Grilled Cheese Society

688 Columbus Ave, New York
(833) 698-2483

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jessica Lerner

The grilled cheese we ordered was just a cheese sandwich. The tomato soup was just watery tomato paste. Do not order from here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Melissa Hurwitz

I'm sick of Google even suggesting this place. Not real. It's a dumpster.

Milan Thacker

Almost got sent to soul society after eating this horrible foodEverything was barely edible…and how do you even mess up tomato soup lol

John Dery

Sub-par food, forgot most of the order, small portions. Won't order again.

Sara W

This is a "virtual restaurant". The company created a menu and found local restaurants who said they can prepare the items on the menu and then they get delivered through a third party service like grubhub. Problem is that the company has not check whether the partner restaurants actually sell any of the things on the menu so when you order you have no idea what items they will send you. You also have no idea whether the kitchen that prepared the food has a good health code grade. It's like lunchtime Russian roulette. Pass.

Cassie Jane

Worst food I’ve ever tried!!! Ordered corn on the cob and got canned corn. Disgusting! Ordered chicken noodle soup and got a few noodles and broth. Never again

Traci R

Highway robbery. Paid more than $30 for two sandwiches and soup—the soup container was the smallest I’ve ever seen in my life and wasn’t even filled up. It was the equivalent to 1/2 a cup of soup. The grilled cheese used Kraft American cheese slices with low quality store bought bread. It wasn’t even tasty. Food was overall 3/10 because it was edible but I could’ve made this in my kitchen for $2 max. Ridiculous. I do not recommend ordering from here.

Jay Owens

16$ sandwich on regular sliced bread and 8 onion rings for 5$. Extremely overpriced for the portion size

SamJKerr360

RIPOFF SCAM -We paid $45 for 2 sandwiches and two sides that were extra SMALL. The grilled cheese looked like they toasted bread and put 8 slices of grilled cheese on it that weren’t melted and there was a fly in it.Mac and cheese looked burnt and like it was a week old, just a solid cold brick of Mac . My boyfriend wouldn’t even eat his sandwich, the toast was burnt and it smelled awful. Do not eat here

Aratanxa Dave

‘The Usual’ is not worth the price.

Hyun Jae Jung

this is a rip-off. everything is so bad and even lemonade($3) is a can of minute made. They are fake never order from this place.

Claire DeBoer

The worst grilled cheese I have ever had. Maybe one slice of American cheese on white bread and served cold... also the tomato soup was cold and seemingly came straight out of a can.. will never order from here ever again.

Andrew Kozik

It’s called the Grilled cheese society lol I’ve had better sandwiches in a holding cell.

Tray R

Highway robbery. Paid more than $30 for two sandwiches and soup—the soup container was the smallest I’ve ever seen in my life and wasn’t even filled up. It was the equivalent to 1/2 a cup of soup. The grilled cheese used Kraft American cheese slices with low quality store bought bread. It wasn’t even tasty. Food was overall 3/10 because it was edible but I could’ve made this in my kitchen for $2 max. Ridiculous. I do not recommend ordering from here.

Justin Fydelity

16$ sandwich on regular sliced bread and 8 onion rings for 5$. Extremely overpriced for the portion size

Loading...