Great cheap slices open late. Charge less for pepperoni than most places charge for cheese
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Queen K
The winner for me here is the Margarita pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Henry Goldberg
Really good pizza for my 1st in New York!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Allen Burton
Wonderful NY Pizza! Super nice workers, and exactly the right crust to sauce to cheese ratio! Love the crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Reid
best pizza in new york, been going here over a decade and it never disappoints. staff is always really kind!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adriana Pesel
Very good Thanks for this moment
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Garry
I saw a literal cockroach crawling around their cooking area and other bugs, super unsanitary and disgusting. Don't waste your money here, it's so unclean and nasty they clearly don't care they have bugs crawling around where they make their food
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Logan D
I ordered a delivery and was going to tip cash like I always do, and after handing me the pizza the driver started harassing me for not tipping and yelling like crazy. I said I was going to tip cash which I had ready to give him, but this is the first time someone has ever harassed me for a tip, I obviously felt uncomfortable and started to walk away but the driver kept following me to outside my apartment yelling at me to tip. I called the store to complain but the guy was also condescending and said I should’ve tipped before, I couldn’t even eat the pizza at that point because how would I know the driver didn’t mess with it? So unprofessional and DANGEROUS. AVOID!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Michael Wilson
Went to Gotham Pizza on Sunday. Just a couple Canadian kids in the concrete jungle for the first time. Hungover and spent from the hustle and bussle of “Zoo York,” we needed some fuel. On a wim we stopped in at Gotham Pizza. As soon as we walked in it felt like coming to a place I never knew was mine. The endearing and charming atmosphere pulled us in. The folks behind the counter were buzzing around working extra hard for us customers. It was at this moment that I started to realize what the appeal was of this grand city. Hard working, blue collar people putting in work to support their families, by doing what they love. Now, if I wasn’t in love by vibes alone, when I had my first bite was when I truly fell head over heels. It felt like I had been blasted back to the ninth grade and was experiencing my first kiss. Crisp, and flavourful. The cheese was fresh and gooey, the crust was paper thin, yet had a decadent texture. Canadian pizza is nothing in compare to what I experienced here in Gotham. I was blind and now I see. The charm of New York and Gotham Pizza will never be forgotten. Can’t recommend enough. 10/10
Classic nyc slice, love the cornmeal crust. Nice workers too
Mike Scicchitano
Excellent slices. Will be back.
Taymour H
Ordered a Margherita pizza expecting fresh ingredients, but it was a letdown. The pizza was overly oily, and they used processed cheese instead of real mozzarella. Basil was barely visible — just tiny shreds. After eating, I felt unwell, which makes me question the hygiene and ingredient quality. Very disappointed with both the food and overall experience. Would not recommend.
Matthew Leto
Gotham Pizza isn’t trying to reinvent the wheel—it’s just doing New York pizza right. The crust has that ideal balance: thin with a crunch, but still foldable enough to eat on the go like a true local. The sauce isn’t overcomplicated, just fresh and perfectly seasoned, and the cheese—melty, golden, and generous—ties it all together.
What makes Gotham stand out isn’t just the pizza (though it’s excellent), it’s the vibe. It’s no-frills, fast, and friendly—exactly what you want when you’re craving a late-night slice or a quick, satisfying lunch. It feels like part of the city’s DNA.
If you want the real NYC pizza experience—no gimmicks, no fusion, just great pizza—Gotham delivers every time.
Great cheap slices open late. Charge less for pepperoni than most places charge for cheese
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The winner for me here is the Margarita pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really good pizza for my 1st in New York!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Wonderful NY Pizza! Super nice workers, and exactly the right crust to sauce to cheese ratio! Love the crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
best pizza in new york, been going here over a decade and it never disappoints. staff is always really kind!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good
Thanks for this moment
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I saw a literal cockroach crawling around their cooking area and other bugs, super unsanitary and disgusting. Don't waste your money here, it's so unclean and nasty they clearly don't care they have bugs crawling around where they make their food
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I ordered a delivery and was going to tip cash like I always do, and after handing me the pizza the driver started harassing me for not tipping and yelling like crazy. I said I was going to tip cash which I had ready to give him, but this is the first time someone has ever harassed me for a tip, I obviously felt uncomfortable and started to walk away but the driver kept following me to outside my apartment yelling at me to tip. I called the store to complain but the guy was also condescending and said I should’ve tipped before, I couldn’t even eat the pizza at that point because how would I know the driver didn’t mess with it? So unprofessional and DANGEROUS. AVOID!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Went to Gotham Pizza on Sunday. Just a couple Canadian kids in the concrete jungle for the first time. Hungover and spent from the hustle and bussle of “Zoo York,” we needed some fuel. On a wim we stopped in at Gotham Pizza. As soon as we walked in it felt like coming to a place I never knew was mine. The endearing and charming atmosphere pulled us in. The folks behind the counter were buzzing around working extra hard for us customers. It was at this moment that I started to realize what the appeal was of this grand city. Hard working, blue collar people putting in work to support their families, by doing what they love. Now, if I wasn’t in love by vibes alone, when I had my first bite was when I truly fell head over heels. It felt like I had been blasted back to the ninth grade and was experiencing my first kiss. Crisp, and flavourful. The cheese was fresh and gooey, the crust was paper thin, yet had a decadent texture. Canadian pizza is nothing in compare to what I experienced here in Gotham. I was blind and now I see. The charm of New York and Gotham Pizza will never be forgotten. Can’t recommend enough. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very unsanitary
Restaurantji Recommends
Classic nyc slice, love the cornmeal crust. Nice workers too
Excellent slices. Will be back.
Ordered a Margherita pizza expecting fresh ingredients, but it was a letdown. The pizza was overly oily, and they used processed cheese instead of real mozzarella. Basil was barely visible — just tiny shreds. After eating, I felt unwell, which makes me question the hygiene and ingredient quality. Very disappointed with both the food and overall experience. Would not recommend.
Gotham Pizza isn’t trying to reinvent the wheel—it’s just doing New York pizza right. The crust has that ideal balance: thin with a crunch, but still foldable enough to eat on the go like a true local. The sauce isn’t overcomplicated, just fresh and perfectly seasoned, and the cheese—melty, golden, and generous—ties it all together.
What makes Gotham stand out isn’t just the pizza (though it’s excellent), it’s the vibe. It’s no-frills, fast, and friendly—exactly what you want when you’re craving a late-night slice or a quick, satisfying lunch. It feels like part of the city’s DNA.
If you want the real NYC pizza experience—no gimmicks, no fusion, just great pizza—Gotham delivers every time.
Perfect NYC pizza 🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...