Magnolia Bakery

200 Columbus Ave, New York
(212) 724-8101

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jing Ern

Clean and cozy bakery. The smell of fresh bread is irresistible!

Mikhail Zhebrak

Very good banana pudding

Jesse J Calloway

Banana Pudding. It was fantastic!

Valentina Asprilla

So good

Esteban Quinones

We had an impromptu birthday party for one of my co workers. Check out the birthday cake.

Sol Park

you know. it's magnolia in NY

Ozlem M.

I’ve enjoyed their cupcakes and banana pudding in the past, but my experience today was really disappointing. The red velvet cupcakes tasted like they were made days ago. The texture was dry and dense, and the frosting was bland and flavorless. The banana pudding was okay, but it didn’t taste fresh either. On top of that, the store didn’t even have proper AC in the middle of summer! It was uncomfortably warm inside. I wouldn’t recommend this location based on today’s visit. Not sure if the other branches are better.

Jonathan Scott

Used to be ok. Has gone downhill. Cake today tasted of acetone. Called to let them know and suggest they might want to test it or take it off the shelf but they were dismissive. A few weeks ago the cream cheese frosting didn’t have any sugar in it, so was just cream cheese. Go figure… Oh, and the frosting has always been a bit too sickly sweet. It needs a touch of salt to balance it out, so I usually add that at home.

Mike Bean

this is the third time I came to this place and they don't have any banana pudding or red velvet pudding. today is the last time I try. I came as they open and no pudding. correction they had pudding but that nasty hot chocolate or whatever it's called filled up the refrigerator they tell me to come back in 2 hrs and I came back3 hrs and still nothing. what a waste of time.. glad I still got my money.bet it probably nasty

Patrick Jee

Ordered a birthday cake for my son and cake was dry (compared to the slice I sampled before ordering). The frosting was brittle (cream cheese frosting). To make matters worse they completely failed on the design I meticulously provided for them…location of text wrong, execution of simple design poor, and they misspelled my son’s name. While the manager was understanding and offered me a 25% discount I have yet to see that credited back to me. The worst of it was the icer who didn’t take kindly to the criticism and muttered in passive aggressive fashion. It wasn’t worth my time to argue with her. Someone like that with poor execution skills and equally poor manners shouldn’t work there.

Food: 3

Service: 1

peter

Taste is ordinary

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jose Tavarez

From the first bite to the last… Yum.

Wheelchair accessibility: They have a ramp.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Red Velvet Cupcake

David

Line is far too long. 21 people, and they've been stuck on the first patron for 3-5 minutes

Andre Munhoz

Wonderful sweet

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Federico Policano

Good cupcake , awful customer service. Cashier straight up ignored me for 5 minutes with no one else around, and not even apologized after. There were 4 other available workers and none of them took my order neither. My cappuccino was cold and only filled at half, not the full cup. Basically I asked for a large cappuccino and they gave me less than a regular one. It’s a shame because Magnolia is really good, just not this branch.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Loading...