La Diagonal Agaveria

185 St Nicholas Ave, New York
(212) 418-1220

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Beth Shelburne

Yikes.
Visited this place, which has a great vibe, great music, great decor. Food and drink? Not so much.
Weak and forgettable house margarita. Had to order an extra shot of tequila to balance the amount of triple sec and sweetened lime juice, and it arrived, strangely, in a tiny plastic condiment cup.
They seemed understaffed and overwhelmed. The food was just OK, way overpriced for what we got. We added an order of yuca fries, which we never received, but they were still on the bill. To our waiter's credit, he seemed embarrassed and took it off the final bill when I told him.
It made me sad because I wanted to like it so much.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Kyle Chan-Shue

Food isn’t bad but the portions are horrendous. 2 little pieces of octopus for 20 dollars is insane.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 2

Demetri Yannopoulos

We’ve only had the drinks so far but they’re to die for. Ask for Nelson the bartender!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alessio Santoro

Straight pass. Overpriced and so not worth it. Tastes like camp food.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Vince Hernandez

Have been dining at this place for a long time, and they just launched their new in house drinks. Their drinks specifically the long island iced tea. When I tell you if you wanna feel the buzz, man this is better than buzzballs! Thats some mad strong drinks. I got the steak quesadillas which is my all time favorite!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brendan Spohn

Bad drinks
Bad service
Gorgeous decor
What a shame

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 1

A K

I was very disappointed. I ended up there by accident — the service was poor and the food wasn’t very tasty

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

S. H.

Service was good, food was ok.

Ivan Valigy

I had to wait a very long time for just the guacamole after 30 minutes I didn’t have my drink after 30 minutes. My Shirley temple was average and a little too sparkly like soda but sweeter not balenced or equal. My food came around 10:57 pm but my my family wanted to leave asap so we took it to go and the food tasted mid. I do not think you should go here it is basic and not the best. My sister had to strongly explain everything she said multiple times it was frustrating. We got a discount so if your on a budget come and eat. My trip here was mid and average there is nothing wrong but nothing great.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 2

M. Santana

Unimpressed and Overpriced af. Just go to Tacuba in Hells Kitchen. Better everything.

Heather Swanson Photography (\u0026 Art Director)

Good drinks, good food, good atmosphere. Always like stopping in here. Start is friendly and accommodating.

Empressive Ken

The ambiance was presentable. i ordered the fish tacos highly recommended, plus the 🍹 margaritas are worth your buck!.

Rodney Byke

This has been the most amazing experience, Live music , Great staff, and an Amazing Host Selam. I will always return , the weather didn't stop anyone from coming out.

M. Veronica Sanchez

Came here on Christmas day when other places were closed. Great choice! Great drinks and quality food. I ordered the grilled octopus and it was amazing. This is a dish difficult to get right. It was soft but not overcooked with great seasoning. I recommend this little corner jewel in Harlem.

jae f

For 6 drinks and 2 appetizers, the total came out to be $191.00. Throughout the evening, our server consistently encouraged us to order more items and brought additional food to our table. When I attempted to settle the bill and leave, the server displayed visible dissatisfaction. I felt that the establishment was overly focused on maximizing revenue. I would advise others to explore alternative options. Notably, I was not informed about the specific drinks I was being served, and I had simply requested a basic margarita without any additional ingredients. Fortunately, I decided to leave and avoid any further unnecessary expenses

Loading...