Made in New York Pizza
271 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(646) 449-8556
Customers' Favorites
Regular Pizza Slice and Buffalo Chicken Slice
Garlic Knots with Marinara
White Grandma Pie
Plain Cheese Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Slice
Spicy Pepperoni
Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Eggplant Parm
Round Pies
Cheese Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano.
Pepperoni Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school large pepperoni.
Margherita Pie
Vodka Pie
Sausage Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school sliced, sweet Italian sausage.
Gluten Free Pie
Buffalo Chicken Pie
BBQ Chicken Pie
Mushroom Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with fresh mushrooms.
Sausage Jalapeno Pie
Sausage Pepperoni Pie
White Spinach Pie
Pepperoni Mushroom Pie
Spinach Mushroom Pie
Sausage Mushroom Pie
Yo Paulie Pie
Street Fair Pie
Square Pies
Spicy Pepperoni Pie
Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano topped with spicy cupping pepperoni.
Grandma Pie
Vodka Square Pie
Upside Down Pie
Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano.
Eggplant Pie
White Pie
Veggie Pie
Classic Sicilian Pie
Sides
5 Garlic Knots w/ Sauce
Chicken Roll
Pepperoni Roll
1 Knot
Cheese Calzone
Sodas
Coca Cola
Diet Coke
Coke Zero
Root Beer
Ginger Ale
Sprite Zero
Sprite
Glass Bottles
Vitamin Water
Seltzer Water
Dr. Pepper
Gold Peak Tea
Fanta
Body Armor
house drinks
Lemonade
Fuze Tea
Monster
Water
Dasani
Smart Water
Poland Spring
Side Sauces
Ranch
Marinara
Mike's Hot Honey
BBQ
Golden Italian
Balsamic
Desserts
Cannolis
NY Cheesecake
Tiramisu
Desserts
Cannolis
NY Cheesecake
Tiramisu
Side Sauces
Ranch
Marinara
Mike's Hot Honey
BBQ
Golden Italian
Balsamic
Round Pies
Cheese Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano.
Pepperoni Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school large pepperoni.
Margherita Pie
Vodka Pie
Sausage Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school sliced, sweet Italian sausage.
Gluten Free Pie
Buffalo Chicken Pie
BBQ Chicken Pie
Mushroom Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with fresh mushrooms.
Sausage Jalapeno Pie
Sausage Pepperoni Pie
White Spinach Pie
Pepperoni Mushroom Pie
Spinach Mushroom Pie
Sausage Mushroom Pie
Yo Paulie Pie
Street Fair Pie
Square Pies
Spicy Pepperoni Pie
Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano topped with spicy cupping pepperoni.
Grandma Pie
Vodka Square Pie
Upside Down Pie
Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano.
Eggplant Pie
White Pie
Veggie Pie
Classic Sicilian Pie
Sides
5 Garlic Knots w/ Sauce
Chicken Roll
Pepperoni Roll
1 Knot
Cheese Calzone
Sodas
Coca Cola
Diet Coke
Coke Zero
Root Beer
Ginger Ale
Sprite Zero
Sprite
Glass Bottles
Vitamin Water
Seltzer Water
Dr. Pepper
Gold Peak Tea
Fanta
Body Armor
house drinks
Lemonade
Fuze Tea
Monster
Water
Dasani
Smart Water
Poland Spring
Side Sauces
Ranch
Marinara
Mike's Hot Honey
BBQ
Golden Italian
Balsamic
Desserts
Cannolis
NY Cheesecake
Tiramisu
Sides
5 Garlic Knots w/ Sauce
Chicken Roll
Pepperoni Roll
1 Knot
Cheese Calzone
Sodas
Coca Cola
Diet Coke
Coke Zero
Root Beer
Ginger Ale
Sprite Zero
Sprite
Glass Bottles
Vitamin Water
Seltzer Water
Dr. Pepper
Gold Peak Tea
Fanta
Body Armor
house drinks
Lemonade
Fuze Tea
Monster
Water
Dasani
Smart Water
Poland Spring
Round Pies
Cheese Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano.
Pepperoni Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school large pepperoni.
Margherita Pie
Vodka Pie
Sausage Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school sliced, sweet Italian sausage.
Gluten Free Pie
Buffalo Chicken Pie
BBQ Chicken Pie
Mushroom Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with fresh mushrooms.
Sausage Jalapeno Pie
Sausage Pepperoni Pie
White Spinach Pie
Pepperoni Mushroom Pie
Spinach Mushroom Pie
Sausage Mushroom Pie
Yo Paulie Pie
Street Fair Pie
Square Pies
Spicy Pepperoni Pie
Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano topped with spicy cupping pepperoni.
Grandma Pie
Vodka Square Pie
Upside Down Pie
Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano.
Eggplant Pie
White Pie
Veggie Pie
Classic Sicilian Pie
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I wanted to like the establishment and the pizza ? served out here however was disappointed by the dough quality and the ingredients used. It is way too greasy and for some margherita pizza you taste the tomato paste that is heavily used. So they don't use good quality dough, cheese or tomatoes. The crust is so so and there is way too much oil that isn't good quality either.
May 2024
I love this place and their pizza is great every single time. However, there's occasionally an older guy there, early on in the day, who handles the pizza with his hands... Yuck.
May 2024
Was looking forward to great pizza with friends. Ordered half pepperoni and half Margarita. 75% was pepperoni and no mozzarella visible on the margarita. Very very disappointing and won't be back.
April 2024
You May Also Like
Simply Noodles - 267 Amsterdam Ave Unit 1
![]()
Noodles, Tapas/Small Plates, Gluten-Free, Vegan, Vegetarian
Chipotle Mexican Grill - 269 Amsterdam Ave
![]()
Mexican, Fast Food