Made in New York Pizza

512 7th Ave, New York
(646) 370-6488

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Margherita Pizza and Veggie Pizza

Buffalo Chicken Sicilian Pie

Vegan Gluten Free Pizza

Yo Paulie Grandma Slice

Eggplant Grandma Slice

Spicy Pepperoni Sqaure

Classic Margherita Pie

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

New Margherita Slice

New Margherita Pizza

Photos

+11 photos

+10 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Made in New York Pizza

Recent Reviews

Pizza by the slice in New York??
Yes we can!
I didn't think so...but pizza...is a pizza lady.
Tasty and with good quality ingredients.
If you want pizza... this place will immediately bring to mind the taste of a real pizza... made in Italy.
Ps: we took a simple Margherita... all the other proposals were American style... too much stuff on top.

March 2025

New York is the pizza capital, so you know the standards are high. Stopped by Made in New York Pizza to see if their slice lives up to the hype. Here’s the breakdown for $4+tax per slice.

Would I go back? Maybe. Would I recommend it? If you’re in the area and craving a no-nonsense NY slice, definitely. But in a city with endless options, the search for the perfect slice continues…

March 2025

I had a gluten free pie - the base is the worst gluten free base I have ever had. They were careful about cross contamination. The toppings could not be faulted and were beautiful and fresh.
1/5 - gluten free base, 5/5 toppings, 5/5 service.

Dietary restrictions: Good understanding of cross contamination for gluten free, but the gluten free alternative was almost inedible

December 2024

More Reviews

Restaurants in New York, NY

Made in New York Pizza

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Made in New York Pizza