Jeffrey's Grocery

172 Waverly Pl, New York
(646) 398-7630

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Gino Parisi

Hoping to get in touch with management. I ate here about two months ago, had a great meal, but unfortunately a server spilled the non-alcoholic beat cocktail all over me- shirt, shorts, and white shoes. It was quickly cleaned up by the hostess, but I had to ask the server to be reimbursed or to get a gift card or something to make up for the ordeal. She gave me an email address to message to send a receipt of my dry cleaning. I did so, and didn’t get a response nor did I get a response to my follow up. I’ve also sent you messages on Instagram. Hoping to just get this reimbursed, it’s pretty disappointing how the server handled it and that I haven’t gotten reimbursed after it. Otherwise I had really good food and it’s a really cool atmosphere. Happy to take this review down after we get this situated. Let me know if there’s a better email to contact. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

Mackenzie Moore

Oysters were so tasty! Loved the vibe here too.

Robert Marmorstein

My wife took me here for…I forget why lol. This place is incredible. We had the oysters, the smoked whitefish salad, the burger, and the lobster roll. Every item was better than the last. The oysters were fresh and incredible, the smoked whitefish salad slapped, the burger was insanely flavorful, and the lobster roll was so fresh, light, and perfectly seasoned. Garlic bread ruled and the cocktails were also great! Can’t wait to go back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike Davis

Terrible. I stepped in. Told the guy at the bar that I'm waiting for my friend. He asked if I want a cup of water while I wait, regular or sparkling. I said sparkling. He opens a bottle of club soda and pours me a cup. When I left he charged me $9 for the drink! (I thought he was just offering me water like in any other establishment)

Chahat Jain

We had such a great time there! We are vegetarian and there weren’t a lot of options on the menu, however, the staff was so nice and gave us the option to replace meat with veggies! So we had the BEC but with avocado and other veggies and ofcourse, the pancakes! Delicious! We also just posted a reel about it on my food page - @fete_de_food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

jeremy leonard

Love my little spot !! Good food good service and very nice server and bartender

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brent K

Not great guys. Booked a res here a week ago for the pride parade and received an email 6 days before that they “forgot to close their books” and that they are closed to the general public. Now everything is booked up and we are back to square one with a half-hearted apology. Do better y’all.

Tarek Farahat

Excellent food and warm authentic service. We loved the food. Lobster Roll was excellent . We also ordered spaghetti with lobster, as well as some oysters, and both were equally delicious. Service was great and very attentive . The place is dynamic with the bar being the “center of gravity”
Not my first time ..and I would go again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joshua Pacheco

I wish I had taken more photos of the beautiful food, but that’s how good it was! The burrata was to die for and the steak fritters were so tender. Our server (forgive me for spelling) Rodin? Ah! So sweet! Knew everything about the menu and made us feel so comfortable and confident in our meal. Such a great experience and we can’t wait to come back! Thank you for such a delightful experience. Panna cotta was the cherry on top!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Seo Yeon Kim

So yummyyy - i need to go back again!!! the kale caesar salad, lobster roll and shrimp cocktail were all 10!!

Lena Halabi

10 years in nyc and I can safely say this is probably my favorite spot. Delicious bloody Mary’s and cocktails, food and vibe. I love everything about this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vivianne Barretto

Loved this restaurant. The vibe is casual. I had the Croquetes, which were delicious and the Clams, which tasted super fresh. Their Cocktails are pricey but very good. I sat outside but the inside is very cute with a nautical theme. The service is good. It's not cheap but considering the quality of the food, it's reasonable. I would definitely come back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Lisa S Feder-Feitel

We had a really delightful summer birthday dinner—smoked whitefish with bagel chips, a great shared platter of raw oysters, clams, cooked shrimp and crab salad, and a fresh strawberry dessert. Yummy!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Greg Knudsen

Love the food. Getting a table without a reservation can be difficult. One at the bar often works for a walk-in. Staff can be a little involved with interaction with each other, not uncommon in NYC these days, but they are attentive to the diners.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Marissa Taylor

Brunch was really good and fresh. Cocktails feel personally crafted. Tons of outside seating and tables both inside and out can accommodate large groups well

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...