Gotham Pizza
144 9th Ave, New York
(212) 989-8858
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni Pizza Slice & Margherita Pizza Slice
Margherita 16 Pizza with 1 Topping
Pepperoni Pizza with One Topping
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice
Grandma Whole Square Pizza
Grandma Pizza Slice
Regular Pizza Slice
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pie
Plain Pizza
Menu
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Went to Gotham Pizza on Sunday. Just a couple Canadian kids in the concrete jungle for the first time. Hungover and spent from the hustle and bussle of “Zoo York,” we needed some fuel. On a wim we stopped in at Gotham Pizza. As soon as we walked in it felt like coming to a place I never knew was mine. The endearing and charming atmosphere pulled us in. The folks behind the counter were buzzing around working extra hard for us customers. It was at this moment that I started...
Gotham Pizza isn’t trying to reinvent the wheel—it’s just doing New York pizza right. The crust has that ideal balance: thin with a crunch, but still foldable enough to eat on the go like a true local. The sauce isn’t overcomplicated, just fresh and perfectly seasoned, and the cheese—melty, golden, and generous—ties it all together.
What makes Gotham stand out isn’t just the pizza (though it’s excellent), it’s the vibe. It’s no-frills, fast,...
What makes Gotham stand out isn’t just the pizza (though it’s excellent), it’s the vibe. It’s no-frills, fast,...
10/10!! Literally recommend this place. Pizza is soooo good!! Staff are amazing! And prices are reasonable. I got 2 pizzas and a drink for under $10 when other restaurants are selling one pizza for $10. I will definitely come back to the place when I’m back at NY! Literally love it! True NY pizza
You May Also Like
Salinas Restaurant - 136 9th Ave
![]()
Spanish, Tapas Bar, Bar
Stone Street Coffee - 134 9th Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea
Bathtub Gin - 132 9th Ave
![]()
Bar, Speakeasies, Cocktail Bar, American, New American