Hamilton Hall Bar & Restaurant

3493 Broadway, New York
(646) 454-9797

Recent Reviews

Oleh “Swinemaker”

The best place I've found in NY. Nice selection of draft beers, great service and wonderful atmosphere

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hamilton Burger, Confit Chicken Wings, Burger

Renata R.

Great place!!! We came in for a family function, and I was pleasantly surprised. We live in the area and never stoped in. This is a hidden gem! This place has a nice old school bar, some high top tables and regular tables as well. In the back of the building there is a second smaller bar so this place is great for having a party. The menu has a lot to choose from, portions are generous and food tasted delicious. Valentina was extremely friendly and attentive. We will return to this spot more often.

Chris Maxwell

Mommy needs some alone time.

Ramon Nieves

Happy with service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Reema RAO

Really bad service. We visited the restaurant last week for bfast and the server didn’t even say hi or good morning. I greeted her. We ordered coffees and she brought the coffee but spilled in the saucers and without even saying a word she left. I went to the counter to ask for extra napkins to clean the saucers. The coffees were good though but the food was just okay. Then after finishing our coffees and bfast we ordered cold drinks and all the plates and cutlery stayed on the table until we left. She didn’t even bother to take the empty plates and there was only one more table except us. It was highly disappointing and the overall attitude wasn’t good at all. We felt like she didn’t want to serve us. We paid the bill, gave her the tip and left. I don’t recommend going there if you don’t want to feel bad or disrespected.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

Alexander Juarez

Bad service, they leave people waiting for a long time, very

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nick Felker

I got their meatball soup when I arrived at this Irish pub in the heights on a Sunday night. Musicians started a set of live jazz as I ate. The food was solid and the drinks were good too. I think this place is has a very cozy feel and it right next to the 145th St station.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kyle S.

When you walk in, it's nice inside with a lot of wood and a long full bar to the right. High tops are on the left, with table and booth seating in the back. Service is fine, nothing over the top (I've only been when it wasn't super busy, so idk about peak times). Pretty decent food and the featured cocktails are nice too. The star is the salmon burger (one of the best I've had personally).

Dominick Auciello

We’ve had dinner here several times. Staff is always friendly. Menu is a mix of standard bar fare and some more interesting choices, such as crispy skin salmon over spinach and risotto. There are various vegan and vegetarian options. Full bar and beer selection, including several NA beers. Lighting and ambiance are pleasant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pan Seared Salmon

Rye LlIM

So this place is surprisingly spacious, it has a private rooms section in the back, which will be a great rental space. Decorated really nicely. But the food is a big NO. We got wings and they had the breading on it which it wasn’t my fave. We had a chicken pot pie, which tasted like a chicken soup with a flaky croissant on the side. The 3 bean nacho was great. I wanted to admit to it, which I did, and they had steak, which were burnt. The apple pie was… not good it was pretty presentation. I would just come here for drinks and to watch a game that’s about it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 4

James Carter

Friendly

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Terence P.

Just had a quick drink. Atmosphere wasn't too bad. Was middle of the afternoon, so it was quiet.

Mary Kohl

Whenever I am here for bingo, Payphone is always on my bingo card. Anyways…the service here is awesome and the food is

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michelle C.

This place can be hit or miss. I've gone about 7 times. The first experience was typical of a restaurant but they've fallen off. I have had the same waiter most of the visits but the last time, the person I was with was asking a lot of questions and this made the waiter visibly annoyed. It was a little annoying but hey, that's part of the job right?Next is the food. It's nothing special. I've had the salmon a few times, decent enough. But the burgers have fallen off. I've had the veggie burger and salmon burger before. Both went downhill. Even the oysters had fallen off during my last visit.

Dawn Hadley

I ordered risotto and they gave me rice.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More

Hamilton Hall Bar & Restaurant

3493 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
(646) 454-9797