Grilled Cheese Society

688 Columbus Ave, New York
(833) 698-2483

Recent Reviews

Jessica Lerner

The grilled cheese we ordered was just a cheese sandwich. The tomato soup was just watery tomato paste. Do not order from here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Melissa Hurwitz

I'm sick of Google even suggesting this place. Not real. It's a dumpster.

Natalia N.

They delivered the wrong items. Grilled cheese is that burnt white toast with a cold slice of American cheese in between I am surprised they actually took a wrapper off before sticking it inside the toast.

Dominic G.

$21 for the blue plate special w/ bacon. For 4 slices of cheese two slices of bacon and 1/2 cup of canned tomato soup. Never again GCS!!

Lucy W.

Complete waste of money. For how expensive it is, the quality of food was abysmal. I ordered a grilled cheese and tomato soup and received two pieces of barely toasted bread with a couple slices of unmelted American cheese and underwhelming tomato soup that tasted like it just came from a can. Don't spend your money here.

Milan Thacker

Almost got sent to soul society after eating this horrible foodEverything was barely edible…and how do you even mess up tomato soup lol

John Dery

Sub-par food, forgot most of the order, small portions. Won't order again.

Sophia G.

TRASH SERVICE TRASH. thoroughly disappointed; won't order from here again! POS FAKE A$$ food it was insulting!!! Let me show u!! LOOK AT THIS !!!!!

K R.

Soup was literally abysmal. Stay away. Plenty of other choices for grilled cheese and soup. Grilled cheese was just "fine". It saved the meal, but the soup had to go in the trash.

Hedy P.

Ordered from here tonight and the "shoestring fries" were thick cut and soggy and the "creamy" tomato soup was basically pasta sauce. So bad. And super expensive.

Ashley H.

B******* a** restaurant. Food was cold, the order was incomplete and had to search several different sites just to get a number to talk to someone and he was also no help. This place sucks. Just make grilles cheese at home but I highly recommend against ordering from here.

John L.

This is the worst place you could ever ever ever go. Run away!! You could make better food in a sewer

Cath R.

this is an actual scam. they literally gave me 1/3 cup of tomato soup....i measured...$5 for that? really? its so watery too. gross. can't believe i paid $17 for this and a grilled cheese with 2 pieces of american on white bread with a stale cookie. the cheese isnt even melted!!! way too much packaging! took almost 2 hours to get here! why did you send me 2 sets of silverware lmao thats hilarious. yeah let me share my drop of soup.

Barr C.

Extremely watered-down tomato soup. Grilled cheese was cold and cheese wasn't melted. Bread was dry too. Mac and cheese was worse than Kraft, cheese not mixed in, and the tots were soggy, super mushy, and lacked flavor. Never again. Made a mistake of not looking at all the reviews here before ordering. Burnt cookies and bad sandwiches. Buyer beware. Feels a bit like a scam.

Sara W

This is a "virtual restaurant". The company created a menu and found local restaurants who said they can prepare the items on the menu and then they get delivered through a third party service like grubhub. Problem is that the company has not check whether the partner restaurants actually sell any of the things on the menu so when you order you have no idea what items they will send you. You also have no idea whether the kitchen that prepared the food has a good health code grade. It's like lunchtime Russian roulette. Pass.

Load More