Pizza Slice
John McDaniel
This place is so slept on, the pizza is some of the best in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa Hindman
DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS PLACE!!!! Ordered 2 pizzas and garlic knots to be delivered. We added special instructions to include Parmesan cheese and to text us when they arrive at our hotel. They never texted and dropped 2 pizzas in the lobby of the hotel we’re staying at. No garlic knots or Parmesan. We called twice to try and get it taken care of and the guy said he personally put the garlic knots in the large pizza box with the large pizza and basically hung up. First off, there were no garlic knots in the box. Second, why in the world would you put anything in the box WITH the large pizza that’s already in the box. The guy obviously screwed up, then lied and refused to handle it properly. So we paid for something that we never received. Also, the pizza sucks. The crust has zero flavor and tastes like cardboard. Avoid these thieves at all cost!
Long nights require thick slices of pizza. Gotham is dependable. Not the best slice in Manhattan, perhaps not even the best in the UES. But this spot is your workhorse, your beast of burden. Less Rachmaninoff than Bruno Mars.
And the Bruno Mars comparison is apt because they play the chorus of a Mars song on loop. A perfect sound to lull you into pizza eating fantasia.
Totes hit the spot. Very tasty.
Best pizza slices and pepperoni in the neighborhood
Great pizza and very affordable. Not much space to eat in.
Man, this is really good thin-crust pizza! Some of the best I've had!
Delicious and very affordable
I got my ass kicked by batman
Best pizza I ever had. Fr.
Stinging tourists, they charged me significantly more than the written price on the grounds of additional taxes, I inquired and they chose to round up significantly, yes, it's delicious there, I won't lie
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Good pizza
Great deal
$6 for to cheese slices and a soft drink. 11am -3pm
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Cheese Pizza Slice
Restaurantji Recommends
There is this guy Reptar who is talking bad about your food on Twitter Spaces
My new favorite pie!! I love the thin textured crust, the sauce is delicious, and the pizza was delivered HOT!! Highly recommend!
Food: 5
Service: 5
We found this place by accident, it's the best pizza I ever had. And I came from New Haven, Gotham has the best thin crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Cheese Pizza Slice
This place is so slept on, the pizza is some of the best in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS PLACE!!!! Ordered 2 pizzas and garlic knots to be delivered. We added special instructions to include Parmesan cheese and to text us when they arrive at our hotel. They never texted and dropped 2 pizzas in the lobby of the hotel we’re staying at. No garlic knots or Parmesan. We called twice to try and get it taken care of and the guy said he personally put the garlic knots in the large pizza box with the large pizza and basically hung up. First off, there were no garlic knots in the box. Second, why in the world would you put anything in the box WITH the large pizza that’s already in the box. The guy obviously screwed up, then lied and refused to handle it properly. So we paid for something that we never received. Also, the pizza sucks. The crust has zero flavor and tastes like cardboard. Avoid these thieves at all cost!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...