Make My Cake
409 W 125th St, New York
(212) 932-0833
Customers' Favorites
Vanilla Butter Happy Birthday Cake
Strawberry Cupcakes
Red Velvet Cupcakes
Red Velvet Cupcake
Chocolate Cupcake
Red Velvet Cake
Sweet Potato Pie
Chocolate Cake
Key Lime Pie
Bakery
Menu
Photos
+27 photos
+26 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Today was my first time experiencing, Make My Cake. The staff were friendly and welcoming. I had the chocolate cream cake. It was fresh and moist. I enjoyed every piece of the cake. Thanks so much👏🏾
Stopped by for a quick birthday cake. Needed something small so I went for a box of assorted cheesecakes. The place is super cute with flower decor. I also got a 3 Leche cake that was delicious!! Worth a stop by
MAKE MY CAKE is a dessert oasis in Harlem
Aaliyah gave me the best customer service I’ve EVER experienced!
Friendly engaging & offering wonderful conversation.
Now to the cakes & pies
I got a red velvet cake that was moist & absolutely delicious!
Key lime pie was divine.
There’s a coffee shop next door I LIKE IT BLACK & even though it was closed Aaliyah made me an iced coffee...
Aaliyah gave me the best customer service I’ve EVER experienced!
Friendly engaging & offering wonderful conversation.
Now to the cakes & pies
I got a red velvet cake that was moist & absolutely delicious!
Key lime pie was divine.
There’s a coffee shop next door I LIKE IT BLACK & even though it was closed Aaliyah made me an iced coffee...
You May Also Like
I Like It Black - 409 W 125th St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee, Pet Friendly
Charles Pan-Fried Chicken - 439 W 125th St
![]()
Soul Food, Chicken Shop, Chicken Wings
Rich Aroma - 465 W 125th St
![]()
Chinese