Tucked away in the bustling heart of NYC’s Financial District, Joseph’s Italian Restaurant offers a pre-fix dinner option within a setting that exudes comfort and a welcoming atmosphere. Its proximity to the lively Stone Street and the renowned Harry’s Steakhouse adds to its allure as a dining destination in FiDi. The interior ambiance strikes the right note for a pleasant dining experience, offering a respite from the urban rush.My decision to dine at Joseph’s was influenced by the promise of a serene environment paired with the convenience of its location. However, while the setting met expectations, certain aspects of the service and culinary experience left room for improvement.The service was adequate up until the conclusion of our meal, when the attentiveness of our server notably diminished. The prolonged wait to request our check, seemingly forgotten after our table was cleared, detracted from the overall dining experience. Furthermore, the presentation of my leftovers in a simple plastic ‘Thank You’ bag, placed unceremoniously on the table before dessert was even served, lacked the finesse one might expect from an establishment of Joseph’s caliber.Culinary-wise, the dishes were satisfactory, yet unremarkable. The steak, requested medium, leaned towards medium-rare, verging on rare at its core. Additionally, a specific request to substitute the mushroom sauce due to allergies resulted in a plain, sauceless steak, rather than an alternative concoction from the chef. This oversight was disappointing and contributed to the overall oddity of the meal.The dessert course brought its own set of mixed feelings. While the tiramisu I received was enjoyable, the portion size compared to my friend’s—visibly about 20% larger—left me feeling somewhat overlooked. Whether my slice was unusually small or my friend’s was generously oversized, it introduced a sense of inconsistency that marred the end of our meal.The value proposition of dining at Joseph’s Italian Restaurant is debatable. While the location is undoubtedly prime, nestled within the FiDi area and surrounded by ample dining alternatives, the culinary and service missteps suggest that there’s room for refinement.In conclusion, Joseph’s Italian Restaurant earns a solid three stars from me. It stands as a nice spot in the Financial District with potential for greatness, yet the inconsistencies in service, culinary execution, and the dessert disparity suggest that there is yet some way to go in fully realizing its promise.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Leslie
Can’t believe this was my first time eating here, living in NYC 13 years. Everything was outstanding— Gnocchi, branzino, calamari, upside down cake. Superb!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
syed haider Abbas
Amazing food , one of the best steak in the city…
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dawn Romero
Had a nice time!
Adam
Had an absolutely wonderful Valentine's day dinner with my family yesterday. Food service and ambiance all top tier !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Frank Clark
My recent visit to Italian Restaurant Joseph was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment my friends and I stepped through the door, we were enveloped in an ambiance of warmth and sophistication.Upon being seated, we were promptly greeted by our waiter, Henor, whose professionalism and attentiveness set the tone for the evening. His recommendation particularly the Doversole Special, proved to be outstanding choices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sophia L.
My new favorite spot for upscale and classic northern Italian cuisine. The food was delish, and the ambiance was even better. I was seated near a cozy fireplace and it was just the perfect dinner. The service was also super attentive, and we were recommended the perfect dishes for our meal. Can't wait to come back again!
Kelli Cackler
Food was delicious. Service was horrible. We had to finally go to hostess and ask for our bill after we had sat there for 10 minutes after they emptied our table. The manager brought 2 shots of tequila as an apology (which we did not want) but at least he made an effort.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Lisa1972
I recently hosted a business lunch for 10 people at Joseph's and it was perfect. The restaurant was clean and beautiful, the ambiance was perfect, the service was outstanding and the food was superb. Also to note that I am vegan (the rest of my party is not) and it was so easy for them to accommodate my dietary restriction with food that was amazing, beautiful, and so tasty. I will would recommend Joseph's to anyone looking for an outstanding experience.
Andrea Caruso
Original American italian restaurant. Flacors are not that distinct between dishes. Recommend the chicken scarpiello.Trending elegant bur being underground is a disadvantage for the atmosphere.Attentive seevxie and friendly staff.
The restaurant was one place who wants to have traditional Italian cuisine. I was confused between two dishes and Maria helped me choosee the right one. Enjoed my Lunch here. Awesome atmosphere to have a great time with some wine and of course don’t forget their tiramisu ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tiramisu
HanxiongW
A popular dining place for weekdays, the vibe is quite old-fashioned and formal. The food is good, but I wouldn't say it's outstanding base on price. Service is very great and professional.
This is not an Italian restaurant. Friday evening it was empty which should signaled that something is wrong. The order was mixed up, food was a disaster. Chef is not Italian. Would never ever visit it again.
MaryL
A memorably good dinner! The setting was lovely, the service excellent, and the food outstanding. The Caesar salad was fresh, and the chicken parm and ‘grandma' pasta with meatballs were out of this world! It was actually hard to choose, as the menu was broad, and many dishes looked wonderful—guess we'll have to return and try them all!
