Harlem Baking Co.

1590 Lexington Ave, New York
(646) 760-7933

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Biscotti Crusted Original Cheesecake
Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Icing

Our Desserts
SPECIAL!!! BISCOTTI CRUST STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE
Yum, yum, yum!!! Our Original Cheesecake topped with a fresh strawberry compote and our one-of-a kind biscotti cookie crust...a summery mélange worth blushing about.
Premium Combo Pack of 6 Assorted Flavors
Choose any combination of 6 flavors of your choice. Jars will be delivered frozen or ready-to-eat for your convenience. Let us know your choice of flavors in the notes.
Deluxe Combo Pack of 12 Assorted Jars
Choose any combination of 12 flavors of your choice. Jars will be delivered frozen or ready-to-eat for your convenience. Let us know your choice of flavors in the notes.
Biscotti Crusted Original Cheesecake
Our famous original cheesecake with an added layer of love: a biscotti cookie crust. A most memorable marriage of 2 unforgettable flavors. This dessert is all natural, small batch and made locally with no preservatives.
Apple Cinnamon Crumble with Vanilla Ice Cream
Sweet and tangy organic apples with a perfect blend of cinnamon and a sugary crumble. Served with a cup of vanilla ice cream. Microwave for 45 sec and serve warm. Our delicious version of apple pie a la mode. All natural, nut free, small batch, no preservatives, handcrafted and made with fresh fruits.
Classic Key Lime Pie
We took the citrusy magic of the Florida keys and squeezed it into a jar! Made with the freshest ingredients, our classic key lime pie is bursting with flavor. Add a dollop of whipped cream for a complete tropical experience. This small batch dessert is all natural, nut free, and made locally with no preservatives.
Creamy Belgian Chocolate Mousse
We didn't invent it, we just perfected it! Semi-sweet Belgian chocolate is whipped to airy perfection before being sprinkled with a generous amount of chocolate shavings. This small-batch dessert is all-natural, gluten-free, nut-free, and made locally with no preservatives.
Molten Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Ice Cream
All the decadence, exhilaration & anticipation of ordering dessert in a restaurant only at home and only 35 seconds away (microwave not included). Made with the finest Belgian chocolate and served with a cup of vanilla ice cream. All natural, nut free, small batch, no preservatives, handcrafted.
Authentic Italian Tiramisu
Our tiramisu is a traditional family recipe made with all the usual suspects: ladyfingers, mascarpone, and espresso. This small-batch dessert is all-natural, nut-free, and made locally with no preservatives.
SPECIAL: Homestyle Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Icing
Our delicious and airy homemade carrot cake topped with a chock-full of creamy cream cheese icing…as good as it possibly gets.

Cannolis and Other Selections
Classic Large Cannoli
Tube-shaped shells of fried dough filled with creamy stuffed ricotta impastata blended with mini chocolate morsels.
2 Mini Classic Cannolis
Tube-shaped mini shells of fried dough filled with creamy stuffed ricotta impastata blended with mini chocolate morsels.
Lloyd's Carrot Cake
From the popular neighborhood bakeshop known for its signature from-scratch carrot cake (no nuts, no fruits).

Coffees
Americano
Cappuccino
Iced Americano
Iced Cappuccino

Italian Sodas
LIMONETTA (lemon Italian soda) Antica Ricetta Siciliana
275 ml. Vintage soda from Sicily made with natural ingredients ideal to sip on its own or with pizza or homemade desserts.
ARANCIA ROSSA (blood orange Italian soda) Antica Ricetta Siciliana
275 ml. Vintage soda from Sicily made with natural ingredients ideal to sip on its own or with pizza or homemade desserts.
MELOGRANO (pomegranate Italian soda) Antica Ricetta Siciliana
275 ml. Vintage soda from Sicily made with natural ingredients ideal to sip on its own or with pizza or homemade desserts.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+50 photos
Photo credit: google
+49 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Ordered the biscotti cheesecake for takeout. The cheesecake was flavorful but wasn’t much in the container and seemed like a high price for such a small amount. I think this may be a dessert better ordered in a larger size and shareable.
May 2024
I have a mixed review because the first time I went here, it was great, but the second time around, not so much. I'll say this: tho, my first time here, the desserts was a bit of what I assume the desserts if any that heaven will be serving. With every bite, I felt all my troubles and worries melting away. So I was surprised that my second time around wasn't as thrilling. It was nowhere near as fascinating and flabbergasting as the first time. I felt ripped off, especially...
February 2024
I have a mixed review because the first time I went here, it was great, but the second time around, not so much. I'll say this: tho, my first time here, the desserts was a bit of what I assume the desserts if any that heaven will be serving. With every bite, I felt all my troubles and worries melting away. So I was surprised that my second time around wasn't as thrilling. It was nowhere near as fascinating and flabbergasting as the first time. I felt ripped off, especially...
February 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Lexington Pizza Parlour - 1590 Lexington Ave
Italian, Pizza, Pet Friendly
Chu Ros Thai - Chu Ros Thai Restaurant, 1590 Lexington Ave
Thai, Asian Fusion, Vegan, Pet Friendly
Plue - 1575 Lexington Ave
Thai, Noodles, Comfort Food, Asian Fusion, Vegan

Harlem Baking Co.

1590 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10029
(646) 760-7933