My son comes here all the time! I just experienced it today for the first time and the Penne al La Vodka is amazing! I also had (being greedy) Chicken and Tomato was slamming! The slices are super big and the owner was super sweet! Plus they are really nice to the HS kids. Support this place!!
Tracy Willacey
Great pizza and the owner is super nice to high school students
J.A. Wilson
Perfect pizza place for tourists visiting battery park. Everything in the vicinity screams New York, and it's a quiet area, too, compared to the hustle and bustle scene of the financial district. The taste of the pizza was above and beyond, better than any pizza I could buy in my hometown.
Janet Rodriguez
Amazing LARGE slices! My favorite weekly lunch for my office day!
John Allie
Justinos Pizzeria is everything you want in a classic NYC slice shop—quick, affordable, and seriously delicious. After a night out on Stone Street, this place hit the spot perfectly. The service was fast, the staff was friendly, and the pizza? Fantastic. I grabbed two slices for just $9 and was genuinely impressed by the quality and flavor. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Justinos is a solid go-to for a late-night bite or casual lunch. Will definitely be back!
Mister Anderson
Good afternoon, I just want to say something I don't like about your employee Angelo. He touches the pizza without wearing gloves and touches the money. He smokes a lot. Last time I told him not to touch the mixed slices of mushrooms and he changed it with a very bad attitude. I will not return to this pizzeria.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Gibran Mancus
Justino’s pizza is a proper New York slice. The crust cracks when folded and holds its shape all the way to the top. Delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Portillo
(Edited) Five stars for the history of this Stone Street institution, 3 stars for the pizza, 1 star for the fact that it now closes before 9pm on a Thursday night. There’s literally a row of bars next door. Owners, we know times are hard and we appreciate what you’ve given, but if this place can’t serve our FiDi community like it used to, it may be time to pass the reins to a new generation of ownership. I’ll happily come back and edit this review when that happens.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
Yuliana Medina
Pizza doesn’t taste very good. The sauce and cheese do not go well together. I guess for the price it’s ok 3.44… I rather pay 4.50 for a slice in the Bronx.
This is exactly what we were looking for. A proper New York pizza slice from a cool little pizzeria not far from Wall St/Pier 11 and The Battery. Me and my two kids felt welcomed and were looked after patiently whilst we made our choices with help from the server. There’s a little seating area outside which was nice but this place is all about the pizza…amazing! We had a pepperoni and sausage slice, a buffalo chicken slice, and a chicken parmigiana slice all were equally delicious with a great crunch and texture. They do other dishes on the menu which I can’t comment on but if the pizza is anything to go by then I highly recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Animesh Gosavi
First time in new york, i was excited about pizza slices, i tried many different location. But this was the best location where I had the tastiest pizza, and the customer service was excellent compared to all other pizza restaurants which I had. More than 5 stars this restaurant deserves.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Василиса Микулишна
I really enjoyed this place twice!)) and will come back again. Both of them I get a mushroom slice and it was wonderful!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
S VENKATACHALAPATHY
Looking for a quick tasty bite near stone street, don’t miss this place. Mouthwatering pizzas by slize.
The owner was very nice!
My son comes here all the time! I just experienced it today for the first time and the Penne al La Vodka is amazing! I also had (being greedy) Chicken and Tomato was slamming! The slices are super big and the owner was super sweet! Plus they are really nice to the HS kids. Support this place!!
Great pizza and the owner is super nice to high school students
Perfect pizza place for tourists visiting battery park. Everything in the vicinity screams New York, and it's a quiet area, too, compared to the hustle and bustle scene of the financial district. The taste of the pizza was above and beyond, better than any pizza I could buy in my hometown.
Amazing LARGE slices! My favorite weekly lunch for my office day!
Justinos Pizzeria is everything you want in a classic NYC slice shop—quick, affordable, and seriously delicious. After a night out on Stone Street, this place hit the spot perfectly. The service was fast, the staff was friendly, and the pizza? Fantastic. I grabbed two slices for just $9 and was genuinely impressed by the quality and flavor. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Justinos is a solid go-to for a late-night bite or casual lunch. Will definitely be back!
Good afternoon, I just want to say something I don't like about your employee Angelo. He touches the pizza without wearing gloves and touches the money. He smokes a lot. Last time I told him not to touch the mixed slices of mushrooms and he changed it with a very bad attitude. I will not return to this pizzeria.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Justino’s pizza is a proper New York slice. The crust cracks when folded and holds its shape all the way to the top. Delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
(Edited) Five stars for the history of this Stone Street institution, 3 stars for the pizza, 1 star for the fact that it now closes before 9pm on a Thursday night. There’s literally a row of bars next door. Owners, we know times are hard and we appreciate what you’ve given, but if this place can’t serve our FiDi community like it used to, it may be time to pass the reins to a new generation of ownership. I’ll happily come back and edit this review when that happens.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
Pizza doesn’t taste very good. The sauce and cheese do not go well together. I guess for the price it’s ok 3.44… I rather pay 4.50 for a slice in the Bronx.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
This is exactly what we were looking for. A proper New York pizza slice from a cool little pizzeria not far from Wall St/Pier 11 and The Battery.
Me and my two kids felt welcomed and were looked after patiently whilst we made our choices with help from the server.
There’s a little seating area outside which was nice but this place is all about the pizza…amazing!
We had a pepperoni and sausage slice, a buffalo chicken slice, and a chicken parmigiana slice all were equally delicious with a great crunch and texture.
They do other dishes on the menu which I can’t comment on but if the pizza is anything to go by then I highly recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time in new york, i was excited about pizza slices, i tried many different location.
But this was the best location where I had the tastiest pizza, and the customer service was excellent compared to all other pizza restaurants which I had.
More than 5 stars this restaurant deserves.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I really enjoyed this place twice!)) and will come back again. Both of them I get a mushroom slice and it was wonderful!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Looking for a quick tasty bite near stone street, don’t miss this place. Mouthwatering pizzas by slize.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sauteed Fresh Mushroom Pizza Slice
Friendly fast & GREAT pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...