Amazing New York style pizza!! Try the buffalo chicken slice you won’t regret it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rowan Krishnan
Just get the vodka - strong contender for best slice in NYC.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
JEDIGONK DRONE
Stopped in for a slice of spicy pepperoni.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spicy Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Sally Jones
Got the drunken grandma with pepperoni. I had high hopes and sadly this disappointed. Flavors were good, it was just too dry/not enough sauce.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Vodka Square Pie
James Mcguiness
Music blasting so loud you can’t hear yourself think, trash covering the floor and every single table. Drunk employees behind the counter couldn’t be more rude. Horrible operation, insanely sub par and over priced product. NOT REAL NYC PIZZA avoid at all costs
SV
Gluten free personal pizza is sufficient to feed two adults with an appetite. It is way larger than a plate.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Oliver C.
Biting into this starchy creation was nothing short of a sensory orgasm. I felt the exclamation of fireworks exploding throughout my neurons, I have not felt a joy like this in what feels like ages. My life is so sad now, after the incident with Tony nothing has been the same. The only thing I can look forward to is this warm slice of heaven. I love New York, I could never forget about it (New York accent).
Darkknight Rocks
I recently had the pleasure of dining at this fantastic pizza place, and it was per expectations. The crust was perfectly crispy, providing an ideal base for the flavorful toppings. Each bite was a symphony of tastes, and the generous portions left me completely satisfied. The ambiance was warm and inviting, and the staff displayed exceptional friendliness. This pizza haven has certainly earned its spot as a favorite, and I would definitely return for another delightful experience.We had the mushroom, BBQ chicken, 4 cheese and garlic knots
Solid upside down slice and great sauce and crust …the keys for me. This location better than the one by me on UWS. Would go back anytime I’m in west village. 4 stars great review for me on pizza by the way…I give out 5 sparingly to the legendary spots only.
Had to grab a slice (or two) of pizza here after leaving a tequila pop up not too long ago while strolling by in the neighborhood. Was so hungry and eager to gobble up all those bigger-than-my-face slices of pizza in front of me since the prior event hardly served any bites. This is mostly a grab-to-go instead of a sit-down kind of place but does have several bar height tables and bar stools made out of metal. Some tables can be wobbly and uneven but customers usually don't mind since this place is mostly for quick bites. You get the food, you eat and then you leave. Simple as that. Pretty fast and friendly service from the staff as they pop the pre-made slides into the oven to toast and heat them up. Sorry, mate....no restroom there. They accept cash and/or credit/debit card as forms of payment. Your food will be ready in less than 5 minutes. I think this spot would be a good option as hangover food because they open pretty late until 2am on some nights. As I've mentioned before, these pizza are bigger-than-my-face kind of slices. It would've been fun to see if I could actually hide behind them. But, I didn't want the oil to drip onto my face and become a real grease ball lol. Ambiance wise is pretty cool with a NY History themed collage/wall displaying colorful posters, Broadway playbills, and stickers plus a huge mural with graffiti covering the floor to give off more personality, more style and more creativity to the place. The atmosphere and vibes are stunning for the visuals, reminding me of hip hop culture in a way. The decor makes me feel welcoming since it doesn't just look like your typical/local pizzeria, it actually stands out from the rest solely of that main reason! Now onto the mushroom and sausage slices, they're both bigger (size wise) in comparison to my face of course. I normally don't order two slices but didn't come all the way from Queens either just to eat a plain slice.....that's for sure! Besides, I was super hungry on that day. The sausage slice was still crispy even though I'd already finished 2/3 of it. As for the mushroom, I was slightly disappointed by the texture because it became pretty soggy from having all the mushroom slices spread out on the pizza. Couldn't withstand the hold while being held like a normal slice.....became a messy blob of sogginess and then fell apart altogether in the end.On a side note, I was trying to see what the place was called and didn't know/realize until seeing the huge "Made In New York Pizza" logo from the display window when I was getting ready to leave. I only thought they were just advertising that their pizza is made in NYC lol. Basically, it pretty much didn't hit me until I was actually standing to take pics of the entire storefront. So, I thought that was kinda funny.- My Conclusion:Not the best pizza I've had eaten but certainly not the worst either. Would go back again if I happen to be in the West Village area next time.
Charlie W
Was apparently charged the credit card processing fee despite paying in cash. When I asked the guy at the counter why the processing fee was there he said it was the tax. When I asked why there was a separate charge for credit card processing from the charge for tax, he didn't respond to me and just looked at me. Sleazy practice to take money from your customers like that...Great Sicilian slices though! If you're looking for something of the same quality that's only a few blocks away, I recommend Village Square Pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Charlie Wolther
Was apparently charged the credit card processing fee despite paying in cash. When I asked the guy at the counter why the processing fee was there he said it was the tax. When I asked why there was a separate charge for credit card processing from the charge for tax, he didn't respond to me and just looked at me. Sleazy practice to take money from your customers like that...Great Sicilian slices though! If you're looking for something of the same quality that's only a few blocks away, I recommend Village Square Pizza.
