Hill and Bay

581 2nd Ave, New York
(212) 245-5554

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jennifer Katzoff

Hill and Bay has such attentive staff, great food, and amazing coffee. Highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bodine Berger

Great Staff!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

karen

Comfortable quiet place to have nice lunch with friends with a lot of options on the menu. I would be happy to go back anytime I'm in that neighborhood.

Samantha

Awesome experience, timely service, great food and enough space for larger groups in the back of the restaurant

Nicole Sparacio

Burger is ehhh

But the happy hour is really good. Drinks are cheap and pretty good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

jenny muller

The staff here is incredible! And the happy hour specials are crazy good, especially for this neighborhood.

Douglas Blake

One of my go to spots In the neighborhood. Perfect spot to hit for lunch before a movie. Absolutely love their wraps the chipotle chicken wrap might be my favorite in the city. The French onion soup is also quite good as is the Mac and cheese. So far there hasn’t been anything I wouldn’t recommend. I do wish they had a slightly better beer list but the ones they do have give you plenty of options. As I mentioned it’s a great place to go before a movie and every week they have a new movie themed cocktail.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Taylor

They need Gordon Ramsay for some Kitchen Nightmares remodeling in here. Service is SO slow (they don't check on you or refill drinks), food is simply not good (we got chicken and mahi mahi - under-seasoned, overcooked), there are flies everywhere. The mahi mahi was so bad we ordered a burger instead and it took so long we ended up leaving. One redeeming factor is the manager is really nice.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Robert

Good experience. We had a long table which allowed for good conversation and service and food were very good.

Burak Baytunca

Here is the happy hour menu, thank me later.

tara

A wonderful surprise. The food and service were excellent. The tables are a bit small but great for a nice lunch outing

Jack Long

Food was fine. Decent selection to satisfy my picky son. Bacon was good but had a more smokey flavor than I was expecting. Toast and biscuits were hard.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Elijah Robinson

So looking forward to my meal. Chicken mash and kale. I had it months ago and it was phenomenal. Like a homemade meal. Rather quick and great flavor. Whiskey mules too.
Today I went looking forward to it; empty house and it took me 30mins to get my meal which came out dry. Looks like the chucked an extra piece of chicken on it because I’m certain they forgot about it and the waiter had to expedite it. For $60 not at all worth it. That’s not including tip bc tip comes for good service and good food. I had no guilt not including that for this meal. Hesitant to go back which is unfortunate. I’ll just have to make my own gravy. Everything else it typical, hard to mess up but alas.

Update: as you can see they responded… I never complained about drink prices. I asked if a whiskey mule was on the drink special and then we discussed the good price for Wednesday specials.
So their passive aggressive response is crazy.
I had a watch on my wrist and it took 32 minutes for a plate of chicken and mashed potatoes? Make it make sense. “Made fresh” and came out dry. Again, make it make sense.
Last time I visited my meal came out much quicker.
I will no longer suggest this place as I have in the past. Nor will be going back.

Thought it was a good find. I was wrong.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rob Buttigieg

Absolutely fantastic! Went for lunch (excellent for quality and value) and stayed for a couple more beers :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Selina Lutchman

Absolutely the best burger in town.. great service and good vibe. Nothing more to say. Just love love it. Will definitely visit again.

Loading...