The bouncer hurt a friend of mine really badly and tried to extort money from him
Jamie L
Jeremy's, a swanky cocktail bar in the Upper East Side. The drinks are amazing and beautifully garnished, creating an elevated ambiance and fantastic atmosphere. You should definitely try the tiramisu espresso martini. The drinks are on the pricier side. Highly recommend coming here for a date or a girls night out!
Mere
I was a bit baffled by the review that mentioned this little cocktail lounge having a bouncer, but the imposing gentleman at the door does seem to serve as one. He's also charming, though, and showed us to a cozy little corner booth in the window, albeit after a brief confusion about availability, where we nearly went elsewhere. I'm glad we didn't. The overall atmosphere is upscale, but warm and relaxed, with bar lamps that sort of resemble squashed Christmas baubles, and a mixture of singable, classic songs playing.
The menu has a decent variety of beverages, and im pleased to report both the dry mezcal and chartreuse drink I had (delicious, complex, with a very well-blended note of clove and cinnamon) and the tiramisu martinis were fantastic. They will also land you on your ass, if you're not careful. They're sneaky, but strong as anything.
Kevin Philips
Nice place, make good cocktails and I enjoy the vibe.
Jessica Lew
Dear Jeremy, I had the most disappointing time at your venue on Friday night. I arrived and the new sandy-haired female bartender halfheartedly asked how I was doing. When I recounted some highlights of my day aloud, she first showed obvious sign of disinterest through her affect and body language, but as I spoke, she further became green with envy when my privileged lifestyle just made it way into the conversation based on what I did during that day - trying out an 1877 vintage Steinway, and waiting for a delivery of my package at Louis Vuitton, etc. I then caught the eye of C**, ordering my favorite BLT sandwich with him only to hear that it, along with the mainstay pigs in a blanket are no longer available, and will soon be replaced with seafood dishes. I used to come to your namesake restaurant for the amazing offerings from your family’s butcher’s shop so artfully folded into a decidedly and deliberately limited food menu, and Christopher’s wonderful mixology. You are driving away your primary demographic: 35-55 year olds who are well - established both in their careers and lifestyles, and we were excited to support Schaller & Weber, and your family, in an originally tasteful cocktail lounge that exuded an opulent place for us to share great ideas. You are quickly losing us.
Jennifer Kennedy
This is my go to neighborhood spot when I’m craving a well made craft cocktail and I want to enjoy great vibes. I always end up talking to people, and the staff are extremely nice. The only caveat is it can get busy bc it’s on the smaller side. I highly recommend stopping by and checking Jeremy’s out
Zach Rosen
I used to like this place. The manager made insane assumptions about me and ruined me and seven of my other friends’ night. I would avoid.
jalyn gould
From the moment we walked in I just loved this place. Not only is the ambience amazing, but the staff make you feel right at home. Monica, Carmine, Kenny, and Marta - they were absolutely exceptional, attentive, and super friendly. We also had the charcuterie board and fries and I would highly recommend both. We’ll definitely be back! We love Jeremy’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nick Napolitano
Superb experience. The staff consisting of Monica, Carmine, Marta, and Kenny were exceptional in accommodating our party and satisfying our every need. I never wrote reviews unless someone pisses me off, but this experience is worth it.
Spencer Winston
Beware of This Establishment
I feel compelled to share my experience at this bar, as it seems to be a pattern of mistreatment that cannot be ignored. A month ago, I visited and was shocked by how poorly I was treated. The atmosphere was cold and unwelcoming, and I found myself doubting the quality of the drinks being served—who could trust a place that treats customers so poorly?
What’s even more concerning is the way they handle their staff. I learned that they fired an employee after he was involved in a car accident and couldn’t come to work. This speaks volumes about the owners’ character and their lack of empathy. It’s not just the customers who are affected; the employees are clearly at risk as well.
This bar has a reputation for mistreating anyone who doesn’t fit their narrow criteria. I encourage potential patrons to take these negative reviews seriously. There are plenty of other establishments that value their customers and employees—support those instead. Let's not let this place continue its harmful practices unchecked.
Last night approached Jeremy’s, which was open - the door was unlocked, music was playing, and the bar was fully stocked. No sign whatsoever of them closing. However, within seconds of stepping inside, we were accosted by a bouncer who physically put his hand on my shoulder, forcefully pushing me while repeating "out, out, out" and pointing at the door.
This behavior is not only rude and disrespectful but potentially illegal. There was absolutely no need for physical contact. A simple "We're closing soon, sorry about that" would have sufficed - if indeed that was the case. We still don’t understand why we were shoved outside with no explanation other than “out”.
The contrast between the completely white clientele allowed inside and the treatment we received from that bouncer raises questions about racial profiling. While I hesitate to throw around accusations of racism, it's hard to ignore such blatant discrimination.
Avoid if you want to avoid being shoved around by a silly bouncer. There are plenty of other establishments in the area that know how to treat their customers with respect.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Weronika W
I highly recommend this place, especially the service - delicious drinks and a very professional Mrs. Marta, the security guard is also very nice
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
XDep
The atmosphere is like soooo good and the service is like the best i was served by Marta and Monica.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ishani Amin
Love the vibe of this place!! Great for a date night or a girls night. Good cocktails. I didn’t get food but the small bites looked really tasty. Happy this place is in UES!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Joe Strain
Kenny is the man - very great bartender, lots of great banter. Fantastic Negroni and amazing fries - will be going again. $14 happy hour
The bouncer hurt a friend of mine really badly and tried to extort money from him
Jeremy's, a swanky cocktail bar in the Upper East Side. The drinks are amazing and beautifully garnished, creating an elevated ambiance and fantastic atmosphere. You should definitely try the tiramisu espresso martini. The drinks are on the pricier side. Highly recommend coming here for a date or a girls night out!
