Ortomare Ristorante Pizzeria

Best meal we had in NYC! Nice ambiance, fabulous desserts. The meals were perfectly proportioned and the pasta was amazing!

Fantastic dinner as always. We had the new potato pizza and the gnocchi. Both were delicious. Great, friendly service.

They charged me the wrong tip! I had to call
Them. What is this behaviour I cannot understand how a restaurant can charge an amount different than the one I signed for.

Service: 1

The food is consistently delicious, never disappointing. The staff is warm and welcoming, making every visit enjoyable. Their brick oven pizzas are absolutely outstanding! This is our go-to spot for a cozy, authentic Italian meal that won’t break the bank—perfect for out-of-town guests.

Very nice neighborhood place. The baby fried artichokes are fabulous - i would go there everyday for them if i could. We loved our red pizza with pancetta (big enough for sharing) and the delicious grilled vegetables. The chocolate lava cake was a lovely finishing treat. Wine list is reasonably priced and servers were attentive and amiable.

Vegetarian options: Fried artichokes are the best!

Dietary restrictions: Not that great for vegans b/c most dishes have cheese.

Kid-friendliness: We saw many families with children really enjoying their made-to-order pizzas.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fire Brick Oven, Ortomare

Fantastic meal as always! Ordered the Margharita pizza, penne rosate, endive salad, and meatballs. All were great (pizza and pasta were particularly delicious). Fantastic, friendly and quick service.

We were seated promptly. Food selection was good. All of our food substitutions were accommodated. The food came out hot, was plentiful and very tasty. This is a solid neighborhood restaurant that we have visited many times and always enjoy our meal.

Wonderful dinner as always! Food came out quickly and deliciously. We had the gnocci and the eggplant pizza. We also had two aperol spritzes.

Such a great place to enjoy delicious food and the restaurant Italian atmosphere!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

So welcoming and comforting with great service, food and ambiance. Always look forward to returning with friends.

Gluten free pasta and pizza were okay, a bit more cheese on the margarita would have been appreciated! Three stars because they forgot about our starters and brought the main dishes straight away.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizza and pasta

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Another fantastic meal at Ortomare! We had the penne rosate and the quattro formaggio pizza. We also had a side of sautéed spinach with garlic. I had the strawberry mojito. All were delicious and well made. Service was quick and friendly as always.

Fabulous service, spectacular food. 10/10 recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

we ordered the pizza and beet salad. The salad was great, fresh and the dressing good. The pizza was good but not outstanding

Again, Ortomare didn't disappoint! Best pizza place on the UWS. Always very consistent. Fresh ingredients and quality products. Service is excellent. Very friendly and attentive.