Me and my sister got some slices while we were up in Times Square, just behind out hotel. Real fast and tasty pizza, kind staff members, and would def return when we come back.
Mike Jones
Quick and good. Close to times square.
Terry Ot
Ha ds down the best pizza in NYC 10/10
grettel felix
we where walking down 8th st when I notice a sign in yellow and red lights Gotham pizza?? Well I said let try it!? Well my friend/family I found a lil slice of heaven here in New York?Friendly staff and amazing pizza will definitely be back on my next trip to New York ?
Clayton H Harris
The best pizza in NYC. I was here for a week, and I ate here 4 times. Tried another couple of places after my first visit, and they didn’t compare to Gotham’s.
Dan McKnight
Excellent, delicious NYC Pizza!
Elizabeth H.
Came for lunch on a Saturday in the midst of a busy day touring the city. Fast service. Pizza is very good. We had slices of plain, margherita, and pepperoni. Not the best pizza but very good and very affordable. Not a ton of tables but we easily grabbed one. Recommend for a simple, fast, affordable meals. We were in and out in fifteen minutes and had three slices and three drinks for $18 with tip.
adammccarthy2017
We were in NY for 4 days and my family and kids stopped in for pizza each night on the way home. Great staff and pizza
marcus94pitt
the place is very easy and the pizza is pretty good, we stayed in the hotel right in front of the place so we spent a lot of time inside the pizza shop
Small, local place. Pizza was fantastic, especially loved the crust. We grabbed a quick slice when we arrived in town, then again late at night, it was that good! Cheese slice and a drink...$5.
Algin G.
In search for late night snacks, GOTHAM did not disappoint. Ended up ordering via Yelp for delivery and the process was breezy and no delivery fee. simple win for me! Only mix up was there was no way accurately track the delivery person on their bike... so when the estimated time was up - just headed to the lobby and my pizza was waiting for me. This was my first NY Pizza and it was delicious. I would definitely order from here again. Not so sure why the reviews are low but I thought it was good and the crust was so crispy and yet a good amount of thickness. Very simple ingredients but it was all I need. Paid about 12 bucks for 2 slices and a few waters? the slice was pretty good size - possibly just as big as my face. I could have gone for another one. Maybe next time I am in the city!
Justin J.
This was the New York pizza i had been craving for the last few trips to New York! Every time I go there I try getting a proper New York pizza and end up with these goofy former pizzas. I got a basic cheese and it was exactly what I had wanted for a while now. Quick delivery too, exactly within the expected window. Will definitely order again next time I am in town!
big chevy1
Best pizza I've had in a long time
mattnalex
Popped in for a couple of slices on way back to hotel. Was very happy with the pizza, very good. Chap serving was possibly the most myserable person in manhattan. Looked like he had a promise from a liar.
The best thin slice pizza in Manhattan.
Me and my sister got some slices while we were up in Times Square, just behind out hotel. Real fast and tasty pizza, kind staff members, and would def return when we come back.
Quick and good. Close to times square.
Ha ds down the best pizza in NYC 10/10
we where walking down 8th st when I notice a sign in yellow and red lights Gotham pizza?? Well I said let try it!? Well my friend/family I found a lil slice of heaven here in New York?Friendly staff and amazing pizza will definitely be back on my next trip to New York ?
The best pizza in NYC. I was here for a week, and I ate here 4 times. Tried another couple of places after my first visit, and they didn’t compare to Gotham’s.
Excellent, delicious NYC Pizza!
Came for lunch on a Saturday in the midst of a busy day touring the city. Fast service. Pizza is very good. We had slices of plain, margherita, and pepperoni. Not the best pizza but very good and very affordable. Not a ton of tables but we easily grabbed one. Recommend for a simple, fast, affordable meals. We were in and out in fifteen minutes and had three slices and three drinks for $18 with tip.
We were in NY for 4 days and my family and kids stopped in for pizza each night on the way home. Great staff and pizza
the place is very easy and the pizza is pretty good, we stayed in the hotel right in front of the place so we spent a lot of time inside the pizza shop
Restaurantji Recommends
Small, local place. Pizza was fantastic, especially loved the crust. We grabbed a quick slice when we arrived in town, then again late at night, it was that good! Cheese slice and a drink...$5.
In search for late night snacks, GOTHAM did not disappoint. Ended up ordering via Yelp for delivery and the process was breezy and no delivery fee. simple win for me! Only mix up was there was no way accurately track the delivery person on their bike... so when the estimated time was up - just headed to the lobby and my pizza was waiting for me. This was my first NY Pizza and it was delicious. I would definitely order from here again. Not so sure why the reviews are low but I thought it was good and the crust was so crispy and yet a good amount of thickness. Very simple ingredients but it was all I need. Paid about 12 bucks for 2 slices and a few waters? the slice was pretty good size - possibly just as big as my face. I could have gone for another one. Maybe next time I am in the city!
This was the New York pizza i had been craving for the last few trips to New York! Every time I go there I try getting a proper New York pizza and end up with these goofy former pizzas. I got a basic cheese and it was exactly what I had wanted for a while now. Quick delivery too, exactly within the expected window. Will definitely order again next time I am in town!
Best pizza I've had in a long time
Popped in for a couple of slices on way back to hotel. Was very happy with the pizza, very good. Chap serving was possibly the most myserable person in manhattan. Looked like he had a promise from a liar.