Wow best pizza in town! My wife and I came and had the best experience.
Katrina Humphrey
Great pizza and great customer service. IOrder a pickup from seamless and I couldn’t find the place. The person on the phone was very polite and directed me to the new location on 33rd and 7th Avenue. Thank you ?
Scha Al
Pizza always on point but sutomer service needs some work
Tenisha U.
If you love flavorful sauce, crispy pizza and allot of garlic on your knots this is the place to go! Little Italy Pizza is just what a New York slice should taste like. The place is decent looks wise and the pies are always fresh. Do yourself a favor and visit this pizza heaven.
Patrick Shea
Great crust. A little pricey for just a slice. I would like to see the $1 slice make a comeback.
Paul H.
Great pizza, affordable and with an excellent selection. Staff is very friendly, and there is currently tables set up for outside dining. Convenient food option in midtown Manhattan.
Santos Hayden
We came to this restaurant for a meeting. This restaurant was recommended to us by a friend. Well, we were not disappointed. we were warmly welcomed by the crew and we had a great feeling. The food was just great. We enjoyed every moment and we will visit this place again. Warmly recommended.
Theresa P.
Mediocre at best. Pepperoni Roll and Sicilian White slice very bland / not a lot of flavor.
Alan H.
Pizza here was the best I've ever had. The crust was perfectly cooked and the cheese to sauce ratio was perfect. Definitely recommend coming here. (Got greedy and took a bite before I remembered to take a picture haha)
Their pizza - wow! I normally don't like the crust too much but jeez this stuff is soo good. The crust is PERFECT and it's so crunchy! The cheese tastes very good and fresh.
Adam Stoddard
When hopping off the train at Penn station make the short walk and enjoy a slice of fantastic NY pizza!
Sherrie Pesce
Very casual place to grab a great slice of pizza after fun at Madison Square Garden!
Daniella L.
Honestly one of the best NY pizza places I've been to. Every bite had a crunch. It's absolutely delicious. They have a deal of 2 cheese slices and a soda for 6 bucks which is hard to beat. Worth coming here after you get buzzed at the Rosé museum.
Steven P.
The cashier at Walgreens suggested this place, just across the street. She told me a few times that they had a different crust. Well, she was right. The crust was different - and fantastic! It's a bit thicker by NYC standards, but the bottom is super crispy. Buy it by the slice or grab a whole pie. They warm the slices to order, and they have a variety of choices. We were literally just grabbing a snack, so we had a slice of margherita and a garlic knot. I then went back to the counter for a slice of mushroom and pepperoni. The slices were terrific, flavorful, and the crust - very unique in a good way. The garlic knot was like a mini dinner roll slathered in garlic and butter. The staff was friendly and service quick. It's a smallish place, so count on sharing a table or eat it on the go. Great job Little Italy Pizza!
Best Pizza in the world ❤️
Wow best pizza in town! My wife and I came and had the best experience.
Great pizza and great customer service. IOrder a pickup from seamless and I couldn’t find the place. The person on the phone was very polite and directed me to the new location on 33rd and 7th Avenue. Thank you ?
Pizza always on point but sutomer service needs some work
If you love flavorful sauce, crispy pizza and allot of garlic on your knots this is the place to go! Little Italy Pizza is just what a New York slice should taste like. The place is decent looks wise and the pies are always fresh. Do yourself a favor and visit this pizza heaven.
Great crust. A little pricey for just a slice. I would like to see the $1 slice make a comeback.
Great pizza, affordable and with an excellent selection. Staff is very friendly, and there is currently tables set up for outside dining. Convenient food option in midtown Manhattan.
We came to this restaurant for a meeting. This restaurant was recommended to us by a friend. Well, we were not disappointed. we were warmly welcomed by the crew and we had a great feeling. The food was just great. We enjoyed every moment and we will visit this place again. Warmly recommended.
Mediocre at best. Pepperoni Roll and Sicilian White slice very bland / not a lot of flavor.
Pizza here was the best I've ever had. The crust was perfectly cooked and the cheese to sauce ratio was perfect. Definitely recommend coming here. (Got greedy and took a bite before I remembered to take a picture haha)
Restaurantji Recommends
Their pizza - wow! I normally don't like the crust too much but jeez this stuff is soo good. The crust is PERFECT and it's so crunchy! The cheese tastes very good and fresh.
When hopping off the train at Penn station make the short walk and enjoy a slice of fantastic NY pizza!
Very casual place to grab a great slice of pizza after fun at Madison Square Garden!
Honestly one of the best NY pizza places I've been to. Every bite had a crunch. It's absolutely delicious. They have a deal of 2 cheese slices and a soda for 6 bucks which is hard to beat. Worth coming here after you get buzzed at the Rosé museum.
The cashier at Walgreens suggested this place, just across the street. She told me a few times that they had a different crust. Well, she was right. The crust was different - and fantastic! It's a bit thicker by NYC standards, but the bottom is super crispy. Buy it by the slice or grab a whole pie. They warm the slices to order, and they have a variety of choices. We were literally just grabbing a snack, so we had a slice of margherita and a garlic knot. I then went back to the counter for a slice of mushroom and pepperoni. The slices were terrific, flavorful, and the crust - very unique in a good way. The garlic knot was like a mini dinner roll slathered in garlic and butter. The staff was friendly and service quick. It's a smallish place, so count on sharing a table or eat it on the go. Great job Little Italy Pizza!