I was a bit baffled by the review that mentioned this little cocktail lounge having a bouncer, but the imposing gentleman at the door does seem to serve as one. He's also charming, though, and showed us to a cozy little corner booth in the window, albeit after a brief confusion about availability, where we nearly went elsewhere. I'm glad we didn't. The overall atmosphere is upscale, but warm and relaxed, with bar lamps that sort of resemble squashed Christmas baubles, and a mixture of singable, classic songs playing.
The menu has a decent variety of beverages, and im pleased to report both the dry mezcal and chartreuse drink I had (delicious, complex, with a very well-blended note of clove and cinnamon) and the tiramisu martinis were fantastic. They will also land you on your ass, if you're not careful. They're sneaky, but strong as anything.
Nice place, make good cocktails and I enjoy the vibe.
Dear Jeremy, I had the most disappointing time at your venue on Friday night. I arrived and the new sandy-haired female bartender halfheartedly asked how I was doing. When I recounted some highlights of my day aloud, she first showed obvious sign of disinterest through her affect and body language, but as I spoke, she further became green with envy when my privileged lifestyle just made it way into the conversation based on what I did during that day - trying out an 1877 vintage Steinway, and waiting for a delivery of my package at Louis Vuitton, etc. I then caught the eye of C**, ordering my favorite BLT sandwich with him only to hear that it, along with the mainstay pigs in a blanket are no longer available, and will soon be replaced with seafood dishes. I used to come to your namesake restaurant for the amazing offerings from your family’s butcher’s shop so artfully folded into a decidedly and deliberately limited food menu, and Christopher’s wonderful mixology. You are driving away your primary demographic: 35-55 year olds who are well - established both in their careers and lifestyles, and we were excited to support Schaller & Weber, and your family, in an originally tasteful cocktail lounge that exuded an opulent place for us to share great ideas. You are quickly losing us.
This is my go to neighborhood spot when I’m craving a well made craft cocktail and I want to enjoy great vibes. I always end up talking to people, and the staff are extremely nice. The only caveat is it can get busy bc it’s on the smaller side. I highly recommend stopping by and checking Jeremy’s out
I used to like this place. The manager made insane assumptions about me and ruined me and seven of my other friends’ night. I would avoid.
From the moment we walked in I just loved this place. Not only is the ambience amazing, but the staff make you feel right at home. Monica, Carmine, Kenny, and Marta - they were absolutely exceptional, attentive, and super friendly. We also had the charcuterie board and fries and I would highly recommend both. We’ll definitely be back! We love Jeremy’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Superb experience. The staff consisting of Monica, Carmine, Marta, and Kenny were exceptional in accommodating our party and satisfying our every need. I never wrote reviews unless someone pisses me off, but this experience is worth it.
Beware of This Establishment
I feel compelled to share my experience at this bar, as it seems to be a pattern of mistreatment that cannot be ignored. A month ago, I visited and was shocked by how poorly I was treated. The atmosphere was cold and unwelcoming, and I found myself doubting the quality of the drinks being served—who could trust a place that treats customers so poorly?
What’s even more concerning is the way they handle their staff. I learned that they fired an employee after he was involved in a car accident and couldn’t come to work. This speaks volumes about the owners’ character and their lack of empathy. It’s not just the customers who are affected; the employees are clearly at risk as well.
This bar has a reputation for mistreating anyone who doesn’t fit their narrow criteria. I encourage potential patrons to take these negative reviews seriously. There are plenty of other establishments that value their customers and employees—support those instead. Let's not let this place continue its harmful practices unchecked.
Restaurantji Recommends
Last night approached Jeremy’s, which was open - the door was unlocked, music was playing, and the bar was fully stocked. No sign whatsoever of them closing. However, within seconds of stepping inside, we were accosted by a bouncer who physically put his hand on my shoulder, forcefully pushing me while repeating "out, out, out" and pointing at the door.
This behavior is not only rude and disrespectful but potentially illegal. There was absolutely no need for physical contact. A simple "We're closing soon, sorry about that" would have sufficed - if indeed that was the case. We still don’t understand why we were shoved outside with no explanation other than “out”.
The contrast between the completely white clientele allowed inside and the treatment we received from that bouncer raises questions about racial profiling. While I hesitate to throw around accusations of racism, it's hard to ignore such blatant discrimination.
Avoid if you want to avoid being shoved around by a silly bouncer. There are plenty of other establishments in the area that know how to treat their customers with respect.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
I highly recommend this place, especially the service - delicious drinks and a very professional Mrs. Marta, the security guard is also very nice
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The atmosphere is like soooo good and the service is like the best i was served by Marta and Monica.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Love the vibe of this place!! Great for a date night or a girls night. Good cocktails. I didn’t get food but the small bites looked really tasty. Happy this place is in UES!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Kenny is the man - very great bartender, lots of great banter. Fantastic Negroni and amazing fries - will be going again. $14 happy hour
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Extra Crispy Fries
Loading...