Amazing New York style pizza!! Try the buffalo chicken slice you won’t regret it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just get the vodka - strong contender for best slice in NYC.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in for a slice of spicy pepperoni.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spicy Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Got the drunken grandma with pepperoni. I had high hopes and sadly this disappointed. Flavors were good, it was just too dry/not enough sauce.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Vodka Square Pie
Music blasting so loud you can’t hear yourself think, trash covering the floor and every single table. Drunk employees behind the counter couldn’t be more rude. Horrible operation, insanely sub par and over priced product. NOT REAL NYC PIZZA avoid at all costs
Gluten free personal pizza is sufficient to feed two adults with an appetite. It is way larger than a plate.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Biting into this starchy creation was nothing short of a sensory orgasm. I felt the exclamation of fireworks exploding throughout my neurons, I have not felt a joy like this in what feels like ages. My life is so sad now, after the incident with Tony nothing has been the same. The only thing I can look forward to is this warm slice of heaven. I love New York, I could never forget about it (New York accent).
I recently had the pleasure of dining at this fantastic pizza place, and it was per expectations. The crust was perfectly crispy, providing an ideal base for the flavorful toppings. Each bite was a symphony of tastes, and the generous portions left me completely satisfied. The ambiance was warm and inviting, and the staff displayed exceptional friendliness. This pizza haven has certainly earned its spot as a favorite, and I would definitely return for another delightful experience.We had the mushroom, BBQ chicken, 4 cheese and garlic knots
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken, Mushroom Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Garlic Knots
Place was empty, pizza was good just cold.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Slice of Pizza
Solid upside down slice and great sauce and crust …the keys for me. This location better than the one by me on UWS. Would go back anytime I’m in west village. 4 stars great review for me on pizza by the way…I give out 5 sparingly to the legendary spots only.
Restaurantji Recommends
I got food poisoning from their grandma
Food: 1
Their pizza is great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had to grab a slice (or two) of pizza here after leaving a tequila pop up not too long ago while strolling by in the neighborhood. Was so hungry and eager to gobble up all those bigger-than-my-face slices of pizza in front of me since the prior event hardly served any bites. This is mostly a grab-to-go instead of a sit-down kind of place but does have several bar height tables and bar stools made out of metal. Some tables can be wobbly and uneven but customers usually don't mind since this place is mostly for quick bites. You get the food, you eat and then you leave. Simple as that. Pretty fast and friendly service from the staff as they pop the pre-made slides into the oven to toast and heat them up. Sorry, mate....no restroom there. They accept cash and/or credit/debit card as forms of payment. Your food will be ready in less than 5 minutes. I think this spot would be a good option as hangover food because they open pretty late until 2am on some nights. As I've mentioned before, these pizza are bigger-than-my-face kind of slices. It would've been fun to see if I could actually hide behind them. But, I didn't want the oil to drip onto my face and become a real grease ball lol. Ambiance wise is pretty cool with a NY History themed collage/wall displaying colorful posters, Broadway playbills, and stickers plus a huge mural with graffiti covering the floor to give off more personality, more style and more creativity to the place. The atmosphere and vibes are stunning for the visuals, reminding me of hip hop culture in a way. The decor makes me feel welcoming since it doesn't just look like your typical/local pizzeria, it actually stands out from the rest solely of that main reason! Now onto the mushroom and sausage slices, they're both bigger (size wise) in comparison to my face of course. I normally don't order two slices but didn't come all the way from Queens either just to eat a plain slice.....that's for sure! Besides, I was super hungry on that day. The sausage slice was still crispy even though I'd already finished 2/3 of it. As for the mushroom, I was slightly disappointed by the texture because it became pretty soggy from having all the mushroom slices spread out on the pizza. Couldn't withstand the hold while being held like a normal slice.....became a messy blob of sogginess and then fell apart altogether in the end.On a side note, I was trying to see what the place was called and didn't know/realize until seeing the huge "Made In New York Pizza" logo from the display window when I was getting ready to leave. I only thought they were just advertising that their pizza is made in NYC lol. Basically, it pretty much didn't hit me until I was actually standing to take pics of the entire storefront. So, I thought that was kinda funny.- My Conclusion:Not the best pizza I've had eaten but certainly not the worst either. Would go back again if I happen to be in the West Village area next time.
Was apparently charged the credit card processing fee despite paying in cash. When I asked the guy at the counter why the processing fee was there he said it was the tax. When I asked why there was a separate charge for credit card processing from the charge for tax, he didn't respond to me and just looked at me. Sleazy practice to take money from your customers like that...Great Sicilian slices though! If you're looking for something of the same quality that's only a few blocks away, I recommend Village Square Pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Was apparently charged the credit card processing fee despite paying in cash. When I asked the guy at the counter why the processing fee was there he said it was the tax. When I asked why there was a separate charge for credit card processing from the charge for tax, he didn't respond to me and just looked at me. Sleazy practice to take money from your customers like that...Great Sicilian slices though! If you're looking for something of the same quality that's only a few blocks away, I recommend Village Square Pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1