Tucked away in the bustling heart of NYC’s Financial District, Joseph’s Italian Restaurant offers a pre-fix dinner option within a setting that exudes comfort and a welcoming atmosphere. Its proximity to the lively Stone Street and the renowned Harry’s Steakhouse adds to its allure as a dining destination in FiDi. The interior ambiance strikes the right note for a pleasant dining experience, offering a respite from the urban rush.My decision to dine at Joseph’s was influenced by the promise of a serene environment paired with the convenience of its location. However, while the setting met expectations, certain aspects of the service and culinary experience left room for improvement.The service was adequate up until the conclusion of our meal, when the attentiveness of our server notably diminished. The prolonged wait to request our check, seemingly forgotten after our table was cleared, detracted from the overall dining experience. Furthermore, the presentation of my leftovers in a simple plastic ‘Thank You’ bag, placed unceremoniously on the table before dessert was even served, lacked the finesse one might expect from an establishment of Joseph’s caliber.Culinary-wise, the dishes were satisfactory, yet unremarkable. The steak, requested medium, leaned towards medium-rare, verging on rare at its core. Additionally, a specific request to substitute the mushroom sauce due to allergies resulted in a plain, sauceless steak, rather than an alternative concoction from the chef. This oversight was disappointing and contributed to the overall oddity of the meal.The dessert course brought its own set of mixed feelings. While the tiramisu I received was enjoyable, the portion size compared to my friend’s—visibly about 20% larger—left me feeling somewhat overlooked. Whether my slice was unusually small or my friend’s was generously oversized, it introduced a sense of inconsistency that marred the end of our meal.The value proposition of dining at Joseph’s Italian Restaurant is debatable. While the location is undoubtedly prime, nestled within the FiDi area and surrounded by ample dining alternatives, the culinary and service missteps suggest that there’s room for refinement.In conclusion, Joseph’s Italian Restaurant earns a solid three stars from me. It stands as a nice spot in the Financial District with potential for greatness, yet the inconsistencies in service, culinary execution, and the dessert disparity suggest that there is yet some way to go in fully realizing its promise.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Can’t believe this was my first time eating here, living in NYC 13 years. Everything was outstanding— Gnocchi, branzino, calamari, upside down cake. Superb!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food , one of the best steak in the city…
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a nice time!
Had an absolutely wonderful Valentine's day dinner with my family yesterday. Food service and ambiance all top tier !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My recent visit to Italian Restaurant Joseph was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment my friends and I stepped through the door, we were enveloped in an ambiance of warmth and sophistication.Upon being seated, we were promptly greeted by our waiter, Henor, whose professionalism and attentiveness set the tone for the evening. His recommendation particularly the Doversole Special, proved to be outstanding choices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My new favorite spot for upscale and classic northern Italian cuisine. The food was delish, and the ambiance was even better. I was seated near a cozy fireplace and it was just the perfect dinner. The service was also super attentive, and we were recommended the perfect dishes for our meal. Can't wait to come back again!
Food was delicious. Service was horrible. We had to finally go to hostess and ask for our bill after we had sat there for 10 minutes after they emptied our table. The manager brought 2 shots of tequila as an apology (which we did not want) but at least he made an effort.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
I recently hosted a business lunch for 10 people at Joseph's and it was perfect. The restaurant was clean and beautiful, the ambiance was perfect, the service was outstanding and the food was superb. Also to note that I am vegan (the rest of my party is not) and it was so easy for them to accommodate my dietary restriction with food that was amazing, beautiful, and so tasty. I will would recommend Joseph's to anyone looking for an outstanding experience.
Original American italian restaurant. Flacors are not that distinct between dishes. Recommend the chicken scarpiello.Trending elegant bur being underground is a disadvantage for the atmosphere.Attentive seevxie and friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
The restaurant was one place who wants to have traditional Italian cuisine. I was confused between two dishes and Maria helped me choosee the right one. Enjoed my Lunch here. Awesome atmosphere to have a great time with some wine and of course don’t forget their tiramisu ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tiramisu
A popular dining place for weekdays, the vibe is quite old-fashioned and formal. The food is good, but I wouldn't say it's outstanding base on price. Service is very great and professional.
This is not an Italian restaurant. Friday evening it was empty which should signaled that something is wrong. The order was mixed up, food was a disaster. Chef is not Italian. Would never ever visit it again.
A memorably good dinner! The setting was lovely, the service excellent, and the food outstanding. The Caesar salad was fresh, and the chicken parm and ‘grandma' pasta with meatballs were out of this world! It was actually hard to choose, as the menu was broad, and many dishes looked wonderful—guess we'll have to return and try them all!
Top notch Italian in NYC