Make My Cake

409 W 125th St, New York
(212) 932-0833

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Vanilla Butter Happy Birthday Cake
Strawberry Cupcakes
Red Velvet Cupcakes
Red Velvet Cupcake
Chocolate Cupcake
Red Velvet Slice
Sweet Potato Pie
Red Velvet Cake
Chocolate Cake
Key Lime Pie

TRADITIONAL CUPCAKES
TRADITIONAL CUPCAKES - Strawberry Frosted
TRADITIONAL CUPCAKES - Lemon Frosted
TRADITIONAL CUPCAKES - Chocolate Frosted
TRADITIONAL CUPCAKES - Red Velvet
TRADITIONAL CUPCAKES - Chocolate Cream
TRADITIONAL CUPCAKES - Double Chocolate
TRADITIONAL CUPCAKES - Buttercream

SLICE OF CAKE
SLICE OF CAKE - Carrot Cake
SLICE OF CAKE - Red & White
SLICE OF CAKE - Buttercream
SLICE OF CAKE - Chocolate Layer
SLICE OF CAKE - Red Velvet
SLICE OF CAKE - Lemon Frosted
SLICE OF CAKE - Cookie & Cream
SLICE OF CAKE - Strawberry Frosted
SLICE OF CAKE - Chocolate Cream
SLICE OF CAKE - Coconut Pineapple
SLICE OF CAKE - German Chocolate
SLICE OF CAKE - Caramel Frosted
SLICE OF CAKE - Double Chocolate

COBBLER
COBBLER - PEACH
COBBLER - APPLE

PUDDINGS & PARFAITS
BANANA PUDDING
PUDDINGS - Banana Pudding

Cheesecakes
Red Velvet Cheesecake
Sweet Potato Cheesecake
NY Style Cheesecake
Lemon Cheesecake
Cherry Cheesecake

6 inch Pie
Sweet Potato Pie
Key Lime Pie

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: ubereats
+29 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+28 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We went to see a Gospel cerimony and after the function, we went in this little backerty. We get one macchiato and one espresso, they were both good. We also tasted muffin and cheese cake
They were really great, than you
September 2025
Definitely one of the best spots in the city. A Harlem staple, this bakery has some of the most authentic flavors without compromising on quality. It's difficult to scale up home made recipies to maintain the original intent, but they've done it. Also, the staff at this particular locationn are professional and friendly. Sorry to say I can't say that for all bakeries of this type.
August 2025
Today was my first time experiencing, Make My Cake. The staff were friendly and welcoming. I had the chocolate cream cake. It was fresh and moist. I enjoyed every piece of the cake. Thanks so much👏🏾
May 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

I Like It Black - 409 W 125th St
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee, Pet Friendly
iPizzaNY - 357 W 125th St
Pizza, Chicken Wings
Domino's Pizza - 409 W 125th St
Pizza, Chicken Wings, Vegetarian

Make My Cake

409 W 125th St, New York, NY 10027
(212) 932-0833